Garner
Out of his depth? Although he hasn't scored I feel he's looked the most comfortable at this level than our other strikers.
This.
Out of his depth? Although he hasn't scored I feel he's looked the most comfortable at this level than our other strikers.
In what sense has he looked comfortable ?
Falling on the floor constantly doesn't seem that comfortable.
- Joined
- Aug 3, 2010
- Messages
- 2,766
WIBG/Fulwoodwhite is just looking for a bite.
Stop feeding him.
Stop feeding him.
- Joined
- Oct 30, 2011
- Messages
- 2,482
It's a steep learning curve for him. Especially as his perfect striking partner is injured and the rest are no great shakes.
I remember Kurt nogan having a similar spell and getting dogs abuse. He turned it around. Maybe garner will get a bit of luck and the confidence will return.
I remember Kurt nogan having a similar spell and getting dogs abuse. He turned it around. Maybe garner will get a bit of luck and the confidence will return.
- Joined
- Apr 10, 2008
- Messages
- 3,220
Our willingness to attack and to try and kill teams off is really helping Joe find the net!! Give the lad a chance eh?
- Joined
- Jun 2, 2015
- Messages
- 18,711
Looks a bit out of his depth at the moment.
However, it's still harsh to judge the strikers yet, as clear cut chances are very rarely created.
We need to add some pace and creativity in the next transfer window, then we can see how the strikers get on.
But isn't the sign of a good striker one who can create his own chances out of nothing, when others can't provide him with any? If so, this suggests Joe isn't quite good enough. Hope I am wrong but, blimey, it's been a long old drought now for Joe.
OP
fulwood white
Thread starter
- Joined
- Feb 7, 2010
- Messages
- 290
ThisBut isn't the sign of a good striker one who can create his own chances out of nothing, when others can't provide him with any? If so, this suggests Joe isn't quite good enough. Hope I am wrong but, blimey, it's been a long old drought now for Joe.
But isn't the sign of a good striker one who can create his own chances out of nothing, when others can't provide him with any? If so, this suggests Joe isn't quite good enough. Hope I am wrong but, blimey, it's been a long old drought now for Joe.
I don't know many strikers in the world who can create goal scoring opportunities when the ball is pinged at him, usually a foot over his head, bring it down and then score. Odd examples yes but it's not ideal
The greatest strikers in the world wouldn't score with these tactics!But isn't the sign of a good striker one who can create his own chances out of nothing, when others can't provide him with any? If so, this suggests Joe isn't quite good enough. Hope I am wrong but, blimey, it's been a long old drought now for Joe.
- Joined
- Jun 2, 2015
- Messages
- 18,711
Yes, point taken, but my point is this......PNE do not create many chances, so a decent player would resort to sniffing out and creating his own. Garner can't do this at this level.I don't know many strikers in the world who can create goal scoring opportunities when the ball is pinged at him, usually a foot over his head, bring it down and then score. Odd examples yes but it's not ideal
We create zilch chances yet Daniel Johnson plays in the same team and has managed to score six or seven, mainly by creating his own chances. Now he IS good enough for the championship.
I think that best summarises the difference between a player being good enough and a player not being good enough.
- Joined
- Jun 2, 2015
- Messages
- 18,711
The greatest strikers in the world wouldn't score with these tactics!
But those same tactics haven't stopped Daniel Johnson scoring six and Gallagher three so far. Now they ARE both championship standard players. Capable of creating something themselves, which is what Joe often did last season, but against poorer defenders.
Gallagher and Johnson play in midfield do get different opportunities, clutching at straws there!But those same tactics haven't stopped Daniel Johnson scoring six and Gallagher three so far. Now they ARE both championship standard players. Capable of creating something themselves, which is what Joe often did last season, but against poorer defenders.
Yes, point taken, but my point is this......PNE do not create many chances, so a decent player would resort to sniffing out and creating his own. Garner can't do this at this level.
We create zilch chances yet Daniel Johnson plays in the same team and has managed to score six or seven, mainly by creating his own chances. Now he IS good enough for the championship.
I think that best summarises the difference between a player being good enough and a player not being good enough.
Garner gets marked by one or two centre halves. Johnson doesn't get marked and is able to pick up the 2nd ball at the edge of the box. It's a bit different to be honest and Garner has probably helped Johnson more than Johnson has helped Garner in creating space and opportunities.
- Joined
- Jun 2, 2015
- Messages
- 18,711
Gallagher and Johnson play in midfield do get different opportunities, clutching at straws there!
DIFFERENT opportunities, Nobber, maybe, but not MORE opportunities. Isn't it true that Joe has had more shots than anyone in the division so far?
But isn't the sign of a good striker one who can create his own chances out of nothing, when others can't provide him with any? If so, this suggests Joe isn't quite good enough. Hope I am wrong but, blimey, it's been a long old drought now for Joe.
Good point, but still, it's very hard to conjure up anything off constant long balls.
That said, his record is poor in the Championship and I feel that we're now beginning to see why.
I don't know many strikers in the world who can create goal scoring opportunities when the ball is pinged at him, usually a foot over his head, bring it down and then score. Odd examples yes but it's not ideal
The greatest strikers in the world wouldn't score with these tactics!
He did against Rotherham for THAT goal.
Yes, I am taking the piss.
The greatest strikers in the world wouldn't score with these tactics!
You're more boring then grayson! Cheer up
Garner must have been too good for Div 1 because he was the top goal scorer without playing in all the matches. Doyle scored frequently for Chesterfield in this division and May scored many in the Scottish Premier league. The Championship is of course a step up and we have had to alter our tactics and style of play to avoid being relegated. We have been using 3 centerbacks and wing backs, which is a much more defensive formation. We have hardly played any out and out wingers and our front 2 have had to go wide to pick up the ball. Joe Garner has led the line fantastically well in my opinion. He isn't the tallest and yet manages to compete for the ball with great success. He hasn't scored yet but has hit the bar,post and keeper and is just short of luck. Grayson's searching for the right combination with him and none of Doyle,Keane, Hugill and May have been able to replicate Beckford's partnership.
Pet Shop Boy - have Garner and May actually played together?
Genuine question because I don't know.
Genuine question because I don't know.