Skip to main content

Grimshaw

Grimshaw

So your opinion is that because one of our other young midfielders got moved on and hasn't done anything we should get rid of anyone in the squad who doesn't play every week?

That might be a generalisation, but there shouldn't be any problems with that since you just made one about everyone who wants to keep Grimshaw being a hoarder.

I'm honestly not scared he might do something somewhere else. My opinion is that I want to see him more in his preferred position before making my mind up rather than people like you who want him gone because you've seen him twice and he isn't delivering right this very second.

Has he even seen him twice? Isn't he in California?!
 
You lot are missing the point. See jackD post a few up. We ain't in a luxury position to 'bring grimshaw on' I don't give a fuck about grimshaw anyway he isn't my beef he could be anyone, Pringle, Beckford, lindgard, any of them. This summer, next season is the chance. This is it. If we don't do it be ready for Grayson to be poached, Robinson, Johnson, Cunningham, Pearson maybe even Browne to all be targeted and pne will struggle to protect all this due to our relative size of club.

In a perfect world yeah let's develop and give time but I think that's all irrelevant as we are so close to having a promotion winning team. To maximize that I'd support a pne squad cull and focusing.

Zzz aye let's chuck geography into the mix when you're losing an argument... Boring gents.
And yeah of course fucking Josh brownhiill is a relevant player to compare with, why not?
 
Grimshaw is not being well received by the Chesterfield fans, some comments below from their defeat last Saturday

"Grimshaw is shocking. If he had put away the sitter at 1-0 - our only chance in second half - we might have won"

"Grimshaw wide right of a three looked completely awful"

"As for Grimshaw, he's a poor man's Jordan Henderson. Runs around a lot, hit's square balls, but when a bit of quality is needed he falls short whether it's a shot or a pass"

"Grimshaw not good enough"

"Gardner, Grimshaw, Brown were all poor whilst on the pitch"

"Grimshaw is such a poor player. He adds absolutely nothing to the team at all"

"He's been the biggest disappointment for me. At best he is a poor man's Dereck Niven. Expected a lot more from him"

"You shouldn't even mention the words "Grimshaw" and "Niven" in the same sentence. When Derek was fully fit, and when he came on loan, he showed far more enthusiasm, work effic, pace, pride etc than the likes of Grimshaw and Brown"

I don't think it's fair to group Grimshaw with Brown. I wouldn't have faulted Grimshaw's enthusiasm, stamina, even bravery. I'd have faulted his skill set.

Not many comments after the draw at Millwall in midweek as they only took 80 supporters, but one who posted had this to say

"Grimshaw and Gardner, well the less said the better - two extremely poor players who worked hard but just lack distinct quality".

I hope for the lads sake, its just a lack of confidence playing in a poor team, managed by what their fans think is clueless manager.

That said, I work with Grimshaw's brothers best mate and he is not enjoying his time at North End. He wanted to stay at Motherwell, but Man United wanted a fee and Motherwell couldn't/wouldn't pay it.

Hope he can turn it around as he is still only young.

Incorrect 🙂
 
Me ��

If you have to be a successful manager to comment on a message board it would be a quiet place.

All this is well and good but we ain't Brighton fof Christ's sake, and thank the Lord for that!
Grimshaw isn't Joe garner or Pearson cause they both delivered, not after 16 months of no output but after a few months of trying.

My opinion is you're all hoarders and scared he might do something somewhere else. Well. My opinion is that's bollox cause he ain't up to it, that opinion is based on his clear lack of output.

Josh brownhiill got the same rants on here this time last year, gone to Bristol and done sod all of any note.

Slim the squad down, free up the wage quality not quantity as a poster said before. We are so so so so close to doing it its time we realised it. Genuinely this era has one last go at this before our assets are poached and that goes for Grayson also. We need 3/4 more first team starters and we can do it and go up properly!

UTWs

I completely agree with your quality over quantity statement, but lets just break that down for a second:

DJ - quality and came from a similar backstory to Grimshaw
Pearson - quality and came from a similar backstory to Grimshaw
Robinson - quality and similar backstory to Grimshaw
Vermaijl - decent and a similar backstory to Grimshaw


My point being - we dont have the millions to spend on taking punts on lower league players. Our transfer policy has been for some time now picking off young talent from PL sides and seeing how they cope in our side. Sometimes, we will uncover real gems and sometimes they will be fairly average. But the element of risk is fairly minimal.

Quality over quantity is such an easy statement to make. Say Grimshaw is on 3k a week (just a guess, by no means am i ITK). Over the course of a 2 year contract, it'll cost us in and around 300k,. Nowadays, what would that 300k get us?
 
