I'm curious to know the overall opinion of the new Keeper? As most successful teams build from the back do we think he commands the area well enough? Too small in stature for me
Goalkeeper
Give him time and support him
I have only seen him play once in the flesh for PNE against Notts County. Personally, i feel that he should have saved the shot from Cassidy, it was at an easy level on his near post. At this level, he shoudl have made that save.
I have also seen the flap he made at Donny that cost us two points.
Jones has arguably cost PNE 4 points in two games. Granted it is a team game and we defend and attack as a team but they were two major ricks that have directly cost us 4 points in my opinion.
I hope he doesnt cost us many more points. I can see Stuckmann between the sticks if he carries on. It was always going to be a big job following the excellent Rudd. Personally, think Jones is not the answer and i do not believe he would be good enough for the Championship.
The cheap option.
I have also seen the flap he made at Donny that cost us two points.
Jones has arguably cost PNE 4 points in two games. Granted it is a team game and we defend and attack as a team but they were two major ricks that have directly cost us 4 points in my opinion.
I hope he doesnt cost us many more points. I can see Stuckmann between the sticks if he carries on. It was always going to be a big job following the excellent Rudd. Personally, think Jones is not the answer and i do not believe he would be good enough for the Championship.
The cheap option.
GloucesterPete
Thread starter
That's not an opinion PNE King 2012. It sure beats the drivel about idiotic kids that need a good sorting out smashing up seats.
GloucesterPete
Thread starter
Agreed Sports Lawyer. Rudd is a very hard act to follow particularly at this level.
I have only seen him play once in the flesh for PNE against Notts County. Personally, i feel that he should have saved the shot from Cassidy, it was at an easy level on his near post. At this level, he shoudl have made that save.
I have also seen the flap he made at Donny that cost us two points.
Jones has arguably cost PNE 4 points in two games. Granted it is a team game and we defend and attack as a team but they were two major ricks that have directly cost us 4 points in my opinion.
I hope he doesnt cost us many more points. I can see Stuckmann between the sticks if he carries on. It was always going to be a big job following the excellent Rudd. Personally, think Jones is not the answer and i do not believe he would be good enough for the Championship.
The cheap option.
He made a couple of good saves at Scunthorpe which kept us in the game. 3 points gained!
Rudd never made a mistake.
He's only let in 2 goals in 4 games.
I think you've already made your mind up.
Not good enough from what I've seen, he is extremely poor at one of the most crucial aspect of goalkeeping and that's catching crosses. Ask any centre half and they love it when the ball comes in and the keeper plucks it out of mid air amidst a challenge from opposing centre forwards.
I'm be surprised if Alan Kelly isn't working on this but by now you'd think he'd have shown some improvement, all the friendlies and 4 games in and he's still punching or more often just flapping. His punches rarely clear the danger either.
I hope that Grayson isn't too proud to drop him if his poor form continues.
I'm be surprised if Alan Kelly isn't working on this but by now you'd think he'd have shown some improvement, all the friendlies and 4 games in and he's still punching or more often just flapping. His punches rarely clear the danger either.
I hope that Grayson isn't too proud to drop him if his poor form continues.
I have only seen him play once in the flesh for PNE against Notts County. Personally, i feel that he should have saved the shot from Cassidy, it was at an easy level on his near post. At this level, he shoudl have made that save.
I have also seen the flap he made at Donny that cost us two points.
Jones has arguably cost PNE 4 points in two games. Granted it is a team game and we defend and attack as a team but they were two major ricks that have directly cost us 4 points in my opinion.
I hope he doesnt cost us many more points. I can see Stuckmann between the sticks if he carries on. It was always going to be a big job following the excellent Rudd. Personally, think Jones is not the answer and i do not believe he would be good enough for the Championship.
The cheap option.
Agree his mistakes have cost us, but if we could learn how to be clinical and kill off games, like Scunny away, then his mistakes wouldn't have such a big impact. Either way I think he deserves time to settle. If the mistakes keep coming week after week then it'd probably be worth giving Stuckers a go, but for now, give the lad a chance! We're only 3 games into the season. No need to jump to any rash conclusions.
Agree his mistakes have cost us, but if we could learn how to be clinical and kill off games, like Scunny away, then his mistakes wouldn't have such a big impact. Either way I think he deserves time to settle. If the mistakes keep coming week after week then it'd probably be worth giving Stuckers a go, but for now, give the lad a chance! We're only 3 games into the season. No need to jump to any rash conclusions.
This is pne-online🙂
I've seen all bar the last two games and for me he is an excellent replacement for Rudd. Yes he's made a couple of mistakes but Rudd was also a bit of a flapper when it came to crosses. Jones has made a good start pulled off some excellent saves and doesn't deserve sledging he's got after such a short period of time. I agree with the sentiment to give him time.
- Joined
- Jan 26, 2013
- Messages
- 287
It will take Jones a few games to get the confidence needed behind the players in front of him. That would be the case with any new keeper. Rudd was a very good keeper, but dont forget he had part of a season with us before he played a full season here. Also dont start believing that Rudd was flawless. Last season at Peterbro he failed to hold onto 2 shots at him that led to their 2 goals. Jones will come good, he was one of the reasons Leyton had a good season last time.
