Was the lad injured on Saturday or 'rested'? Either way I think we could have done with him - he provides balance and energy to the left of midfield and even as an 'impact' sub he seems to have had more impact against Wolves than Monkana did against MKD. He also frees up Holmes for use elsewhere, which is important because I increasingly suspect that Holmes is a spent force as a wide left player and is better used elsewhere either cutting in from the right or, perhaps, he could even become the creative central midfielder we seem to need.
Hayhurst
Was the lad injured on Saturday or 'rested'? Either way I think we could have done with him - he provides balance and energy to the left of midfield and even as an 'impact' sub he seems to have had more impact against Wolves than Monkana did against MKD. He also frees up Holmes for use elsewhere, which is important because I increasingly suspect that Holmes is a spent force as a wide left player and is better used elsewhere either cutting in from the right or, perhaps, he could even become the creative central midfielder we seem to need.
I must admit, I like Hayhurst. He has a football brain and knows what positions to take up when we are moving forward. It would be nice to have a central midfielder who can pass the ball to one of our team rather than giving it to the opposition. As much as I like Keane for his tackling and anticipation which puts us on the front foot, I find that he then gives the ball away too easily.
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2004
- Messages
- 19,671
He also frees up Holmes for use elsewhere, which is important because I increasingly suspect that Holmes is a spent force as a wide left player
You keep saying this, and for me it's complete bollocks. He's being used more centrally due to Keane and Welsh being paired together. Once that ends, which it will soon, Holmes will be back on the wing.
You keep saying this, and for me it's complete bollocks. He's being used more centrally due to Keane and Welsh being paired together. Once that ends, which it will soon, Holmes will be back on the wing.
Fair enough - but from what I have seen Holmes increasingly struggles to get past a defender on the outside when he is on the left but looks much more comfortable when he cuts in from the right either to cross or move to a more central position. It was from precisely such a position that he threaded through the pass that freed up Humphrey for our first goal on Saturday.
A winning PNE side contains Hayhurst, yelling 'Slit.'
Is that a bookable offence for referees ITK?
You keep saying this, and for me it's complete bollocks. He's being used more centrally due to Keane and Welsh being paired together. Once that ends, which it will soon, Holmes will be back on the wing.
Only one goal conceded from open play in 4 games suggest that the defensive central midfield players must be doing something right
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2010
- Messages
- 850
I remember that stat towards the back-end of last season which indicated Hayhurst had the best points return per game out of entire squad. The only game that we have won this season, he indeed started.
We always looked more comfortable, assured and organised when he plays. I know Ernest loves his 'wing-halves' but it is true that the comparison between him and Chris Sedgwick is uncanny.
I would much rather Hayhurst started for the time being until our other wingers started to show the same level of consistency. It is true that wingers naturally come in and out of games but this is the area which I believe is the difference between us staying solid and scoring goals.
We played high up the pitch in Saturday's first half, we were a bit more expansive and probably carrying the burden of drawing blanks in front of goal. As it turns out, this was as much a hindrance as it was helpful. The one time Humphrey really got in behind their backline and delivered a dangerous ball, their defender put it in his own net. Our wide play is the key for me, much as it was under David Moyes 14 years ago.
We always looked more comfortable, assured and organised when he plays. I know Ernest loves his 'wing-halves' but it is true that the comparison between him and Chris Sedgwick is uncanny.
I would much rather Hayhurst started for the time being until our other wingers started to show the same level of consistency. It is true that wingers naturally come in and out of games but this is the area which I believe is the difference between us staying solid and scoring goals.
We played high up the pitch in Saturday's first half, we were a bit more expansive and probably carrying the burden of drawing blanks in front of goal. As it turns out, this was as much a hindrance as it was helpful. The one time Humphrey really got in behind their backline and delivered a dangerous ball, their defender put it in his own net. Our wide play is the key for me, much as it was under David Moyes 14 years ago.
- Joined
- Jun 9, 2004
- Messages
- 10,645
14 years ago things were different in that Rankine played a more forward role and, despite his weaknesses with the ball at feet, gave the midfield a good box-to-box presence. Supporting this, Alexander offered a lot with his creativity and passing ability.
Getting this balance right (either through personnel or tactics) is Grayson's biggest challenge and will define our season.
Getting this balance right (either through personnel or tactics) is Grayson's biggest challenge and will define our season.
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2010
- Messages
- 850
14 years ago things were different in that Rankine played a more forward role and, despite his weaknesses with the ball at feet, gave the midfield a good box-to-box presence. Supporting this, Alexander offered a lot with his creativity and passing ability.
Getting this balance right (either through personnel or tactics) is Grayson's biggest challenge and will define our season.
I wholeheartedly agree.
