Skip to main content

Going to be difficult

Going to be difficult

That's about the size of it. One way guarantees forking out 500k a month and getting nowt for it. The other way may and I repeat may actually get him all the money back that he's ever put in plus not forking out 500k a month.

So put in 6 million pounds a year or buy 6 million pounds worth of players to have a really good stab at promotion to the 😛redleague:

Trev didn't get to be very rich indeed without taking risks. So I think we can assume that having weighed up the odds he thinks that, on the balance of probabilities, this isn't what he wants to do with his mountains of cash. I imagine he knows the difference between taking risks and being reckless. His money, his choice.
 
That's about the size of it. One way guarantees forking out 500k a month and getting nowt for it. The other way may and I repeat may actually get him all the money back that he's ever put in plus not forking out 500k a month.

So put in 6 million pounds a year or buy 6 million pounds worth of players to have a really good stab at promotion to the 😛redleague:

There is only one way we will buy 6 million worth of talent and that's if we sell 10 million worth of talent that's what our club is all about at the moment.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
That's about the size of it. One way guarantees forking out 500k a month and getting nowt for it. The other way may and I repeat may actually get him all the money back that he's ever put in plus not forking out 500k a month.

So put in 6 million pounds a year or buy 6 million pounds worth of players to have a really good stab at promotion to the 😛redleague:
The 6 million a year pays the bills that are not covered by our takings (bums on seats plus TV/league money). These bills have to be paid by TH whatever happens, for the club to remain a going concern.

So you're not offering an either/or choice here.

You're offering that TH spends £6m a year (as now), or he spends £12m a year, plus whatever wages the six million pound man would want, plus whatever enhanced wages everyone else would want to maintain parity within the wage structure that had just been smashed. And in return for the latter, results might be better on the pitch, or they might not.

I suspect TH has already had this internal dialogue, and has chosen the £6m option.
 
If we finish about 8th or something... push for the play offs and just miss out then so be it... if we manage to retain our best players.. Stevie will be back and sign a couple of decent ones in the summer then you never know what might happen. Do need to retain the likes of pearson though!

And Fulham are really good now. Probably would be right up there without their terrible Blip.
 
"always the bridesmaids"

"always the bridesmaids"

TH is a multi millionaire, but Preston North End Football Club could not pay either the transfer fee's or wages for a top striker, it is as simple as that.

It is very easy to tell other people how to spend their money; less easy to earn those large sums yourself. Apparently Hemmings was devastated by the loss of his horse the other week. Like any much loved pet he mourns its passing, but it may also have been lined up for some big races this season, and may also have represented a significant investment lost. This sort of business is fraught with risk. Hemmings has taken calculated risk throughout his life, and come out well.

Hence, I'm pretty sure that without the money of the owner, many of the players who are at the club would not be, and North End would not be the force they are. So criticism has to start with that context in place. North End would not be 7 points off the top six without Trevor, given the nature of the owners of neighbouring clubs.

Hypothesis: If Sean Dyche were manager of Preston North End, the club would now be a premier league club.

Boiling it down, Burnley FC is surely the model football club for all to aspire to. Where Blackpool, Blackburn, Bolton and Wigan have floundered under bad management, Burnley FC continues to fly the Lancashire flag, by apparently punching way above the weight that the football world would determine they carry. This is down to an understanding at both board and managerial level, as to where the club fits into the game. An element of modest ambition is ticking over, managing the funds and releasing players when required, spending also, wisely. I would place Dyche as a perfect fit for their model and without doubt the best English manager in the country, bar none.

It is from this standpoint that a question about Hemmings could be asked. When he sees Burnley signing Andre Gray, what conclusions does he come to as regards his own club? Does he doubt Grayson's ability to find such a player (Grayson is a master at revitalising the careers of drifting talent - McGeady, Gallagher, Johnson, Robinson, Beckford - but seems to be committed to finding these left overs who are such because of flaws that eventually surface).

I conclude that the large element of risk that comes with a big signing is too much for Preston North End to handle. It doesn't seem to be in their business model to do so. This does not concur with most fans of football. A sport where, time and time again, successful teams usually build a solid team around one outstanding talent, who leads with inspiration and makes the 20 point difference with, say, a miraculous winner at Barnsley, or consistently scores regular and important goals.

The policy of a chairman totally committing £50 million to a new manager has been proven not to work. But in a football world where half of the rival clubs are verging on financial collapse, when you have a manager like Grayson and a stable club running according to budget, and a squad like North End's current squad, I would be very confident that an injection of transfer cash would be a worthwhile risk.

