Skip to main content

Ginger Forward

Ginger Forward

Can't fault his work rate. If Grayson sees something in him then I trust his judgement. If he does sign I hope he scores quite a few and proves the doubters wrong.
 
Grayson likes Doyle.

Doyle wants to move here.

Can see it happening but can't see us wanting pay a big fee so could go on for a while.
Cardff must be kicks themselves turning down £800k from us in August. There are parts of his game i do like. Looked more of a goal threat than JG in recent months. Read on Twitter Sheffield Utd were interested but they've potted Adkins since.
 
Grayson said "I'd probably sign all the loan players if I could..."

Doyle seemed to like it here and looks to want out of Cardiff who have just got a new manager and with their finish last season will probably be looking for better.

Can't see it being on a free so maybe a nominal fee?
 
Grayson said "I'd probably sign all the loan players if I could..."

Doyle seemed to like it here and looks to want out of Cardiff who have just got a new manager and with their finish last season will probably be looking for better.

Can't see it being on a free so maybe a nominal fee?

If he's on a high salary could be a free to get him off the payroll.
 
Cardff must be kicks themselves turning down £800k from us in August. There are parts of his game i do like. Looked more of a goal threat than JG in recent months. Read on Twitter Sheffield Utd were interested but they've potted Adkins since.

He scored the same amount of goals as garner from open play. Doyle (4) Garner (6, 2 of them penalties)
 
If we are wanting 2 strikers as mentioned in LEP then I wouldn't at all be surprised if Doyle is one of them given the limited money we have to spend etc . SG did mention in his post Leeds game interview about how sharp he was looking in training .
 
The real question is this.

Is he better than what we already have (Garner, Beckford, Hugill, May)?

I would suggest not. We need better than the 4 above if we are to improve which at the end of the day is the name of the game.

Improvement.
He isn't better than all 4 of them, but I think he pushes (and possibly surpasses) a couple of them for ability.
 
I'd rather have someone like Doyle than a spoilt and overrated player who is scared of league football like Keane.

Tend to agree, but then again, the benchmark for any strikers coming in to the club should surely be a bit higher than just not being Will Keane.

He scored the same amount of goals as garner from open play. Doyle (4) Garner (6, 2 of them penalties)

2 of Garner's were from corners, not taking those away from him but technically that's 2 from open play for him.

Imho the Doyle/Garner comparison doesn't strengthen the argument that Doyle is good enough, it merely points out that Garner probably isn't, unfortunately.

He isn't better than all 4 of them, but I think he pushes (and possibly surpasses) a couple of them for ability.

I prefer him to Hugill, definitely has more ability than him, but then again simply being better than Hugill is a low benchmark.
 
Tend to agree, but then again, the benchmark for any strikers coming in to the club should surely be a bit higher than just not being Will Keane.



2 of Garner's were from corners, not taking those away from him but technically that's 2 from open play for him.

Imho the Doyle/Garner comparison doesn't strengthen the argument that Doyle is good enough, it merely points out that Garner probably isn't, unfortunately.
Thought in 1st half of the season JG was very unlucky with near misses and hitting the woodwork etc. To early to write him of imo.
 
Thought in 1st half of the season JG was very unlucky with near misses and hitting the woodwork etc. To early to write him of imo.

I'm not writing him off just yet, but if we're looking to improve the starting XI I don't think Garner should be the automatic starter next season that he has been in the past.
 
I'm not writing him off just yet, but if we're looking to improve the starting XI I don't think Garner should be the automatic starter next season that he has been in the past.
At the moment though he's the only one of the front players who has that physical presence.
 
I did read this morning on twitter that Grayson was at Deepdale and so was Doyle's agent, this was before all this came out. something to this I reckon
 
Back
Top