You lot are missing the point. See jackD post a few up. We ain't in a luxury position to 'bring grimshaw on' I don't give a fuck about grimshaw anyway he isn't my beef he could be anyone, Pringle, Beckford, lindgard, any of them. This summer, next season is the chance. This is it. If we don't do it be ready for Grayson to be poached, Robinson, Johnson, Cunningham, Pearson maybe even Browne to all be targeted and pne will struggle to protect all this due to our relative size of club.

In a perfect world yeah let's develop and give time but I think that's all irrelevant as we are so close to having a promotion winning team. To maximize that I'd support a pne squad cull and focusing.

Zzz aye let's chuck geography into the mix when you're losing an argument... Boring gents.
And yeah of course fucking Josh brownhiill is a relevant player to compare with, why not?

We are forever in the position of "bringing players on" this never stops until we get bankrolled by some Californian Billionaire.

A lot of our promising youth players have been "brought on" this never stops.
 
I completely agree with your quality over quantity statement, but lets just break that down for a second:

DJ - quality and came from a similar backstory to Grimshaw
Pearson - quality and came from a similar backstory to Grimshaw
Robinson - quality and similar backstory to Grimshaw
Vermaijl - decent and a similar backstory to Grimshaw


My point being - we dont have the millions to spend on taking punts on lower league players. Our transfer policy has been for some time now picking off young talent from PL sides and seeing how they cope in our side. Sometimes, we will uncover real gems and sometimes they will be fairly average. But the element of risk is fairly minimal.

Quality over quantity is such an easy statement to make. Say Grimshaw is on 3k a week (just a guess, by no means am i ITK). Over the course of a 2 year contract, it'll cost us in and around 300k,. Nowadays, what would that 300k get us?

Ben Pringle.
 
You lot are missing the point. See jackD post a few up. We ain't in a luxury position to 'bring grimshaw on' I don't give a fuck about grimshaw anyway he isn't my beef he could be anyone, Pringle, Beckford, lindgard, any of them. This summer, next season is the chance. This is it. If we don't do it be ready for Grayson to be poached, Robinson, Johnson, Cunningham, Pearson maybe even Browne to all be targeted and pne will struggle to protect all this due to our relative size of club.

In a perfect world yeah let's develop and give time but I think that's all irrelevant as we are so close to having a promotion winning team. To maximize that I'd support a pne squad cull and focusing.

Zzz aye let's chuck geography into the mix when you're losing an argument... Boring gents.
And yeah of course fucking Josh brownhiill is a relevant player to compare with, why not?

As shown with the Bailey Wright scenario, our better players will always be the topic of interest from other clubs and potentially 'poached'.

And that was after investment in players like McGeady, Horgan and co
 
You lot are missing the point. See jackD post a few up. We ain't in a luxury position to 'bring grimshaw on' I don't give a fuck about grimshaw anyway he isn't my beef he could be anyone, Pringle, Beckford, lindgard, any of them. This summer, next season is the chance. This is it. If we don't do it be ready for Grayson to be poached, Robinson, Johnson, Cunningham, Pearson maybe even Browne to all be targeted and pne will struggle to protect all this due to our relative size of club.

In a perfect world yeah let's develop and give time but I think that's all irrelevant as we are so close to having a promotion winning team. To maximize that I'd support a pne squad cull and focusing.

Zzz aye let's chuck geography into the mix when you're losing an argument... Boring gents.
And yeah of course fucking Josh brownhiill is a relevant player to compare with, why not?

As far as I can make out your argument can be summed up as "do as well as possible in the transfer market".

I think we'd all agree with that.

PS - some of the deadwood was moved out before Christmas in the form of Humphrey. We evidently aren't rabid player collectors but when you've people under contract its tougher than simply snapping your fingers to move them on if they're surplus to requirements.
 
You lot are missing the point. See jackD post a few up. We ain't in a luxury position to 'bring grimshaw on' I don't give a fuck about grimshaw anyway he isn't my beef he could be anyone, Pringle, Beckford, lindgard, any of them. This summer, next season is the chance. This is it. If we don't do it be ready for Grayson to be poached, Robinson, Johnson, Cunningham, Pearson maybe even Browne to all be targeted and pne will struggle to protect all this due to our relative size of club.

In a perfect world yeah let's develop and give time but I think that's all irrelevant as we are so close to having a promotion winning team. To maximize that I'd support a pne squad cull and focusing.

Zzz aye let's chuck geography into the mix when you're losing an argument... Boring gents.
And yeah of course fucking Josh brownhiill is a relevant player to compare with, why not?
"To maximize that I'd support a pne squad cull and focusing."

What exactly do you mean by "focusing"?

You don't want us "wasting our time" developing young players because we "ain't in that luxury position", so what type of player - exactly - are we going to be signing this summer, in your view?
 