To that end, the demand by fans to Hemmings to inject the funds to launch a genuine challenge is not merely a throw away suggestion. It is a genuine question - does he genuinely think that with Hugill and Makeinok up front, North End is a serious promotion threat to this division? If not, then what action is planned? If so, then at least the fans know where the club sits and can decide whether to invest their interest in as Noel Gallagher put it "Ah, Preston, always the bridesmaids."
 
It is very easy to tell other people how to spend their money; less easy to earn those large sums yourself. Apparently Hemmings was devastated by the loss of his horse the other week. Like any much loved pet he mourns its passing, but it may also have been lined up for some big races this season, and may also have represented a significant investment lost. This sort of business is fraught with risk. Hemmings has taken calculated risk throughout his life, and come out well.

Hence, I'm pretty sure that without the money of the owner, many of the players who are at the club would not be, and North End would not be the force they are. So criticism has to start with that context in place. North End would not be 7 points off the top six without Trevor, given the nature of the owners of neighbouring clubs.

Hypothesis: If Sean Dyche were manager of Preston North End, the club would now be a premier league club.

Boiling it down, Burnley FC is surely the model football club for all to aspire to. Where Blackpool, Blackburn, Bolton and Wigan have floundered under bad management, Burnley FC continues to fly the Lancashire flag, by apparently punching way above the weight that the football world would determine they carry. This is down to an understanding at both board and managerial level, as to where the club fits into the game. An element of modest ambition is ticking over, managing the funds and releasing players when required, spending also, wisely. I would place Dyche as a perfect fit for their model and without doubt the best English manager in the country, bar none.

It is from this standpoint that a question about Hemmings could be asked. When he sees Burnley signing Andre Gray, what conclusions does he come to as regards his own club? Does he doubt Grayson's ability to find such a player (Grayson is a master at revitalising the careers of drifting talent - McGeady, Gallagher, Johnson, Robinson, Beckford - but seems to be committed to finding these left overs who are such because of flaws that eventually surface).

I conclude that the large element of risk that comes with a big signing is too much for Preston North End to handle. It doesn't seem to be in their business model to do so. This does not concur with most fans of football. A sport where, time and time again, successful teams usually build a solid team around one outstanding talent, who leads with inspiration and makes the 20 point difference with, say, a miraculous winner at Barnsley, or consistently scores regular and important goals.

The policy of a chairman totally committing £50 million to a new manager has been proven not to work. But in a football world where half of the rival clubs are verging on financial collapse, when you have a manager like Grayson and a stable club running according to budget, and a squad like North End's current squad, I would be very confident that an injection of transfer cash would be a worthwhile risk.

To that end, the demand by fans to Hemmings to inject the funds to launch a genuine challenge is not merely a throw away suggestion. It is a genuine question - does he genuinely think that with Hugill and Makeinok up front, North End is a serious promotion threat to this division? If not, then what action is planned? If so, then at least the fans know where the club sits and can decide whether to invest their interest in as Noel Gallagher put it "Ah, Preston, always the bridesmaids."

Without doubt, the best post I've ever read on here. Agree with most of it and it poses the sort of questions and thinking I've been putting down for years. I've no doubt the Club is moving in the right direction but IMHO at the wrong pace. If it does not speed up, it may get lapped!
 
It is from this standpoint that a question about Hemmings could be asked. When he sees Burnley signing Andre Gray, what conclusions does he come to as regards his own club?
Burnley bought Andre Gray for a top-whack price with help from the £25m Prem parachute payment they collected that season, and thanks to the fact they were already running a £15.5m wage bill (50% higher than ours is now), having kept their wage bill at least this high every season since their first Prem promotion in 2009.

They've made a substantial loss every season they haven't been in the Prem, in 2013-14 losing £10.5m (100% higher than our annual loss) on their way to promotion. Once in the Prem, they duly doubled their wage bill to £30m.

Holding up Burnley as the example to aspire to - particularly Burnley under Dyche - is disingenuous, because they have only been able to run much higher budgets, wage bills and annual losses than us for the last 7 years thanks to the Prem largesse and parachute payments they have had poured into their pockets since 2010.

And how did they get to the Prem in the first place, back in 2009? By running a club record loss of £11.7m, that's how.

No matter how reasoned and nuanced and thoughtful these arguments that we should emulate Burnley might appear to be on the surface, at their heart they are suggesting just one simple thing - that we should double our annual loss now, double our wage bill now, then cross our fingers and hope we go up.

Because that's all Burnley did.
 
Last edited:
Burnley bought Andre Gray for a top-whack price with help from the £25m Prem parachute payment they collected that season, and thanks to the fact they were already running a £15.5m wage bill (50% higher than ours is now), having kept their wage bill at least this high every season since their first Prem promotion in 2009.

They've made a substantial loss every season they haven't been in the Prem, in 2013-14 losing £10.5m (100% higher than our annual loss) on their way to promotion. Once in the Prem, they duly doubled their wage bill to £30m.

