Skip to main content

Hope I'm Wrong But!!!

Hope I'm Wrong But!!!

So you only relate success to being in the top flight for at least one season in the last 50+ years. You mention a team like Notts County who have spent one season in the top flight since 1984. For the last twenty years they have been confined entirely to the bottom two divisions. I wouldnt deem that 'success' to be honest - more like torture. Don't get me wrong, I do understand we are all envious of our local neighbours all having top flight experiences in the last decade, but it won't mean much to Wigan and Blackpool fans who are gracing League One next year.

It is a dream fulfilled

I can't say the same for us
 
It is a dream fulfilled I can't say the same for us
Sure but probably better to dream of one year in the premiership than endure the actual reality of it. Which is getting caned week after week and struggling to get 30pts all season. I doubt there are many Notts County fans walking around after 20 years in the wildernss with big smiles and fuzzy hearts because they achieved the 'dream'.
 
Sure but probably better to dream of one year in the premiership than endure the actual reality of it. Which is getting caned week after week and struggling to get 30pts all season. I doubt there are many Notts County fans walking around after 20 years in the wildernss with big smiles and fuzzy hearts because they achieved the 'dream'.

I hear what you are saying but I think it is telling that I've never known supporters so despondent - hopes dashed again!
 
All the eras you mention were unfulfilled promise...

Success?

Burnley, Rovers, Blackpool, Bolton, Wigan, Bradford, Portsmouth, Stoke, Bournemouth, Barnsley, Cardiff, Swansea, Bristol City, Northampton, Carlisle, Oxford, Luton, Wimbledon, Notts County...

Those are examples of teams who have achieved something which I believe I will never see at North End. Top flight football.

And they're off the top of my head, I'm sure there are plenty of other unfashionable teams who've made it since the mid sixties. The first 5 names there are especially important.


Still not 'talking sense?'

No you are not talking sense at all. Do my eyes deceive me, or have you really put Blackpool in your list of clubs who have been more successful than PNE? Really?

It is clear you regard success as spending a period of time in the greedy league. Well can I suggest your post should have said that instead of 'success'. I challenge you to front up Sean Gregan an tell him the League one trophy he lifted was not the result of a successful season. What was it?

Do I presume you don't acknowledge the successes you have witnessed as listed by me?

As I final point, I can tell you without doubt that just getting to the greedy league will not be seen as success if its ever achieved. The proof of that pudding are Bolton and Charlton. Two clubs not unlike ours who got there and stayed there for a good while. All of a sudden, mid table in the greedy wasn't success. A top seven finish with top players to watch at Bolton wasn't success. The managers had 'taken the clubs as far as they could' and the deluded fans wanted them gone. They got their wishes.

No fella, getting to the greedy league is not the only thing that means 'success'.

As a final point, ten of the clubs you mention are now worse off than us. Four of them have even dropped out of the league. Successful?
 
It is a dream fulfilled

I can't say the same for us

Wake up please. If the price of a one year dream stay (getting walloped most weeks) in the greedy league is what Blackpool fans are paying now, and most of the teams in your list have experienced then leave us out.
 
Wake up please. If the price of a one year dream stay (getting walloped most weeks) in the greedy league is what Blackpool fans are paying now, and most of the teams in your list have experienced then leave us out.

It is clear we aren't going to agree. What is 'sense' to you, isn't 'sense' to me.

I understand your perspective but I feel that we have reached a watershed in terms of how much persistent underachievement our fan base can sustain. I can assure you that I'll be there next season whatever division we are in. Regrettably the same cannot be said of many people I know. And don't quote the demise of Blackpool to me, if we lose more of our fan base it's not inconceivable that we could finish up in League 2.
 
And don't quote the demise of Blackpool to me, if we lose more of our fan base it's not inconceivable that we could finish up in League 2.
"Lose more of our fan base"? Attendances were up for the second season running this year, after reaching their nadir under Westley.
 
Th hasn't sold the club, which was supposed to be his intention. I've got a feeling we will make some decent signings next season and we will all move on and fall back in love with the club again.
 
Th hasn't sold the club, which was supposed to be his intention. I've got a feeling we will make some decent signings next season and we will all move on and fall back in love with the club again.

You've got a feeling? Oh well, it's definite then.
 
Wake up please. If the price of a one year dream stay (getting walloped most weeks) in the greedy league is what Blackpool fans are paying now, and most of the teams in your list have experienced then leave us out.

You have to try for the top league and don't forget we have had all the lower league crap, including applying for re-election without the experience of that top league for so long.Wigan may be on the way down but several years of top flight football and an FA cup win doesn't sound too shabby to me.
 
Their what?......... Haven't been around that long then have you?
Yeah, I wasn't going back 30 years. 🙂

Since we've been in League 1 this time around, crowds dropped at first, but the last 2 seasons they have risen.

People seem to think they've been dropping constantly year-on-year - they haven't.
 
Yeah, I wasn't going back 30 years. 🙂

Since we've been in League 1 this time around, crowds dropped at first, but the last 2 seasons they have risen.

People seem to think they've been dropping constantly year-on-year - they haven't.

But that's not what you said......... You said that we hit rock bottom with Westley......Which is completely untrue.
 
But that's not what you said......... You said that we hit rock bottom with Westley......Which is completely untrue.
I just clarified - I'm talking about our descent into League 1 - not our entire league history.

Crowds have been trending upwards the last 2 seasons, not downwards. They were going downwards, but they bottomed out under Westley.

Don't think I can be any clearer without drawing a graph or something. Which I'm not going to do.
 
I just clarified - I'm talking about our descent into League 1 - not our entire league history.

Crowds have been trending upwards the last 2 seasons, not downwards. They were going downwards, but they bottomed out under Westley.

Don't think I can be any clearer without drawing a graph or something. Which I'm not going to do.

I know what you said and so do you..... Just hold up your hand when you drop a bollock....There's really no need for the deflection...
 
I know what you said and so do you..... Just hold up your hand when you drop a bollock....There's really no need for the deflection...
No idea what you're on about, sorry. But if you want to keep beating the dead horse, feel free.
 
I just clarified - I'm talking about our descent into League 1 - not our entire league history.

Crowds have been trending upwards the last 2 seasons, not downwards. They were going downwards, but they bottomed out under Westley.

Don't think I can be any clearer without drawing a graph or something. Which I'm not going to do.

Look, I don't want to keep going over this one but I've been supporting North End a long time and I know of more than a few who follow them home and away who say they can't take any more. There is a number in Chorley who follow them all over the country who have elected to go to watch Chorley in the play-offs on Saturday and not bother going on Sunday. Why?
Because they say they can't take the heartache.
 
Back
Top