Skip to main content

Highlights

Highlights

In this instance, Kilkenny could claim that he got an apparently minor but painful blow to the throat/adam's apple. He might even be telling the truth, though I'd doubt it. He was struck (apparenly with all the force of a hamster) in the jaw/throat area. Would he be found guily of simulation? In this case, probably yes... but you get the point.

He could claim that, but the video for me clearly shows that it was a very delayed reaction. And he wasn't smacked. Not a proper smack. If it were a proper smack then based on his reaction to that smack he would have died.
 
To me, Garner is 1 or 2 yards in front of the penalty spot = 7/8 yds into the area too.

Although first view would say that the guy beyond the back stick is not playing him on... I'd also say that he looks to be at least 7/8 yds from the edge of the area!

EDIT... actually, if you watch the video a few times... AFTER the ball's been flicked on, that guy is fairly stationary... he takes a 2 or 3 short steps towards his own goal, and suddenly he's only a couple of yards outside the 6yd box... suggesting he was deeper into his own box than first appears. It is so difficult to judge on that 2D, distant photo.

Having at first thought Garner was probably just off side, having watched the movement of the left back a few times, I'm now thinking that he was probably ONside. I'd certainly say that Garner was pretty unlucky to be flagged for that - but not clearcut

garnervbradford_zpsb7eb8b71.jpg

It really is very close. We've seen a number of goals that look far more offside than that given but, lets face it, we'd be fucking fuming if that had been given against us!
 
Back
Top