Holding up Burnley as the example to aspire to - particularly Burnley under Dyche - is disingenuous, because they have only been able to run much higher budgets, wage bills and annual losses than us for the last 7 years thanks to the Prem largesse and parachute payments they have had poured into their pockets since 2010.

And how did they get to the Prem in the first place, back in 2009? By running a club record loss of £11.7m, that's how.

No matter how reasoned and nuanced and thoughtful these arguments that we should emulate Burnley might appear to be on the surface, at their heart they are suggesting just one simple thing - that we should double our annual loss now, double our wage bill now, then cross our fingers and hope we go up.

Because that's all Burnley did.
Very good points, hate to say it but if you want a good example of getting to the prem on the cheap we need to look down the M55 rather than the 65.
 
Burnley bought Andre Gray for a top-whack price with help from the £25m Prem parachute payment they collected that season, and thanks to the fact they were already running a £15.5m wage bill (50% higher than ours is now), having kept their wage bill at least this high every season since their first Prem promotion in 2009.

They've made a substantial loss every season they haven't been in the Prem, in 2013-14 losing £10.5m (100% higher than our annual loss) on their way to promotion. Once in the Prem, they duly doubled their wage bill to £30m.

Holding up Burnley as the example to aspire to - particularly Burnley under Dyche - is disingenuous, because they have only been able to run much higher budgets, wage bills and annual losses than us for the last 7 years thanks to the Prem largesse and parachute payments they have had poured into their pockets since 2010.

And how did they get to the Prem in the first place, back in 2009? By running a club record loss of £11.7m, that's how.

No matter how reasoned and nuanced and thoughtful these arguments that we should emulate Burnley might appear to be on the surface, at their heart they are suggesting just one simple thing - that we should double our annual loss now, double our wage bill now, then cross our fingers and hope we go up.

Because that's all Burnley did.
,

Furthermore it was a lesser risk back then. More teams are now spending far more money, some with parachute payments and some without.
 
Very good points, hate to say it but if you want a good example of getting to the prem on the cheap we need to look down the M55 rather than the 65.
Afraid there's some truth to that - though even they needed Uncle Valeri to chip in with cash for key signings.

Furthermore it was a lesser risk back then. More teams are now spending far more money, some with parachute payments and some without.
I'd say it was a greater risk back then, because in 2009 "£11.7m was still a lot of money", to coin a phrase.

All you got in parachute payments back in 2009 was £23m total.

Last season you got £25m in just the first year, with £40m more in subsequent years if you stayed down.

Next season, the first year payment will be £40m.
 
Afraid there's some truth to that - though even they needed Uncle Valeri to chip in with cash for key signings.

I'd say it was a greater risk back then, because in 2009 "£11.7m was still a lot of money", to coin a phrase.

All you got in parachute payments back in 2009 was £23m total.

Last season you got £25m in just the first year, with £40m more in subsequent years if you stayed down.

Next season, the first year payment will be £40m.

I take your point but back then £11.7m might buy you promotion (with a bit of luck and good management) now you need to spend an awful lot more.
 
I take your point but back then £11.7m might buy you promotion (with a bit of luck and good management) now you need to spend an awful lot more.
Yes, that's true.

Even if the owner doubled his annual commitment now to match Burnley's 2009 gamble, it wouldn't pay for half a Scott Hogan or Andre Gray in this stupid marketplace, awash with Far Eastern cash and parachute money, and where chronic spendthrifts like Bruce, McLaren, Carvalhal, etc. are operating.

We'd also be asking TH to increase his annual spend from about £5m-6m (where it is now), while the fans themselves, via match receipts and STs, are contributing just £3.2m and falling, and even that's considered too much to pay by some on here.

Just doesn't seem reasonable to me.

If other clubs want to spend themselves into oblivion, that's fine by me, and if they want to throw silly money at us for some of our players, that's fine too, provided we can replace them.

But if the price of getting into the Prem is spending now as if you're already in the Prem, then I don't think that's something we should get into. It's very different for Dyche's Dingles, because they already have the Sky money burning a hole in their pockets, and have had for years.
 
Good points about Burnley riding a debt razor blade. Does this suggest a calamitous crash at some point, for them, just like our other Lancashire neighbours?

Thanks to a lot of hard work by Grayson since the play off promotion, North End has settled back into life in the second flight. A core of talented players such as Gallagher, Pearson, Cunningham, McGeady, Johnson, Clarke and Wright (now sold), plus a decent contracted 'keeper in Maxwell, who is the best penalty saving 'keeper I've ever seen, has made North End a genuine threat, and if Robinson, Hugill and Beckford, between them, can score 40 goals, then they represent the forward line North End might just succeed with.

