Skip to main content

Ginger Forward

Ginger Forward

Grayson's salary and career as a manager hinges on our performances and results and he must have seen something more in Doyle than us fans have seen so far-IF we re-sign him.
 
Doyle is a far superior player to May in every sense.

Had May stayed fit, I suspect a lot of people would be wanting to keep Doyle at May's expense.

May by the way was a lazy signing, after targeting him when in league 1, we signed him in panic having done little homework on how poor he had been in the championship for Sheffiel Wed.

I'd add Reid & Jones who were signed on the back of one good game against us and obviously Little to the lazy signings list,

I'd guess the poster who mentioned lazy signings was maybe also suggesting a lot of players are signed from Grayson's previous clubs
 
Why were Doyle's 4 goals less important than the 3 goals Hugill "popped up" with?

Doyles goals (only scored 3 according to transfermarkt) taken from our results gives us 6 points less than we finished with.

Hugills goals (3 league, 2 cup) taken from our results gives us 5 less points than we finished with, plus he got 2 in the League Cup - 1 against Crewe and the goal which took it to ET against Bournemouth.

I think although Doyles goals were marginally more important for us this season than Hugills, Doyle was missing for massive chunks of games, whereas Hugill - thinking of his goal against Leeds and particularly his overall display against the Plastics - has never stopped trying to get involved, plus he actually scored more and is younger.

Hugill over Doyle every time for me, although evidently there is something in Doyle - you don't score as many as he did last season without some sort of ability.
 
Doyles goals (only scored 3 according to transfermarkt) taken from our results gives us 6 points less than we finished with.
I think you need to find a better website, because that's bollocks.

I won't go into the whole Hugill v Doyle debate (because cba), but I disagree with your assessment, except where you say Hugill is younger.
 
I think you need to find a better website, because that's bollocks.

I won't go into the whole Hugill v Doyle debate (because cba), but I disagree with your assessment, except where you say Hugill is younger.

Erm... I don't see how that's bollocks, he scored against Forest, QPR and Rotherham. Where are you getting the 4th from?

Horses for courses, but I don't see how you can argue Doyle did more for the team than Hugill.
 
Erm... I don't see how that's bollocks, he scored against Forest, QPR and Rotherham. Where are you getting the 4th from?

Horses for courses, but I don't see how you can argue Doyle did more for the team than Hugill.

Doyle got the winner away at Bolton as well.
 
Erm... I don't see how that's bollocks, he scored against Forest, QPR and Rotherham. Where are you getting the 4th from?

Horses for courses, but I don't see how you can argue Doyle did more for the team than Hugill.
Winner v Bolton. One of my highlights of last season. Great day
 
Fair enough, I remember that one being put down to Vermijl at the time. Wikipedia says (therefore it must be true) he only scored 3 too.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tBWX7TOVwrU

1min 50 ish, doyles goal.

doyle is a good player and will score goals given more of a run. if we sign doyle I expect him to be our top scorer next season. Hugill needs to go out on loan I feel to get the games he would need for us to decide if he has enough.
 
Last edited:
13220988_10209596556053681_3965555944658071121_n.jpg



One "for the future" he wants to play for PNE, I can but dream...........
 
Doyle is a far superior player to May in every sense.

Had May stayed fit, I suspect a lot of people would be wanting to keep Doyle at May's expense.

May by the way was a lazy signing, after targeting him when in league 1, we signed him in panic having done little homework on how poor he had been in the championship for Sheffiel Wed.

I'd add Reid & Jones who were signed on the back of one good game against us and obviously Little to the lazy signings list,

I'd guess the poster who mentioned lazy signings was maybe also suggesting a lot of players are signed from Grayson's previous clubs

May has scored more goals in this division than Garner!
 
Doyle is a far superior player to May in every sense.

Had May stayed fit, I suspect a lot of people would be wanting to keep Doyle at May's expense.

May by the way was a lazy signing, after targeting him when in league 1, we signed him in panic having done little homework on how poor he had been in the championship for Sheffiel Wed.

I'd add Reid & Jones who were signed on the back of one good game against us and obviously Little to the lazy signings list,

I'd guess the poster who mentioned lazy signings was maybe also suggesting a lot of players are signed from Grayson's previous clubs

In what way is Doyle far superior to May? How many times have you seen May play? Are you seriously judging him off a handful of brief cameos in a new team? It took both Garner and Beckford a fair while to settle in at the club. Perhaps north end signed him since he's still young and has chance to develop. As mentioned by another poster, he's already done better than Garner's ever done in this league. Doyle is a six yard box player which does not fit into how we play so in my view he would be a poor signing.

