Skip to main content

How long comparison.

How long comparison.

Last 4 managers.

Ferguson
Brown
Westley
Grayson

Who do you trust most to manage us at this level? Only Westley hasn't had the chance at this level. I selected the last 4 only as they have all suffered, to varying degrees, the financial fallout of Saint Alans ineptitude whilst at the reigns of PNE.

Grayson by a landslide.
 
I think it's rather unfair comparing Ferguson with Grayson. Whilst I'm not Grayson's biggest fan I feel he has more tactical nouse than Ferguson will ever have. Also in my humble opinion the standard of the Championship is much higher than it was so difficult to compare records.


I disagree and don't know where this seemingly popular view is coming from.
 
I disagree and don't know where this seemingly popular view is coming from.

Maybe the fact that over half of the teams here have had increased parachute payments since we were last here 5 years ago?

Hardly a level playing field eh Libby?
 
Maybe the fact that over half of the teams here have had increased parachute payments since we were last here 5 years ago?

Hardly a level playing field eh Libby?


I certainly agree that it's not a level playing field anymore but there were some bloody good football teams in the Championship the last time we were in it... Some better than the ones now........ Perhaps this parachute money has done bugger all for the improvement/standard of teams , just a bloody big increase in transfer fees and wages?........ And therefore conned us into believing it's better.
 
I certainly agree that it's not a level playing field anymore but there were some bloody good football teams in the Championship the last time we were in it... Some better than the ones now........ Perhaps this parachute money has done bugger all for the improvement/standard of teams , just a bloody big increase in transfer fees and wages?........ And therefore conned us into believing it's better.
Perhaps not better but definitely, with the financial backing, the quality has moved upwards. will we ever be in a position to compete? Definitely not financially.
 
There's no point in keeping someone long term who doesn't learn lessons from past experiences. Grayson has failed twice in the championship already and is failing again.

What's his record in the last 20 championship games, one win isn't it?

That says it all.

I'd sack him today, but I think he's got about 3 games left. Rumours are that we're sniffing for a new manager

I'd guess that the club will start putting the feelers out to see who is available and/or who wants to come very soon if this dismal run continues.


Last 4 managers.

Ferguson
Brown
Westley
Grayson

Who do you trust most to manage us at this level? Only Westley hasn't had the chance at this level. I selected the last 4 only as they have all suffered, to varying degrees, the financial fallout of Saint Alans ineptitude whilst at the reigns of PNE.

Grayson by a landslide.

This is why people like myself suggested a possible new system including a DoF or Technical director. Every manager since Irvine has had to work on a tight budget because of what happened. We're one of the less financially-able clubs in the league, can we afford to let every new boss rebuild ?

As for your other point, yes, Grayson by a landslide, but being better than Ferguson, Brown and Westley isn't difficult and doesn't necessarily mean he's good enough to lead us in the Championship.


I disagree and don't know where this seemingly popular view is coming from.

The figures with transfers and wages have increased, so people automatically assume the quality has. Personally I think the quality is around about the same, just the transfer figures have inflated since we were last in the Championship.

Also, because we are struggling, people assume the quality has increased. Maybe we are just worse than we use to be ? Probably. Our current squad is a long way off the one Billy took on a 20+ unbeaten run at this level. We have a long way to go to get back to that standard again.
 
I think it's rather unfair comparing Ferguson with Grayson. Whilst I'm not Grayson's biggest fan I feel he has more tactical nouse than Ferguson will ever have. Also in my humble opinion the standard of the Championship is much higher than it was so difficult to compare records.

I didn't compare the two in terms of tactics, just results. I'm judging our club now against it's performance last time we were relegated from this division. That's not just about the management; it's also about the players and the owner's investment.

The point I made that three of our defenders back then were individually better than any defender we have now is surely more relevant given the point you make about the standards in the Championship having risen in the last 5 years?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Perhaps not better but definitely, with the financial backing, the quality has moved upwards. will we ever be in a position to compete? Definitely not financially.


