too many mistakes with our team cost us vital points. Fair enough he has changed the team around and made a couple of good signings but this is as far as were going. He won't get us promoted his tactics are negative and make us play boring football. He doesn't know our strongest team. Look at the goalkeeper situation he signed jones he was useless flapped at everything and cost us points then he signed Johnstone fair enough he is a promising keeper but he doesn't have the experince to organise the defence. He should of stuck with Stuckmann. He's been playing well recently and made some vital saves but Grayson still decides to start Johnstone ahead of him. If we had Stuckmann in the net on saturday it would of finished 1-1 he would of saved their second goal but Johnstone didn't even attempt to save it
Graysons tactics
I've got a feeling this may get merged with one of the other 15 threads on the same topic.
I agree with a large majority of what you say.
I agree with a large majority of what you say.
When I watched the Orient game, there was a number of things that occurred on the night that rang alarm bells with me. With the amount of players taking the lazy option of shooting from distance & without any real care or application really standing out like a sore thumb. It appeared that there has been a turn for the worse within the squad from that night on, with the players not believing in what they are doing and the tactics being deployed. It seemed almost that SG had "lost" the dressing room & seemed reminiscent of the end of the Craig Brown era. As we know when the dressing room is lost there is rarely any outcome bar the inevitable & recent results would suggest that the dressing room has not been regained. Obvoiusly none of the players would ever go public with this. It never happens. Part of me hopes I am wrong and that Grayson turns it around, but a large part of me fears that I am right
Someone else mentioned a comment from Chris Humphrey in an interview after the Walsall game, that indicated it might be a case the players are getting confused and exasperated by the tactics the manager is employing.
Possibly has lost the confidence of the players.
Set up to attack from the off Simon, with a brief of " go out and put them to the sword your better than them", it's only going to be better than the current fare, regardless of the results
Possibly has lost the confidence of the players.
Set up to attack from the off Simon, with a brief of " go out and put them to the sword your better than them", it's only going to be better than the current fare, regardless of the results
SG sets up the team to defend, I don't understand why when we was playing bottom of the league he started with one lone striker he should of started with started with SEB and KD. Don't see why he put KD on so late in the game so he couldn't have an impact on the game
Thracia
Club Owner, or wingback, depending on your view
- Joined
- Aug 1, 2011
- Messages
- 30,692
Brilliant - no evidence offered that he has "lost the dressing room", just the suggestion that he might "almost have", and a reminder that, if he has, then it's curtains, and no one will ever admit it publicly - so, you know, "nudge nudge".When I watched the Orient game, there was a number of things that occurred on the night that rang alarm bells with me. With the amount of players taking the lazy option of shooting from distance & without any real care or application really standing out like a sore thumb. It appeared that there has been a turn for the worse within the squad from that night on, with the players not believing in what they are doing and the tactics being deployed. It seemed almost that SG had "lost" the dressing room & seemed reminiscent of the end of the Craig Brown era. As we know when the dressing room is lost there is rarely any outcome bar the inevitable & recent results would suggest that the dressing room has not been regained. Obvoiusly none of the players would ever go public with this. It never happens. Part of me hopes I am wrong and that Grayson turns it around, but a large part of me fears that I am right
What next? "No smoke without fire"?
Brilliant - no evidence offered that he has "lost the dressing room", just the suggestion that he might "almost have", and a reminder that, if he has, then it's curtains, and no one will ever admit it publicly - so, you know, "nudge nudge".
What next? "No smoke without fire"?
No Thracia... I've no evidence offered at all... Who am I to offer any evidence?... I've supported PNE through thin & thin for 30+ years & have also been involved in football at various levels for many years & I am merely stating that I have observed tell tale signs that a manger may have lost the dressing room... Maybe just maybe I've seen it all before & know my onions. I've expressed my personal view on an internet forum that has little sway on all goings on at PNE. I thought that was what they were for? I may be wrong, I hope I am.... BUT I do recognise the body language of disillusioned footballers
Thracia
Club Owner, or wingback, depending on your view
- Joined
- Aug 1, 2011
- Messages
- 30,692
Fair enough, but it just sounds like poisoning of the well to me, sorry.No Thracia... I've no evidence offered at all... Who am I to offer any evidence?... I've supported PNE through thin & thin for 30+ years & have also been involved in football at various levels for many years & I am merely stating that I have observed tell tale signs that a manger may have lost the dressing room... Maybe just maybe I've seen it all before & know my onions. I've expressed my personal view on an internet forum that has little sway on all goings on at PNE. I thought that was what they were for? I may be wrong, I hope I am.... BUT I do recognise the body language of disillusioned footballers
Liberation
Forum Patron
Fair enough, but it just sounds like poisoning of the well to me, sorry.
You penned an excellent and very impressive match report the other day. Hand on heart ( based on that showing) would you say that all is well with the players? Other than the bloody tactics, would you say that they are doing their best ( within the system they are asked to play )? Genuine question.
No Thracia... I've no evidence offered at all... Who am I to offer any evidence?... I've supported PNE through thin & thin for 30+ years & have also been involved in football at various levels for many years & I am merely stating that I have observed tell tale signs that a manger may have lost the dressing room... Maybe just maybe I've seen it all before & know my onions. I've expressed my personal view on an internet forum that has little sway on all goings on at PNE. I thought that was what they were for? I may be wrong, I hope I am.... BUT I do recognise the body language of disillusioned footballers
Cheers for the insight Buckshaw and if you are seeing the tell tell signs than the writing might be on the wall.
Hopefully not mind.