You lot are missing the point. See jackD post a few up. We ain't in a luxury position to 'bring grimshaw on' I don't give a fuck about grimshaw anyway he isn't my beef he could be anyone, Pringle, Beckford, lindgard, any of them. This summer, next season is the chance. This is it. If we don't do it be ready for Grayson to be poached, Robinson, Johnson, Cunningham, Pearson maybe even Browne to all be targeted and pne will struggle to protect all this due to our relative size of club.

In a perfect world yeah let's develop and give time but I think that's all irrelevant as we are so close to having a promotion winning team. To maximize that I'd support a pne squad cull and focusing.

Zzz aye let's chuck geography into the mix when you're losing an argument... Boring gents.
And yeah of course fucking Josh brownhiill is a relevant player to compare with, why not?

I'm sorry, I must have taken your sweeping generalisation about how we're all hoarders the wrong way.

So you think developing players is irrelevant... because we obviously have the money to go out and splash £5m on players to put the finishing touches on our squad don't we? It's not like it's the reason we're where we are today is it, having faith in young players like Wright, Browne, Robinson, DJ, Hugill..? Silly me.

I never said I disagree with your quality over quantity statement - I also believe we could do with getting some, like Beckford and Pringle, out and replace them with better quality, and I believe if we go up we would have our best shot at it next season. I disagree with the fact that you are so against a 22 year old lad who represents our football club, has been outshone by the quality central midfield competition we have, and has done nothing to get that negative a reaction from anyone. That kind of attitude can surely only help him come along further, after all...

The geography point is valid, regardless of who "wins" the argument (if you insist on being childish enough to consider that this is something you can win). There are plenty of people physically in better places to see how he's doing than both me and you, and these people generally seem to be the sensible ones who are calling for fans to give him time, despite what people like you are saying about him.

I'm not saying Josh Brownhill isn't a relevant player. I'm saying that the problem is just because one central midfielder who didn't offer too much to the squad went somewhere else and didn't pull up any trees doesn't mean that any player who doesn't get into our squad is bound to do the same, especially when you've had virtually no time to see him and judge him properly!
 
The fact is we could move out six players, replace them with two and and save a lot of wages without our squad being noticeably weakened. If Doyle, Pringle, Grimshaw, Beckford, Makienok and Lindegaard all left and we brought in a new reserve 'keeper and a decent forward and I don't think anyone could argue we were worse off. The bigger ask is replacing (or signing, fingers crossed!) McGeady and Baptiste.
 
The fact is we could move out six players, replace them with two and and save a lot of wages without our squad being noticeably weakened. If Doyle, Pringle, Grimshaw, Beckford, Makienok and Lindegaard all left and we brought in a new reserve 'keeper and a decent forward and I don't think anyone could argue we were worse off. The bigger ask is replacing (or signing, fingers crossed!) McGeady and Baptiste.

Nutshell.

We have too many players picking up wages just by sitting game after game in the stands. Should be 3 maximum in this position, not the collection we currently have.
 
Nutshell.

We have too many players picking up wages just by sitting game after game in the stands. Should be 3 maximum in this position, not the collection we currently have.

If they were young lads on peanuts then it wouldn't be much of an issue, but the likes of Beckford and Lindegaard are supposedly top earners and they are doing nothing. Doyle and Pringle will probably be on a decent wedge too having come from other Championship sides. Get rid of this lot and we will have more breathing space to strengthen in the summer, particularly up top.

I think one of the things that has held us back from signing strikers in some recent transfer windows is the amount of average ones that we're already carrying along/paying.
 
Little bit of an assumption that getting rid of a player frees up money. If no one wants to take him on his existing deal then we'd have to subsidize any transfer.
 
Nutshell.

We have too many players picking up wages just by sitting game after game in the stands. Should be 3 maximum in this position, not the collection we currently have.

I'm not sure a squad of 21 would see you through a season now there are no loans in between windows.

2 suspensions and a couple of injuries would mean we wouldn't be able to fill the bench.
 
I'm not sure a squad of 21 would see you through a season now there are no loans in between windows.

2 suspensions and a couple of injuries would mean we wouldn't be able to fill the bench.

That's where the likes of Matthew Hudson, Clive Smith (youngsters) step up.
 
I'm not sure a squad of 21 would see you through a season now there are no loans in between windows.

2 suspensions and a couple of injuries would mean we wouldn't be able to fill the bench.
I agree, a 25-man squad is pretty standard.

And what's the plan supposed to be here? Cut the squad by 4 players and give the wages of 6 players to 2 guys instead?

That would break the wage structure, which isn't likely to happen - certainly not at the expense of squad size.
 
Back
Top