Skip to main content

Grayson !!! Really ?

Grayson !!! Really ?

I know beggars can't be choosers, but OP's entitled to question the negatives of a man who was binned off by Leeds and Huddersfield.

Just like it would be right to question Coyle, who also got sacked didn't he?

Yeah we're in a lower league, but we've no money and the players are average.
 
I have nothing against Grayson and his record in our division is exemplary. If he is appointed it should be a safe pair of hands, unfortunatly thats as far as it goes for me.Its not an appointment for the future, just one that will see us joining the managerial merry go round all over again in 2/3 years times.Personally I belive that now is the time to be brave, and set down the roots that will see PNE grow as a club over the next 20years. |Hemmings needs to take a deep breathe and think outside the box, unfortunatly with Ridsdale advising him the only thinking outside the box that will go on is how to avoid paying tax.

I thought the Westley debacle was a result of "thinking outside the box". Appointing a proven non league manager with the hope of him, with is lack of experience or qualification at a decent level, guiding us to the Premiership.

Please save us from this kind of thinking outside the box. I'd be more than happy if we were to appoint a proven manager at this level and above such as Grayson. It's the way forward.
 
I know beggars can't be choosers, but OP's entitled to question the negatives of a man who was binned off by Leeds and Huddersfield.

Just like it would be right to question Coyle, who also got sacked didn't he?

If we questioned every manager who'd ever been sacked we'd have a very short list of potentials to choose from.
 
Its not just that though, its whether he can re-create those "successes" on the lack of budget/money we have.

Yep, agree with that, I just think using the criteria of "he's been sacked by someone else therefore.." isn't likely to be the best filter when considering the right appointment.
 
Yep, agree with that, I just think using the criteria of "he's been sacked by someone else therefore.." isn't likely to be the best filter when considering the right appointment.

I agree. We would never have appointed Billy Davies that way.
 
On the sacking point Grayson wasn't doing a bad job really at Leeds it just seemed they wanted to get in the premier league immediately and that wasn't happening ( of note it isn't any better off now) Huddersfield weren't flying but they where doing ok which was perhaps fading.

He has been sacked but as said in other posts few managers haven't been, but in both cases he wasn't failing badly or running the clubs to ruin. He hasn't however done a bad job in this league which is worth considering.
 
On the sacking point Grayson wasn't doing a bad job really at Leeds it just seemed they wanted to get in the premier league immediately and that wasn't happening ( of note it isn't any better off now) Huddersfield weren't flying but they where doing ok which was perhaps fading.

He has been sacked but as said in other posts few managers haven't been, but in both cases he wasn't failing badly or running the clubs to ruin. He hasn't however done a bad job in this league which is worth considering.

You mean like we want to get back into the championship immediately?
 
didnt huddersfield lose their prized striker right at the very end of the transfer window?? i think it slightly unfair to slur grayson, he did a decent job with leeds - Neil Warnock hasnt exactly gone thier and set the world a light has he??

if we appoint grayson i would get behind him fully, knows what it takes to get out of this league. but my preference is for Coyle
 
Sorry Should of clarified this point.
it doesn't look from the outside like the resources where ever made available at Leeds to achieve this. My point was not that he underachieved but rather the demands where arguably greater than could be attained with the resources at hand. Something which should not be a bar to success in this league with the backing that the manager has typically received and the turnover of players that we have seen.
 
I thought the Westley debacle was a result of "thinking outside the box". Appointing a proven non league manager with the hope of him, with is lack of experience or qualification at a decent level, guiding us to the Premiership.

Please save us from this kind of thinking outside the box. I'd be more than happy if we were to appoint a proven manager at this level and above such as Grayson. It's the way forward.

As I said I have no problems with appointing Grayson, but we will still be following the pattern that has brought us to the situation we are in at the moment. We need to settle on a philosophy and stick to it. Say we decide on 442 and pass and move, then we always appoint a manager who plays 442 and pass and move.Furthermore we always buy players who fit this template, no matter what division we are in.Equally if we decide on 433 and lumping the ball the same principles apply.
Again I have nothing against a percived safe appointment (all managerial appointments are a risk).Its just that I think that we are falling into the old pattern which will see manager and players changed around every 2/3 years.I dont belive that this is the way forward. Appoint someone like Grezza or Ainsworth, unite the fans and buy time to lay down a proper foundation.
 
I have nothing against Grayson and his record in our division is exemplary. If he is appointed it should be a safe pair of hands, unfortunatly thats as far as it goes for me.Its not an appointment for the future, just one that will see us joining the managerial merry go round all over again in 2/3 years times.Personally I belive that now is the time to be brave, and set down the roots that will see PNE grow as a club over the next 20years. |Hemmings needs to take a deep breathe and think outside the box, unfortunatly with Ridsdale advising him the only thinking outside the box that will go on is how to avoid paying tax.

For me this is everything as to why we should appoint Stuart Baxter. Good post.
 
Back
Top