The key factor here is that Grayson is playing all the attacking players you've mentioned, is he not?!
He is playing Reach/Johnson/Gallagher & Browne (who I see as quite attack minded also). What defensive players do we have in our recent starting line ups apart from the back 4/5. Grayson is even playing Reach (an attack minded player as a wing back on occassion due to injuries).
What would you do differently to what Grayson does - genuine question. Our starting 11 is a difficult one for achieving a 'balance' that is obvious. It's not as simple as just moving Gallagher into a more forward position as where does Johnson/Reach/Browne then go? Apparently Gallagher was totally suited playing deep against Charlton where we won 0-3 so that formation seemed to reap goals did it not?
Looking at 2 ends of the spectrum to be defensively solid (which we certainly are at the moment) and to also have a constant attacking threat would mean we were top if the league - realistically do you think this team/squad is capable of that? On the comparative budget we work on?
Watch that video back of Garner's goals - how many came from sideline crosses from Gallagher? Gallagher is our talisman but he is not a winger style crosser of the ball, he's superb at still ball deliveries & spotting a long ball opportunity - a main reason our strikers aren't turning these into goalscoring chances is down to the quality of defending in this league. The majority of teams have strong/solid CB's in this division compared to League 1.
A lot of people attribute our lack of goalscoring/chances to Grayson tactics & telling the players to defend for the majority of games - how do we know this to be true?
Grayson isn't a particularly animated manager, but he seems to get very frustrated & animated when the players do seem to sit back & try to absorb pressure.
May didn't get on at QPR & as much as I'd like to see him get the opportunity for us, Keane was a wiser move with his pace and ball retention/skill. Putting a striker on & the pressure we applied late on suggests to me that Grayson was going for the win & we were unlucky not to get it at the end. We certainly had better chancs than QPR with 2 cleared off the line.
You make some good points. However, it's no good having those creative players in the team if all we're going to do is play long balls up to a sole striker, or on occasion one of two strikers. That for me is the crux of my issue with the tactics and on Saturday (until around 80 minutes) we did it on virtually every occasion we had the ball. There were several times when we could have played it into feet in the midfield very easily but instead chose a pass to the keeper or to Huntington to play it long.
Of course being more expansive leaves us more open defensively but what's the better option - a short, easy ball to Browne to get us moving forward or a short, easy ball to Pickford to launch it to Garner who even if he wins the header can't do anything with it because of the lack of support? There was somebody on here the other day (white123 or something) incredibly trying to tell me it wasn't about entertainment and entertainment isn't important. Whilst results are obviously important, if we don't entertain the crowds won't come and next season we'll lose a lot of season ticket holders.