Skip to main content

Grayson

Grayson

Grayson

Clarke has been part of the team that has won 5 in a row in the league with 5 clean sheets if he had changed it tonight and lost people would have come on here and said he shouldnt have changed it.



He brought Kilkenny on to get a foothold in midfield as Gallagher was puffing and panting and trying to many fancy flicks, we needed a calm head in midfield like Doncaster had in the form of Wellens.

Gallagher and Johnson not tackling or being disciplined in defence was inviting pressure.



BC have a better squad than us IMO they have spent a lot more money this season than we have.

Sheffield Utd should also be doing better than they are.



I don't think we tried defending a lead, but SG needed to change his tactics sooner. We had 3 break aways where players made the wrong decisions, thats not completely SG's fault.



Simply because nobody else up front stood out, the players had an off day which I think they are afforded after winning 5 without conceding a goal, people cannot expect perfection.



Players being tired and not showing up were the reason we drew tonight for me, not his tactics.

Even if he got his tactics wrong thats 5/6 he has got it right, not bad really.

Clarke didn't play on Saturday. He is a centre half, not a right back. Wiseman is a right back.

Gallagher was the second striker. We replaced him with a deep sitting midfielder. We conceded 2 when Kilkenny came on and lost any attacking threat.

Hoofing the ball to Garner who was alone up top was inviting pressure.

I think we have a better squad. We will have to agree to disagree on that.

We defended a lead from pretty much the first goal. Kilkenny and Davies for Gallagher and Garner is pretty much ruling out another goal and sitting back.

No we can't accept perfection so utilise the 4 attacking players we had on the bench if players are having an off day. And I don't mean to chase an equaliser.

If they were tired then surely that's the managers job to bring in fresh legs????
 
Last edited:
Clarke didn't play on Saturday. He is a centre half, not a right back. Wiseman is a right back.

Gallagher was the second striker. We replaced him with a deep sitting midfielder. We conceded 2 when Kilkenny came on and lost any attacking threat.

Hoofing the ball to Garner who was alone up top was inviting pressure.

I think we have a better squad. We will have to agree to disagree on that.

We defended a lead from pretty much the first goal. Kilkenny and Davies for Gallagher and Garner is pretty much ruling out another goal and sitting back.

No we can't accept perfection so utilise the 4 attacking players we had on the bench if players are having an off day. And I don't mean to chase an equaliser.

If they were tired then surely that's the managers job to bring in fresh legs????

He's not a RB but was part of a defence that hadn't conceded in 5 games, so why change it? All on form at the moment its difficult who to drop out of Wright, Clarke and Huntington.

Gallagher was playing in the number 10 role behind Garner, we needed the numbers in midfield to combat them and not let Wellens play through us like he was.

Agree with the Garner tactics, thats why I think KD should have been introduced after 10 mins in the second half.

Kilkenny and Davies were only introduced late in the second half, the other time we tried to play football but you have to give credit to Doncaster they didnt let us.

Grayson took the safe management options with his substitutions worrying about the opposition, which is what he does, another manager might have brought on Reid or SEB, but that is Grayson he is Mr Safe.

Like I said if Grayson changes it and we lose people would come on here and slate him, it is sort of the unwritten rule in football you dont change a winning team.
 
He's not a RB but was part of a defence that hadn't conceded in 5 games, so why change it? All on form at the moment its difficult who to drop out of Wright, Clarke and Huntington.

Gallagher was playing in the number 10 role behind Garner, we needed the numbers in midfield to combat them and not let Wellens play through us like he was.

Agree with the Garner tactics, thats why I think KD should have been introduced after 10 mins in the second half.

Kilkenny and Davies were only introduced late in the second half, the other time we tried to play football but you have to give credit to Doncaster they didnt let us.

Grayson took the safe management options with his substitutions worrying about the opposition, which is what he does, another manager might have brought on Reid or SEB, but that is Grayson he is Mr Safe.

Like I said if Grayson changes it and we lose people would come on here and slate him, it is sort of the unwritten rule in football you dont change a winning team.

Clarke didn't play on Saturday........!!!!!! I'd drop Wright....

We would have been better taking a wide man off. I don't remember us combatting them with the introduction of Kilkenny. If anything we sat deeper and allowed them to focus more on playing football as we had less attacking threat to be concerned about and Garner was isolated.