He made a couple of good saves at Scunthorpe which kept us in the game. 3 points gained!
Rudd never made a mistake.
He's only let in 2 goals in 4 games.
I think you've already made your mind up.
This ^^^^^
People say he's an excellent shot stopper but I've not seen it. 1 good save at Scunthorpe, the other effort was standard for a keeper and beaten at the near post against Notts C.
He's had 3 efforts of any note at him this season, saved 2 and conceded 1 of them. The mistake on Tuesday wasn't an effort on target, it was a flap at a cross and cost us 2 points, we'd have won against Scunthorpe without the 1 decent save he made and to say it kept us in the game is a bit dramatic.
I hope he comes good and will hold my hands up if he does but the OP asked for opinions after 4 games and how anyone can say they're happy with him is strange as he's made 2 big mistakes.
He's had 3 efforts of any note at him this season, saved 2 and conceded 1 of them. The mistake on Tuesday wasn't an effort on target, it was a flap at a cross and cost us 2 points, we'd have won against Scunthorpe without the 1 decent save he made and to say it kept us in the game is a bit dramatic.
I hope he comes good and will hold my hands up if he does but the OP asked for opinions after 4 games and how anyone can say they're happy with him is strange as he's made 2 big mistakes.
Think it's bit harsh to judge the lad after 4 games. Seen him 3 times and I can't recall him doing much wrong. Can't remember the Notts goal, but I didn't walk away thinking "Jeez what a howler!", and I haven't managed to see the Donny goal yet.
But the best players in the world make mistakes, just that the 'keepers errors are highlighted more as they usually lead to goals. But I always felt that Lonners was harshly treated so what do I know!?
As I have documented on this forum many times, none of the summer signings set my pulse racing and the jury is still out on all of them. Thought Woods was awful in the first game but I didn't write him off, and looks like he's improving.
My advice to any of our players would be never to read these message boards, as your confidence will take one hell of a kicking.
But the best players in the world make mistakes, just that the 'keepers errors are highlighted more as they usually lead to goals. But I always felt that Lonners was harshly treated so what do I know!?
As I have documented on this forum many times, none of the summer signings set my pulse racing and the jury is still out on all of them. Thought Woods was awful in the first game but I didn't write him off, and looks like he's improving.
My advice to any of our players would be never to read these message boards, as your confidence will take one hell of a kicking.
He made a couple of good saves at Scunthorpe which kept us in the game. 3 points gained!
Rudd never made a mistake.
He's only let in 2 goals in 4 games.
I think you've already made your mind up.
Rudd did make mistakes, or did everyone forget the Peterborough away game. Rudd tended to parry a lot of shots compared to (I know its early) Jones. And if you looked back at last season a couple of the parried shots ended up getting followed in.
But Rudd was a class keeper and was always going to be a tough act to follow.
I've seen all bar the last two games and for me he is an excellent replacement for Rudd. Yes he's made a couple of mistakes but Rudd was also a bit of a flapper when it came to crosses. Jones has made a good start pulled off some excellent saves and doesn't deserve sledging he's got after such a short period of time. I agree with the sentiment to give him time.
I don't think Jones has made than many mistakes, he maybe got caught under the cross against Doncaster but to be fair that ball should have been won by one of our CB's.
Notts County was the CB's fault again for not winning the ball and going to sleep at a throw in.
Jones for me is very calm and doesn't seem to panic, which means he doesnt parry the ball back into the path of opposition players.
Think it's bit harsh to judge the lad after 4 games. Seen him 3 times and I can't recall him doing much wrong. Can't remember the Notts goal, but I didn't walk away thinking "Jeez what a howler!", and I haven't managed to see the Donny goal yet.
But the best players in the world make mistakes, just that the 'keepers errors are highlighted more as they usually lead to goals. But I always felt that Lonners was harshly treated so what do I know!?
As I have documented on this forum many times, none of the summer signings set my pulse racing and the jury is still out on all of them. Thought Woods was awful in the first game but I didn't write him off, and looks like he's improving.
My advice to any of our players would be never to read these message boards, as your confidence will take one hell of a kicking.
To be honest, I used to stick up for Lonergan as well but I am a bit of a glutton for the underdog! I also thought Woods was abysmal in the first game and went off wondering what he was bringing to the table but I think we can put that down to first day nerves now - I hope so at least!
As for Jones, I thought the communication looked way off in the first game but you don't concede 1 goal from 3 away games without having something about you. Rudd came here to learn and there were a few games he made howlers in but that was part of his learning process. I don't expect the same number of big mistakes from Jones but maybe not as many top drawer saves - maybe more of a steady Eddie if that makes sense.
If I was a manager I'd tell all my players to stay away from forums, although if I was a player I don't think I'd be able to! Read Mick Rathbone's book for (admittedly only one persons) a view on that sort of thing.
One thing I've noticed about him is he's good at catching shots rather than parrying them. Makes a big difference.
He's certainly not lacking in confidence, and has a very calm air about him.
I like him, he'll do us just fine.
He's certainly not lacking in confidence, and has a very calm air about him.
I like him, he'll do us just fine.