We never were.... But Moyes and Davies got us knocking on the door against some top notch teams.And we gave them a run for their money....Almost !! 🙂
 
I'd guess that the club will start putting the feelers out to see who is available and/or who wants to come very soon if this dismal run continues.




This is why people like myself suggested a possible new system including a DoF or Technical director. Every manager since Irvine has had to work on a tight budget because of what happened. We're one of the less financially-able clubs in the league, can we afford to let every new boss rebuild ?

As for your other point, yes, Grayson by a landslide, but being better than Ferguson, Brown and Westley isn't difficult and doesn't necessarily mean he's good enough to lead us in the Championship.




The figures with transfers and wages have increased, so people automatically assume the quality has. Personally I think the quality is around about the same, just the transfer figures have inflated since we were last in the Championship.

Also, because we are struggling, people assume the quality has increased. Maybe we are just worse than we use to be ? Probably. Our current squad is a long way off the one Billy took on a 20+ unbeaten run at this level. We have a long way to go to get back to that standard again.


We do indeed.... And if the signing of May for a million is anything to go by ( I hope he eventually proves his worth ) then we are heading in the wrong direction.
 
Unlike many of our recent previous managers I actually like Simon Grayson. When Sir Tom passed away I thought Grayson and the club as a whole conducted themselves with great dignity and I was pleased it was someone like Grayson who was in charge at the time. He is a decent bloke and has been a very good figure head for the club after the debacle of the medal winners era. He was a steady calming influence and ultimately brought us the play off victory that we all craved.

Beckford was an inspired signing and despite his illness something just works with Grayson. Daniel Johnson has also been a tremendous signing and it has been a good while since we signed someone young with the potential to make us some serious money in the future.

He was very close to getting the boot during January and had we not got that result at Sheff Utd I think he would have been a goner. There is no doubt that the result that night sent us on a great run of results (putting aside the garbage at Colchester) which culminated with one of the most memorable days I've ever had at Wembley.

This season was always going to be a tough one for the club and I don't think Simon has been helped by some interference and dithering by others in the transfer window one win in ten speaks for itself. Non of our strikers have scored in the league and lets be honest we don't look like scoring more than one in a league game any time soon. Gallagher & Beckford have been a huge miss and we also got robbed blind by Trevor Kettle but we just don't look anywhere near good enough and I'm struggling to see Simon changing his defensive first tactics (which just don't work in the championship).

Preston North End can not afford to get relegated again, financially it would be a disaster and I think our fan base would drop even lower.

Back to the question in hand. The only way we are going to stay in this league is if we start winning our home games and have a go at teams. Yes we won't win every game but I do believe whilst the squad is clearly not good enough to challenge at the top end it is good enough to stay in the league. Simon's Presser after Sheff Wed worried me but I hope just like back in January he can turn around the slide and push us on in the league.

However if we lose on Saturday in a similar manner to previous losses I don't think anyone could grumble if Trevor pulls the plug, I think the club will have been very naïve not to be looking at their options. December would be too late to change managers again.....

We have to stay up..... Do I believe that we will achieve that under Grayson? I honestly don't know and that is what worries me.
 
Last 4 managers.

Ferguson
Brown
Westley
Grayson

Who do you trust most to manage us at this level? Only Westley hasn't had the chance at this level. I selected the last 4 only as they have all suffered, to varying degrees, the financial fallout of Saint Alans ineptitude whilst at the reigns of PNE.

Grayson by a landslide.
I don't see your point with this list? So we have had three really really poor managers, does that mean we have to accept anyone that is better than them, but could take us down again?

Grayson has us one foot in defeat before we step on the pitch due to his negativity.

Yes he got us promoted. Yes it was a great day out. Yes he acts more proffessional than previous managers. Yes he is more structured.

But his negativity will take us down if he cannot play a more attacking game and allow the players to create more positive play.
 