On reflection, it is perhaps the success and talent of this team this season, that has caused fans to start flirting with the idea of a top 5 finish; and with it comes the demand for that gamble on a deadly finisher.

Had North End taken at least 7 points from their first 6 matches of the season, the league table would look much healthier, for them.
 
Last edited:
I'm still waiting for us to be the talk of the Championship other than the tosser Beckford being sent off again.

It's more than a waiting game waiting for us to be a force again. Fans get disillusioned and move on. It's all when and good saying they can't be true fans but they want to see something that resembles success and achievement in their lifetime not for their grandson who can't fit into the smallest shirt in the Club kit.

If PNE are to survive then they have to think big, certainly a lot bigger than they are doing now.

My main fear is that the longer this acceptance of "we are a small Lancashire Club and we're doing alright" continues, it will ultimately lead to the demise of the Club and others like us. The younger generation won't want to put up with the donkeys years of suffering and under achievement that they have seen their long suffering Dad's going through.

Mark my words, without a change in direction, a small club will always be a small club and will achieve zilche !
 
I'm still waiting for us to be the talk of the Championship other than the tosser Beckford being sent off again.

It's more than a waiting game waiting for us to be a force again. Fans get disillusioned and move on. It's all when and good saying they can't be true fans but they want to see something that resembles success and achievement in their lifetime not for their grandson who can't fit into the smallest shirt in the Club kit.

If PNE are to survive then they have to think big, certainly a lot bigger than they are doing now.

My main fear is that the longer this acceptance of "we are a small Lancashire Club and we're doing alright" continues, it will ultimately lead to the demise of the Club and others like us. The younger generation won't want to put up with the donkeys years of suffering and under achievement that they have seen their long suffering Dad's going through.

Mark my words, without a change in direction, a small club will always be a small club and will achieve zilche !

We haven't won anything of any great significance since 1938.....
 
It is very easy to tell other people how to spend their money; less easy to earn those large sums yourself. Apparently Hemmings was devastated by the loss of his horse the other week. Like any much loved pet he mourns its passing, but it may also have been lined up for some big races this season, and may also have represented a significant investment lost. This sort of business is fraught with risk. Hemmings has taken calculated risk throughout his life, and come out well.

Hence, I'm pretty sure that without the money of the owner, many of the players who are at the club would not be, and North End would not be the force they are. So criticism has to start with that context in place. North End would not be 7 points off the top six without Trevor, given the nature of the owners of neighbouring clubs.

Hypothesis: If Sean Dyche were manager of Preston North End, the club would now be a premier league club.

Boiling it down, Burnley FC is surely the model football club for all to aspire to. Where Blackpool, Blackburn, Bolton and Wigan have floundered under bad management, Burnley FC continues to fly the Lancashire flag, by apparently punching way above the weight that the football world would determine they carry. This is down to an understanding at both board and managerial level, as to where the club fits into the game. An element of modest ambition is ticking over, managing the funds and releasing players when required, spending also, wisely. I would place Dyche as a perfect fit for their model and without doubt the best English manager in the country, bar none.

It is from this standpoint that a question about Hemmings could be asked. When he sees Burnley signing Andre Gray, what conclusions does he come to as regards his own club? Does he doubt Grayson's ability to find such a player (Grayson is a master at revitalising the careers of drifting talent - McGeady, Gallagher, Johnson, Robinson, Beckford - but seems to be committed to finding these left overs who are such because of flaws that eventually surface).

I conclude that the large element of risk that comes with a big signing is too much for Preston North End to handle. It doesn't seem to be in their business model to do so. This does not concur with most fans of football. A sport where, time and time again, successful teams usually build a solid team around one outstanding talent, who leads with inspiration and makes the 20 point difference with, say, a miraculous winner at Barnsley, or consistently scores regular and important goals.

The policy of a chairman totally committing £50 million to a new manager has been proven not to work. But in a football world where half of the rival clubs are verging on financial collapse, when you have a manager like Grayson and a stable club running according to budget, and a squad like North End's current squad, I would be very confident that an injection of transfer cash would be a worthwhile risk.

To that end, the demand by fans to Hemmings to inject the funds to launch a genuine challenge is not merely a throw away suggestion. It is a genuine question - does he genuinely think that with Hugill and Makeinok up front, North End is a serious promotion threat to this division? If not, then what action is planned? If so, then at least the fans know where the club sits and can decide whether to invest their interest in as Noel Gallagher put it "Ah, Preston, always the bridesmaids."

'Does he trust Grayson to find such a player.' The player was already found before Burnley decided to spend close to 10 million on him. In other words he was already a known talent. Also burnley let's not forget hardly spent any money before they got promoted to the prem. So the only reason they managed to buy Andre Gray was because they had got promoted in the first place.
 
Back
Top