Hayhurst
Plenty been said about why we let him out on loan!
Nothing He showed tonight v Fleetwood suggests he would have made any difference.
He produced little in the way of quality. Ben Davies did OK nothing special.
The whole standard was pretty poor to be honest, why this season has been an opportunity lost, sorry another season in this division of drivell does not wet the appetite. 🙁 🙄
Hume did nothing as well! McLaughlin was probably the best of our old/current players on the pitch tonight. I still think he would have done a decent job with us, when you compare him to Wiseman, or having to play Clarke out there.
He has probably found his level, would simply not have coped with the skill, speed and physical side of the game especially last night.
Ben Davies is quality. First choice left back for us next season, as long as he is not banned from the game.....
Hayhurst is not up to it. Been average at best for York and really isn't developing as I thought he would. He has the most frustrating quality of any winger, an inability to cross beyond the first defender be it from set piece or open play. Another season out on loan next year I would have thought.
Conor McLaughlin, solid L2 defender, nothing more.
Hume - was a class apart at Bootham in the first leg when sitting deep. In front of goal though he is awful and has no self-belief anymore. Typified by a one on one that I'd have finished and he dragged horribly wide. Best summed up on twitter when a fan said they had backed him to score first goal and he replied #dontholdyourbreath.
Hayhurst is not up to it. Been average at best for York and really isn't developing as I thought he would. He has the most frustrating quality of any winger, an inability to cross beyond the first defender be it from set piece or open play. Another season out on loan next year I would have thought.
Conor McLaughlin, solid L2 defender, nothing more.
Hume - was a class apart at Bootham in the first leg when sitting deep. In front of goal though he is awful and has no self-belief anymore. Typified by a one on one that I'd have finished and he dragged horribly wide. Best summed up on twitter when a fan said they had backed him to score first goal and he replied #dontholdyourbreath.
Ben Davies looked really good to me and I think he will be first choice next season.
Hayhurst works hard and looked ok ,I think he will do ok when he comes back after the break. Hume not the player he was .Parkin is finished and Mcgloughclan as found his level
Hayhurst works hard and looked ok ,I think he will do ok when he comes back after the break. Hume not the player he was .Parkin is finished and Mcgloughclan as found his level
- Joined
- Aug 5, 2009
- Messages
- 1,150
I have never seen Hayhurst beat a man, he just does not possess the skill or pace to do so. He will probably forge himself a career in either League Two or the Conference.
Ben Davies on the other hand looks like a different player to the skinny young lad Westley chucked into the first team here 18 months ago. Time to start making bold choices if we want these young lads like Davies and Brownhill to progress here, I'd have Davies back as one of two left backs in the squad.
Ben Davies on the other hand looks like a different player to the skinny young lad Westley chucked into the first team here 18 months ago. Time to start making bold choices if we want these young lads like Davies and Brownhill to progress here, I'd have Davies back as one of two left backs in the squad.
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2004
- Messages
- 1,222
But can he move in from fullback and play left side centre half?
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2004
- Messages
- 13,345
But can he move in from fullback and play left side centre half?
That is an interesting thought in the light of Wright's recent performances
But can he move in from fullback and play left side centre half?
i think long term that'll be Ben Davies position and next season in JPT might be the ideal situation to start experimenting with him playing at CB to see how he copes.
Hayhurst is not a 'winger' like, say, Ross Wallace, but a hard-working left-sided midfielder - frankly he is or could become a left-sided Chris Sedgwick. It would have been interesting to see how he might have done in that left-sided position in front of a back three that Laird played to some effect and Buchanan to very little - both are fullbacks not midfielders - in the season just gone. I like the lad and I hope SG is prepared to give him a go next season - I still think he could become an important player for us.
i think long term that'll be Ben Davies position and next season in JPT might be the ideal situation to start experimenting with him playing at CB to see how he copes.
He used to play at CB in our youth team. He also did play there alongside Paul Huntington in a pre-season game last season, so with us signing Nick Anderton from our youth team who plays at LB aswell so I wonder if Ben Davies will be used as our young Reserve CB next season.
He used to play at CB in our youth team. He also did play there alongside Paul Huntington in a pre-season game last season, so with us signing Nick Anderton from our youth team who plays at LB aswell so I wonder if Ben Davies will be used as our young Reserve CB next season.
Anderton is another player i think who could play as a left sided CB, i saw Chorley a couple of times towards the end of the season and due to the fact Chorley had a LB on loan from Fleetwood called Max Cartwright, who looked a class above Northern premier league level, Anderton was a sub when i saw Chorley play and when he came on he usually played at CB + i'm sure he played in CM once.
Davies and Anderton are low risk players interms of being able to play more than 1 position whilst being on low wages so only taking a tiny % out of the wage budget, if it turns out they're not good enough for L1 it should be easy to shift them due to low wages but if they do grab the opportunity and perform well, like Brownhill + Browne have done this season, they'll look extremely good value for money.
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2004
- Messages
- 13,345
Hayhurst is 20 FFS. Very young to be written off. I'd like to see him loaned out again next year til jan then see where he's at. The fact that he's playing week in week out is brilliant for his development
Agreed. He is not yet ready for our first team and often was not in York's starting eleven. He certainly has ability but. at the moment, he invariably over-hits his crosses and passes.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2004
- Messages
- 3,130
To be honest, from what I've seen, Hayhurst's delivery is frequently better than that of many of the players currently in our first team. It certainly must be better than that of the rest of the York team as well, as they had Hayhurst taking the majority of their set pieces while he was there!
Plenty of potential in this player yet, and I think he has a good future. He forms part of a nucleus of decent young talents within the ranks when you consider we have the likes of him, Ben Davies, Croasdale, Brownhill, Browne, Ryan, Nicholson etc.
They may not all ultimately make it, but they represent our best result from the youth policy for a long time, in years past we've maybe given a 12 month deal to one or two and they've been gone 12 months later.....
Plenty of potential in this player yet, and I think he has a good future. He forms part of a nucleus of decent young talents within the ranks when you consider we have the likes of him, Ben Davies, Croasdale, Brownhill, Browne, Ryan, Nicholson etc.
They may not all ultimately make it, but they represent our best result from the youth policy for a long time, in years past we've maybe given a 12 month deal to one or two and they've been gone 12 months later.....
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2004
- Messages
- 13,345
To be honest, from what I've seen, Hayhurst's delivery is frequently better than that of many of the players currently in our first team. It certainly must be better than that of the rest of the York team as well, as they had Hayhurst taking the majority of their set pieces while he was there!
Plenty of potential in this player yet, and I think he has a good future. He forms part of a nucleus of decent young talents within the ranks when you consider we have the likes of him, Ben Davies, Croasdale, Brownhill, Browne, Ryan, Nicholson etc.
They may not all ultimately make it, but they represent our best result from the youth policy for a long time, in years past we've maybe given a 12 month deal to one or two and they've been gone 12 months later.....
It will be interesting to see whether Croasdale and Nicholson are retained.