Only one goal conceded from open play in 4 games suggest that the defensive central midfield players must be doing something right
Very true but only two goals - I suppose technically three - scored from open play suggests a lack of something else. I don't think that the central midfield pairing of Welsh and Keane is entirely to blame and it has it uses - for instance when we were under pressure against a team from the Fylde coast, but when the rest of the team includes two very defensive fullbacks who aren't very good at getting up on the overlap and two 'wingers', though Holmes is not quite that, then the result is something rather predictable and old-fashioned.
Modern football is a more fluid game and it needs more integration between defence, midfield and attack - something you get by having at least one fullback who get upfield and create an attacking threat and at least one wide midfielder who can tackle and track back. Hayhurst is very much that latter type of player. Holmes isn't though he does bring other qualities - composure and the ability to deliver a telling pass - which as I indicated earlier makes him more than just a 'winger'.
But basically we have looked at our best this season when we have had Holmes on the right, Hayhurst on the left and two of our roster of strikers upfront. I just wish SG would give that formation a consistent run.
Holmes best position is left sided midfield or winger so playing him on the right is a compromise. SG is giving Humphreys, a player he has tracked for a while, a run in the team and clearly he sees Holmes left and Humphreys right as his first option in a 442. I would expect him to change if Humphreys fails to deliver. I think his approach is logical. Hayhurst will get his chance I am sure. Also, had Holmes not been injured last season and finished the season where he started it, he would have pushed Welsh close for player of the year. I am not sure where the idea, that at 26, Holmes is past it as a winger.
- Joined
- Sep 30, 2012
- Messages
- 1,151
Holmes is far from being a spent force as a left winger. He is one of our better players and will provide a lot of goals this season (injury permitting). I think we should stick with him on the left and Humphrey on the right for the time being. Hayhurst and Monakana aren't bad reserve options. If either Holmes or Humphrey suffer from a bad run of form then bringing Hayhurst in is a good option (particularly away from home IMO).
A few weeks ago, I pointed out the fact that we look to have a little too defensive lineup for home games. I was shot down by many for saying that Welsh and Keane are too defensive. However, I still believe this to be true. I also believe that playing Laird at home wouldn't be a bad call, but I have no issues with the work that SG has done in his time here. Primarily, he wants to make us hard to beat. Something he has definitely done.
A few weeks ago, I pointed out the fact that we look to have a little too defensive lineup for home games. I was shot down by many for saying that Welsh and Keane are too defensive. However, I still believe this to be true. I also believe that playing Laird at home wouldn't be a bad call, but I have no issues with the work that SG has done in his time here. Primarily, he wants to make us hard to beat. Something he has definitely done.
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2012
- Messages
- 68
i would play keane with wroe and drop welsh to the bench for home games
i would play keane with wroe and drop welsh to the bench for home games
You are mad
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2012
- Messages
- 68
You are mad
oh sorry might win then instead of drawing
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2004
- Messages
- 19,671
Only one goal conceded from open play in 4 games suggest that the defensive central midfield players must be doing something right
Aye it does, and 2 goals in 3 games (1 an own goal and 1 a mistake) suggests that they're lacking something going the other way. It's all a balancing act, I just don't think Welsh or Keane have the instinct to go forward on a regular enough basis with the quality required. I just can't see that partnership lasting to much longer (I like both and Clarke btw, so tough decision for Grayson to make).
Holmes is far from being a spent force as a left winger. He is one of our better players and will provide a lot of goals this season (injury permitting). I think we should stick with him on the left and Humphrey on the right for the time being. Hayhurst and Monakana aren't bad reserve options. If either Holmes or Humphrey suffer from a bad run of form then bringing Hayhurst in is a good option (particularly away from home IMO).
A few weeks ago, I pointed out the fact that we look to have a little too defensive lineup for home games. I was shot down by many for saying that Welsh and Keane are too defensive. However, I still believe this to be true. I also believe that playing Laird at home wouldn't be a bad call, but I have no issues with the work that SG has done in his time here. Primarily, he wants to make us hard to beat. Something he has definitely done.
Totally agree. Hard to drop Buchanan or Clarke when we have done well defensively but we need to be able to create from all areas of the park. Grezza wasn't a great defender but offered us more of an option going forward. Laird especially would help with our wing play and would enable us to create more. 2 defensive midfielders was fine in big games we just need to be making the opposition worry about us more than us look at blanking them
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2012
- Messages
- 68
Totally agree. Hard to drop Buchanan or Clarke when we have done well defensively but we need to be able to create from all areas of the park. Grezza wasn't a great defender but offered us more of an option going forward. Laird especially would help with our wing play and would enable us to create more. 2 defensive midfielders was fine in big games we just need to be making the opposition worry about us more than us look at blanking them
+1