I agree on the Reid, Jones and Little bit mind.
 
Doyle is a far superior player to May in every sense.

Had May stayed fit, I suspect a lot of people would be wanting to keep Doyle at May's expense.

May by the way was a lazy signing, after targeting him when in league 1, we signed him in panic having done little homework on how poor he had been in the championship for Sheffiel Wed.

I'd add Reid & Jones who were signed on the back of one good game against us and obviously Little to the lazy signings list,

I'd guess the poster who mentioned lazy signings was maybe also suggesting a lot of players are signed from Grayson's previous clubs

Reid, Jones and Little were all low risk\low money signings that were worth taking a risk on for the price we will have ended up paying.

Reid had a very good season with Bradford before his injury, if we could have got the same player before his injury for nothing then the risk would have been worth taking, Grayson gambled but Reid has never recovered from his cruciate injury.

Jones was also having a very good season playing for Orient until he got a back injury, something that he has never shifted and has hindered him, again a gamble.

Little had scored loads in the Scottish lower divisions and there have been a lot of players that have come from the lower Scottish leagues and done well in League 1 and the Championship, I think he started off ok for us until his injury caught up with him.

If Grayson had signed Reid, Little and Jones and it had worked out for them then the scarce funds Grayson had could be used to strengthen the squad elsewhere, you have to gamble in football at times and sometimes you end up losing, but to call these signings lazy is a disservice to the man in charge.

May has barely had a chance to prove himself at Sheffield Wednesday and PNE, he didn't have a pre-season before joining us and was in and out of the team at the expense of Doyle at times whilst Grayson tried to find a suitable partner for Garner, a failing possibly in Graysons management that he didn't give either Doyle or May time to settle in the side and get up to match sharpness, Doyle as an example looked good in the sub appearances towards the end of the season.

May has scored more at this level than Doyle and Garner is younger and deserves to be given his chance, however people will be calling him a shite signing if he doesn't come back firing or is seriously effected by his injury which is understandable, but like history has taught us North End fans have always been patient and understanding with new signings.
 
The real question is this.

Is he better than what we already have (Garner, Beckford, Hugill, May)?

I would suggest not. We need better than the 4 above if we are to improve which at the end of the day is the name of the game.

Improvement.

This is exactly how I see it. Would be a bad signing imo. Lets just hope its a different ginger!!
 
Doyle? After last season's outings? Lightweight, useless in the air, lacking work-rate and hardly clinical. Thanks, but no thanks - even on a free.
 
Not Doyle's biggest fan in any means I don't think he's anything like the calibre of player we should be looking at if we have the "ambition" that Hemmings was talking about however as previously mentioned for a smallish fee I think its a good addition given there's no emergency loan market anymore so should beckford be out were stick with Garner and Hugill so as a back up I think we could do a lot worse given we don't have a large budget,

I don't think Stevie May will be beneficial to us in any way, he'll end up back at St Johnstone probably, I was for some strange reason a really big fan of his and would love to let my heart rule my head and say hell end up coming back stronger and being a fantastic player for us however reality is in my opinion not many players return from the type of injury he's had and get back to the same level or even close to it, I don't think he'll any where near our starting 11 at all next season it'll just be about 10 -15 minute cameos at the end of games when he's back around January IMO.

That being said although i'm not a fan of Doyle its a good signing as a back up or competition for places given the changes o the loan market and the fact he wants to play for PNE should be welcomed by any fan of the club!
 
Not Doyle's biggest fan in any means I don't think he's anything like the calibre of player we should be looking at if we have the "ambition" that Hemmings was talking about however as previously mentioned for a smallish fee I think its a good addition given there's no emergency loan market anymore so should beckford be out were stick with Garner and Hugill so as a back up I think we could do a lot worse given we don't have a large budget,

I don't think Stevie May will be beneficial to us in any way, he'll end up back at St Johnstone probably, I was for some strange reason a really big fan of his and would love to let my heart rule my head and say hell end up coming back stronger and being a fantastic player for us however reality is in my opinion not many players return from the type of injury he's had and get back to the same level or even close to it, I don't think he'll any where near our starting 11 at all next season it'll just be about 10 -15 minute cameos at the end of games when he's back around January IMO.

That being said although i'm not a fan of Doyle its a good signing as a back up or competition for places given the changes o the loan market and the fact he wants to play for PNE should be welcomed by any fan of the club!

Well I've always wanted to play for the club but I can definitely say that prospect should not be welcomed. 🙂
We need to do some clever business this summer,let's not just collect players.
 
Back
Top