Unlike many of our recent previous managers I actually like Simon Grayson. When Sir Tom passed away I thought Grayson and the club as a whole conducted themselves with great dignity and I was pleased it was someone like Grayson who was in charge at the time. He is a decent bloke and has been a very good figure head for the club after the debacle of the medal winners era. He was a steady calming influence and ultimately brought us the play off victory that we all craved.

Beckford was an inspired signing and despite his illness something just works with Grayson. Daniel Johnson has also been a tremendous signing and it has been a good while since we signed someone young with the potential to make us some serious money in the future.

He was very close to getting the boot during January and had we not got that result at Sheff Utd I think he would have been a goner. There is no doubt that the result that night sent us on a great run of results (putting aside the garbage at Colchester) which culminated with one of the most memorable days I've ever had at Wembley.

This season was always going to be a tough one for the club and I don't think Simon has been helped by some interference and dithering by others in the transfer window one win in ten speaks for itself. Non of our strikers have scored in the league and lets be honest we don't look like scoring more than one in a league game any time soon. Gallagher & Beckford have been a huge miss and we also got robbed blind by Trevor Kettle but we just don't look anywhere near good enough and I'm struggling to see Simon changing his defensive first tactics (which just don't work in the championship).

Preston North End can not afford to get relegated again, financially it would be a disaster and I think our fan base would drop even lower.

Back to the question in hand. The only way we are going to stay in this league is if we start winning our home games and have a go at teams. Yes we won't win every game but I do believe whilst the squad is clearly not good enough to challenge at the top end it is good enough to stay in the league. Simon's Presser after Sheff Wed worried me but I hope just like back in January he can turn around the slide and push us on in the league.

However if we lose on Saturday in a similar manner to previous losses I don't think anyone could grumble if Trevor pulls the plug, I think the club will have been very naïve not to be looking at their options. December would be too late to change managers again.....

We have to stay up..... Do I believe that we will achieve that under Grayson? I honestly don't know and that is what worries me.

Good post, pretty much where I am at.

I just cannot see Grayson changeing his defensive play, and I cannot see the poor defensive tactics keeping us up.

Get Warnock in.
 
I don't see your point with this list? So we have had three really really poor managers, does that mean we have to accept anyone that is better than them, but could take us down again?

Grayson has us one foot in defeat before we step on the pitch due to his negativity.

Yes he got us promoted. Yes it was a great day out. Yes he acts more proffessional than previous managers. Yes he is more structured.

But his negativity will take us down if he cannot play a more attacking game and allow the players to create more positive play.

I was pointing out

a) What we can afford.
b) What area we will be shopping in if Grayson goes.

A bit grim really, isn't it?
 
Good post, pretty much where I am at.

I just cannot see Grayson changeing his defensive play, and I cannot see the poor defensive tactics keeping us up.

Get Warnock in.

Warnock has retired. So he said on talkSPORT anyway.
 
I was pointing out

a) What we can afford.
b) What area we will be shopping in if Grayson goes.

A bit grim really, isn't it?
I'd like to think we have been through a transition period. It's no secret that we had a team full of journeymen on huge wages, they were potted by Westley and we have moved on from that low point. Therefore with the money gained by promotion we may have a slightly healthier wallet than in recent years to attract better.
 
JK said:
However if we lose on Saturday in a similar manner to previous losses I don't think anyone could grumble if Trevor pulls the plug, I think the club will have been very naïve not to be looking at their options. December would be too late to change managers again.....

You think he is that close?

Inside whisper or gut feeling?
 
You think he is that close?

Inside whisper or gut feeling?
I can't see him lasting much longer, just gut feeling.

The sad thing is I would love nothing more for him to turn it around and realise he has to try and win, rather than try and not get beat!
 
Would potting Grayson upset the togetherness and spirit within the dressing room that has been built by him?

If he was to go the only person I would look at would be Karl Robinson, plays very good football on a shoestring budget and knows how to use the premiership loan market effectively.

Attracting players to PNE compared to MK dons could see him build quite a competitive squad.
 
Back
Top