KD doesn't score goals. Beckford should have started or at least been introduced sooner. SG brought Beckford in to partner Garner...

We needed to make substitutions sooner and go for a 2nd goal.

And that's why Grayson will be the one to blame if we don't go up. We do drop too many points at home with negative tactics.

Grayson changed the team that won at Oldham and played Clarke out of position by doing so.....!! Clarke didn't play on Saturday...!!
 
I don't think Larry did his homework properly on Doncaster. We have a great attacking midfield but we were bullied out of it tonight, especially in the second half, so he brought Kilkenny on and made it worse, we should have had King on the bench in case a battler was needed.

And this playing of Clarke at right back to fit Wright in is ridiculous, Clarke and Huntingdon make a great CB partnership, put Wright back on the bench and play full backs please Larry.

And Davies should have started tonight, holding the ball up for 4 potential scorers from midfield, it wasn't Garners sort of game tonight.
 
I don't think Larry did his homework properly on Doncaster. We have a great attacking midfield but we were bullied out of it tonight, especially in the second half, so he brought Kilkenny on and made it worse, we should have had King on the bench in case a battler was needed.

And this playing of Clarke at right back to fit Wright in is ridiculous, Clarke and Huntingdon make a great CB partnership, put Wright back on the bench and play full backs please Larry.

And Davies should have started tonight, holding the ball up for 4 potential scorers from midfield, it wasn't Garners sort of game tonight.

All said in hindsight, 16 out of 18 time to move onto Saturday.
 
Because we kept hoofing it up to isolated Garner and it kept coming back at us. They didn't play with much width and Humphrey was shite so he'd have been a better option. Kilkenny doesn't tackle and sits that deep we just absorbed more pressure.
So the solution is to throw another striker on and see if it sticks better? Bringing someone on that won't hoof it is a better option IMO.
 
I know we are 2nd with a game in hand, I know SG has turned us around since he arrived and I know he is nearing on a 50% win ratio..... But I just can't explain how frustrating that was too watch this evening....

I don't understand why when we have a specialist right back on the bench who is good at getting forward we play a centre half there.

When we are crying out for a 2nd goal I don't understand why we bring Kilkenny on and then we only bring Beckford on when we are chasing the game. Gallagher was the '2nd striker' surely taking attacking talent off for a deep sitting centre mid we will invite more pressure.

We have, in my eyes, the best squad in L1 and SG has bought some good players in but if we don't go up then I feel he will be too blame.

Why oh why did we try and defend the lead for the majority of the match. Most fans in the ground tonight could see what was coming and we desperately needed a 2nd goal.

Doncaster had more possession as we kept hoofing the ball forward to an isolated Garner.

We had 2 shots on target and scored them both. They had 4 and 53% possession.

The fact a centre half got MOTM speaks volumes....

I am very happy we are 2nd, I am happy that we have a good squad and I support SG as he will hopefully take us to the Championship but deep down I feel Graysons tactics will cost us this season and I hope to be proven wrong....

Talk about accentuating the negative!
 
See you are stalking me again without actually adding any opinion of the match.....

Did you go on?
What was your option on the game?
The tactics?

Why don't you input your experience or footballing knowledge?

Just because you express an opinion, does not make that opinion correct or, that other people have to express their own. You put your opinions out there and given your extensive knowledge of football tactics, man management etc I am surprised Larry, LVG et al have not been in touch about a possible coaching job. I do go on and have been since 1970, have seen 5 of our 6 promotion campaigns since ww2 and I for one am very happy with SG and second place.
 
Just because you express an opinion, does not make that opinion correct or, that other people have to express their own. You put your opinions out there and given your extensive knowledge of football tactics, man management etc I am surprised Larry, LVG et al have not been in touch about a possible coaching job. I do go on and have been since 1970, have seen 5 of our 6 promotion campaigns since ww2 and I for one am very happy with SG and second place.

It's a football forum for debate.... the same poster does not debate football but constantly comes back with one liners....

I don't believe the questions I posed were to you but thanks for your input and history though....

I'm happy with 2nd, I also think SG has done a good job...... (please refer to OP) however last night I wasn't happy and I post game by game....

I never said I had extensive knowledge but most fans in the ground last night could see what was needed. In fact when we needed to attack and chase the game we scored. Why get to that to force a more positive approach?
 
Back
Top