Skip to main content

Garner ?

Garner ?

Despite everything, he's still come close rather often, including at least 2 (maybe more?) cleared off the line. You get the feeling he's sometimes playing it a bit safe with his finishing... not quite putting his foot/head through the ball. Hopefully that's just a confidence thing.
 
I'd keep Garner and invest in a partner or two for him.
As well as the players already on the books?How many "strikers" do you think we can carry?

I'd keep Garner and invest in a partner or two for him.
The only problem is, Grayson has just done that. But not very well unfortunately.
xKMV8.jpg
 
Well that's in the ideal world where we hadn't wasn't the little money we had and loans

Well in the ideal world,where we all know how every signing is going to work out,I don't suppose many poor signings would be made.I don't recall many on here calling the striker signings we made at the time.
 
Well in the ideal world,where we all know how every signing is going to work out,I don't suppose many poor signings would be made.I don't recall many on here calling the striker signings we made at the time.

I did ask fans to stop wetting themselves on the day we signed them both. SG has been found wanting when purchasing strikers other than Beckford...
 
I did ask fans to stop wetting themselves on the day we signed them both. SG has been found wanting when purchasing strikers other than Beckford...

OK but why would you want him to sign another couple then,bearing in mind how poor you think he is in this aspect of recruitment?
 
OK but why would you want him to sign another couple then,bearing in mind how poor you think he is in this aspect of recruitment?

Good point I suppose. Why get him to waste more fees / loans....

Possibly get a new manager to sign them instead....

See how the next few weeks go..
 
I think that Joes confidence is shattered due to the injury to Beckford and the pressure to score is now weighing on his young shoulders. Hugill for all his naievity ( spelling correct ? ) is probably a better partner for joe at this time due to his eagerness. There is no simple answer but for my tuppence I don't like long balls forward which seem to be cleared with ease by six ft four defenders. Makes no sense that tactic.
 
I think that Joes confidence is shattered due to the injury to Beckford and the pressure to score is now weighing on his young shoulders. Hugill for all his naievity ( spelling correct ? ) is probably a better partner for joe at this time due to his eagerness. There is no simple answer but for my tuppence I don't like long balls forward which seem to be cleared with ease by six ft four defenders. Makes no sense that tactic.

He is 27. Age cannot be used as an excuse on this occasion...
 
The way I see it is the trouble for Garner (and the other forwards) is that they are all playing with their backs to goal. That's fine when you have a partner who will play off the shoulder of the last man looking to stretch play or have midfielders looking to run ahead of the striker, both of which give the defenders more to think about. As it is we have neither of those and it becomes so easy for the defence as its straight forward for them - push the forward up the pitch and job done. Until we resolve those aspects I'll reserve judgement of Garner at this level
 
Now that's a different debate to the Joe Garner and striking options thread.... I've discussed on other threads my options and sure a thread will be created again if we have many more nights like last night

It may be a different debate but I asked because you brought the subject up.
 
Back
Top