Was it just me or did anyone else notice Holmes playing in CM towards the end of the game just before he had his shot against the post with Wroe playing as a Right winger,if so could it work again with Holmes playing in CM alongside either Welsh or Keane ?
Holmes in CM ?
No mate it wouldn't
No mate it wouldn't
Ok thanks just a idea on my part.
Ok thanks just a idea on my part.
He is a very good player but need him out wide. Need him on both wings
I noticed it and thought he did okay. For me he is by far our most creative player but only played there due to the presence of Hayhurst and Buchanan on the left side. Gareth Bale seems to have assumed this CAM role at Tottenham and has had great success there. Possibly a consideration but I'm not sure whether a 15 minute cameo vs Crewe in that position is enough to consider this.
I would much rather we played players in their correct positions and hopefully signed a good passer of the ball to play between the midfield and forwards for next season. We seem to lack the sort of player who can pick a pass and this is a must for me as Wroe has been poor weeks now and Mousinho isn't up to it.
I would much rather we played players in their correct positions and hopefully signed a good passer of the ball to play between the midfield and forwards for next season. We seem to lack the sort of player who can pick a pass and this is a must for me as Wroe has been poor weeks now and Mousinho isn't up to it.
- Joined
- Dec 30, 2009
- Messages
- 1,983
I noticed it and thought he did okay. For me he is by far our most creative player but only played there due to the presence of Hayhurst and Buchanan on the left side. Gareth Bale seems to have assumed this CAM role at Tottenham and has had great success there. Possibly a consideration but I'm not sure whether a 15 minute cameo vs Crewe in that position is enough to consider this.
I would much rather we played players in their correct positions and hopefully signed a good passer of the ball to play between the midfield and forwards for next season. We seem to lack the sort of player who can pick a pass and this is a must for me as Wroe has been poor weeks now and Mousinho isn't up to it.
Excellent post Wicker. Ill bet there's not many better individual players in league 1 than Homes in League 1 so why not use him in a midfield position. I guess one might argue about who delivers the killer balls if he plays centre mid , at least he can still take the corners.
Excellent post Wicker. Ill bet there's not many better individual players in league 1 than Homes in League 1 so why not use him in a midfield position. I guess one might argue about who delivers the killer balls if he plays centre mid , at least he can still take the corners.
The problem with that is he can't tackle and to be honest is a bit soft. He would be ok th the point of a diamond formation, playing behind 2 strikers (did he do this at Coventry in JPT?). However, he couldn't play as one of 2 centre midfielders.
No - we need a higher class, more consistent partner for Welsh than Wroe but pulling Holmes out of position would not be the answer. Frankly in the longer term this is something we need to address in the transfer market. But in the meantime we have to find a workable midfield partnership for this Saturday. So assuming Welsh is back who should partner him? I would like to see King in his proper position with one or other of Ganrner and Cummins partnering Beavon upfront. The alternative is Welsh with either Wroe or Keane with King back upfront with Beavon.
- Joined
- Feb 19, 2011
- Messages
- 687
Not trying to cause on argument, but what would this thread be like if it was Graham Westley who had moved Lee Holmes into CM?
Yes, he was fairly effective there yesterday - but only when he was given acres of space by Crewe. His effort which hit the post was laughable defending. He turned and couldn't believe his luck, he had a free run right to the edge of their penalty area! Great shot though, very unlucky not to hit the back of the net.
My point is Lee Holmes is a winger. One of the biggest criticisms of the last two managers has been the whole square peg in a round hole issue, so why are we even considering the fact Lee Holmes could play through the middle? Left wing or right wing is his position and he should stick to it.
Yes, he was fairly effective there yesterday - but only when he was given acres of space by Crewe. His effort which hit the post was laughable defending. He turned and couldn't believe his luck, he had a free run right to the edge of their penalty area! Great shot though, very unlucky not to hit the back of the net.
My point is Lee Holmes is a winger. One of the biggest criticisms of the last two managers has been the whole square peg in a round hole issue, so why are we even considering the fact Lee Holmes could play through the middle? Left wing or right wing is his position and he should stick to it.