Thracia
Club Owner, or wingback, depending on your view
- Joined
- Aug 1, 2011
- Messages
- 30,692
I'd say most of them are trying their best, but for several of them, their best isn't very good to begin with, no matter what the tactics.You penned an excellent and very impressive match report the other day. Hand on heart ( based on that showing) would you say that all is well with the players? Other than the bloody tactics, would you say that they are doing their best ( within the system they are asked to play )? Genuine question.
One problem with our attacking play (tactics apart) is, it all tends to go through Gallagher, who slows things down, and can be hit-and-miss with his decision-making and execution. That's not a problem with tactics IMO, that's just the way he seems to need to play - he needs more time than is realistically available against some of these L1 outfits. I don't mean to blame Gallagher for all our ills, BTW, this is just an example - he's one of our better players, but that doesn't mean he's always a net positive when e.g. we need to do something quickly.
A lot of the perceived problems with our "tactics" could obviously be solved by using better-quality players in the same roles, but so far we haven't recruited as many better-quality players as our rivals have this window, and that means we risk falling behind in the "arms race". I think we need 2 decent additions today, to move certain squad players further away from first team consideration.
But any talk of SG "losing the dressing room" is based on nothing but thin air, and is just drama-mongering for the sake of it IMO. It doesn't help, and there's no need for it.
Can anyone tell me why Brownhill keeps getting picked other than he is SG's lovechild or something else?
Liberation
Forum Patron
I'd say most of them are trying their best, but for several of them, their best isn't very good to begin with, no matter what the tactics.
One problem with our attacking play (tactics apart) is, it all tends to go through Gallagher, who slows things down, and can be hit-and-miss with his decision-making and execution. That's not a problem with tactics IMO, that's just the way he seems to need to play - he needs more time than is realistically available against some of these L1 outfits. I don't mean to blame Gallagher for all our ills, BTW, this is just an example - he's one of our better players, but that doesn't mean he's always a net positive when e.g. we need to do something quickly.
A lot of the perceived problems with our "tactics" could obviously be solved by using better-quality players in the same roles, but so far we haven't recruited as many better-quality players as our rivals have this window, and that means we risk falling behind in the "arms race". I think we need 2 decent additions today, to move certain squad players further away from first team consideration.
But any talk of SG "losing the dressing room" is based on nothing but thin air, and is just drama-mongering for the sake of it IMO. It doesn't help, and there's no need for it.
Cheers for that..Interesting times ahead.
I'd say most of them are trying their best, but for several of them, their best isn't very good to begin with, no matter what the tactics.
One problem with our attacking play (tactics apart) is, it all tends to go through Gallagher, who slows things down, and can be hit-and-miss with his decision-making and execution. That's not a problem with tactics IMO, that's just the way he seems to need to play - he needs more time than is realistically available against some of these L1 outfits. I don't mean to blame Gallagher for all our ills, BTW, this is just an example - he's one of our better players, but that doesn't mean he's always a net positive when e.g. we need to do something quickly.
A lot of the perceived problems with our "tactics" could obviously be solved by using better-quality players in the same roles, but so far we haven't recruited as many better-quality players as our rivals have this window, and that means we risk falling behind in the "arms race". I think we need 2 decent additions today, to move certain squad players further away from first team consideration.
But any talk of SG "losing the dressing room" is based on nothing but thin air, and is just drama-mongering for the sake of it IMO. It doesn't help, and there's no need for it.[/QUOTE]
What if it is correct though?... Look at my post history & I am not a "Look at ME" contributor to this forum. How can we explain the sudden turn in from from top 3 contenders to bottom 3 contenders?.. Is it all down to the absence of Joe Garner? I find your statement regarding the quality of our players debateable... There is plenty of quality in this squad
Liberation
Forum Patron
I'd say most of them are trying their best, but for several of them, their best isn't very good to begin with, no matter what the tactics.
One problem with our attacking play (tactics apart) is, it all tends to go through Gallagher, who slows things down, and can be hit-and-miss with his decision-making and execution. That's not a problem with tactics IMO, that's just the way he seems to need to play - he needs more time than is realistically available against some of these L1 outfits. I don't mean to blame Gallagher for all our ills, BTW, this is just an example - he's one of our better players, but that doesn't mean he's always a net positive when e.g. we need to do something quickly.
A lot of the perceived problems with our "tactics" could obviously be solved by using better-quality players in the same roles, but so far we haven't recruited as many better-quality players as our rivals have this window, and that means we risk falling behind in the "arms race". I think we need 2 decent additions today, to move certain squad players further away from first team consideration.
But any talk of SG "losing the dressing room" is based on nothing but thin air, and is just drama-mongering for the sake of it IMO. It doesn't help, and there's no need for it.[/QUOTE]
What if it is correct though?... Look at my post history & I am not a "Look at ME" contributor to this forum. How can we explain the sudden turn in from from top 3 contenders to bottom 3 contenders?.. Is it all down to the absence of Joe Garner? I find your statement regarding the quality of our players debateable... There is plenty of quality in this squad
Perhaps we were only average to begin with and things are now just balancing out?
Can anyone tell me why Brownhill keeps getting picked other than he is SG's lovechild or something else?
Can you not see from recent performances that he is anything but SG's lovechild? The lad has natural creativity but IMO it is clear to see he has been given instructions that restrict his ability and instead, make him out to be a scapegoat! With Welsh or Kilkenny behind him the boy should be given license to roam and make things happen
Thracia
Club Owner, or wingback, depending on your view
- Joined
- Aug 1, 2011
- Messages
- 30,692
Of course it's debatable. It's only an opinion.I find your statement regarding the quality of our players debateable... There is plenty of quality in this squad
Likewise, your "there's plenty of quality in this squad" statement is debatable, only being your opinion.
And I disagree with it.
Garner's injury - plus nearly every other bloody striker being injured at the same time lately! - has exposed weaknesses in the squad, but not just up front.