Skip to main content

How long ......

How long ......

Joined
Aug 15, 2005
Messages
18,402
Location
Newcastle
do we accept survival/mediocrity/consolidation (choose your word) in this league?

This isn't an anti Grayson thread topic it's a genuine question that I'd like to know peoples views on. What do you think? the end of this season?, another 2 or 3 seasons? or for all eternity?

At some point most people will want to see progression to the next step and I guess we all have different perspectives but for most there will be a limit on accepting siurvival so what do you think? I guess the next step is to be punching in or around the PO's and being a big hitter in this league like we were under Davies.
 
2 seasons of ensuring that we remain in this division & continue to build . Then I'd expect that we will be established and in a position to challenge for the play offs. There is no quick fix & the landscape of the Championship has changed a hell of a lot since the days of Billy Davies
 
I think the league has moved on since we were in the playoffs with BD. We're struggling to compete with the clubs that have parachute payments, even Wigan are currently in their last season of getting parachute payments and that is why they are able to play much higher wages than we do, Wildschut was on £16K a week in League 1! The TV money that the clubs in the prem get is just ridiculous so when they come back down in to the Championship it isn't a level playing field. The inflation on wages have meant all clubs have had to increase admission prices which in turn keeps fans away.
yes, the argument is there that if we were banging in 5 goals a game and at the top of the league then the gates would increase but the trouble is getting those players to come to the club.

1 of 3 things need to happen to keep people happy:
1. Hemmings allows Grayson to go on a mass spending spree.
2. Investment from abroad comes in to the club.
3. Fans need to lower their expectations

For now survival/consolidation is the way forward as going back in to League 1 would be a disaster that would take a lot longer than last time to recover from.
 
2 seasons of ensuring that we remain in this division & continue to build . Then I'd expect that we will be established and in a position to challenge for the play offs. There is no quick fix & the landscape of the Championship has changed a hell of a lot since the days of Billy Davies

That seems entirely reasonable in all honesty. I hope most folks have similair timescales in mind!
 
We're about the 40th biggest club in the country when ranked by home attendance - the traditional way of ranking a club's relative size.

All things being equal, our natural home is in the bottom half of the Championship, and the answer to how long we should "accept" that is self-evidently: "indefinitely".

Of course, all things are often not equal, but not in our favour.

Nevertheless, there'll be seasons - if we develop our younger players, improve others, and can get the team to click - when we can over-achieve and punch above our weight in this division.

But I don't think we'll ever be "a big hitter" in the Championship unless something was to dramatically change in terms of investment in the playing squad and e.g. youth facilities, etc.
 
2 seasons of ensuring that we remain in this division & continue to build . Then I'd expect that we will be established and in a position to challenge for the play offs. There is no quick fix & the landscape of the Championship has changed a hell of a lot since the days of Billy Davies

Over used term by PNE, we are a more established builder than Redrow, we have been at it since the days of Peters, Moyes etc. in the meantime a lot of our rivals have visited the promised land.
 
Over used term by PNE, we are a more established builder than Redrow, we have been at it since the days of Peters, Moyes etc. in the meantime a lot of our rivals have visited the promised land.

I'd agree, the only way to effectively `build` is to mimic the other clubs that have achieved promotion to the prem and accessed the pot of gold. Then we're in the game.
 
The difficulty is that the division has moved on ridiculously since we were "big hitters" under the dwarf - with the money washing about in the top division, those with parachute payments or wealthy benefactors (or at least those with wealthy benefactors willing to throw cash around) are queuing up to take the top places every year. Deadline day this year was almost repulsive in the expenditure of mid level clubs on average players.

It will get to the stage soon that the teams coming down will have such a financial advantage over the rest of the division that every year will see them bounce back.

I can't see how we can possibly compete with that unless the money dries up higher up. Even if we are able to find and develop decent players on the cheap, they will easily be cherry picked by the higher ups.

God that's depressing but it seems I'm in the "grateful to be here" camp...
 
The difficulty is that the division has moved on ridiculously since we were "big hitters" under the dwarf - with the money washing about in the top division, those with parachute payments or wealthy benefactors (or at least those with wealthy benefactors willing to throw cash around) are queuing up to take the top places every year. Deadline day this year was almost repulsive in the expenditure of mid level clubs on average players.

It will get to the stage soon that the teams coming down will have such a financial advantage over the rest of the division that every year will see them bounce back.

I can't see how we can possibly compete with that unless the money dries up higher up. Even if we are able to find and develop decent players on the cheap, they will easily be cherry picked by the higher ups.

God that's depressing but it seems I'm in the "grateful to be here" camp...

The money being thrown about has increased no doubt about it but I'm not sure the standard has increased so if we could compete then I don't see why we can't now in all honesty. Its been done by others so surely this has to be our aim? If thats punching above our weight then so be it. There wre also parachute payments back then so its never really been a level playing field in the contemporary era.

lol at the depressing admission but fair enough 🙂
 
I have been supporting PNE since the days when Jimmy Milne was manager, this does not make me a better supporter than anyone else, it just means I have been around longer than some. But genuinely if the competitive nature of football is being lost due to money, the dream of seeing PNE play in the top flight is becoming ever more distant, survivalist dull defensive football is on offer, are we coming to a time which provokes the thought why bother?
 
I have been supporting PNE since the days when Jimmy Milne was manager, this does not make me a better supporter than anyone else, it just means I have been around longer than some. But genuinely if the competitive nature of football is being lost due to money, the dream of seeing PNE play in the top flight is becoming ever more distant, survivalist dull defensive football is on offer, are we coming to a time which provokes the thought why bother?

I feel your pain sir! My first match was in 77/78 season and there has been few highs in that time but you're right the acceptance of survival against the odds does sap your motivation a tad. I think I may be entering into the stage of ambivilance!
 
I guess the next step is to be punching in or around the PO's and being a big hitter in this league like we were under Davies.

That's odd, the other day you said the next step was the Premier League and that was why you wanted Grayson out.

Oh and we'd been in this division for 4 seasons before we became a 'big hitter....under Davies'. So why do you expect us to be there in 18 months this time around?
 
A lot of people are put off by the threatening atmosphere at some of our games , example Reading at the start of the season , Blackpool with the pitch invasion . Just look at rugby for a good example of family entertainment . A friendly atmosphere would go along way in correcting falling gate receipts
 
For any one of those words, the answer is as long as it takes for us to become solid enough to start contemplating pushing on.

As good as last season was for us, it was a massive overachievement. I said to my mate in the close season that if he offered me 21st this season I'd take it in a heartbeat because the worst thing that can happen to us at the minute is that we start getting ideas above our station too soon, spend money we don't have on players that we can't really afford and fall back down the pyramid with vast debts and financial problems - see Bolton, Portsmouth, Plymouth and soon Blackburn to see just how bad it can get.

For what it's worth, I'd be satisfied as long as we aren't relegated in the next few seasons too, as long as we aren't as close to the battle as 21st. We are far from guaranteed safety - look at the calibre of teams that are in this league, they're all solid - but how many can realistically challenge for promotion or even the playoffs? The ones that can throw money around like Newcastle, and the ones that have survived year upon year and consolidated, like Ipswich. There's only really one option for us out of those two, and Grayson is no Benitez - he's more of a McCarthy.

Obviously Hemmings said what he said after Wembley, and now that he isn't fulfilling that promise some are turning, which I can understand as people shouldn't take being lied to. However, he might have not been as forthcoming with his cash as we all might have liked this season, but I think it's pretty safe to say him being forthcoming with it in the recent past is one of, if not the main reason PNE is a healthy club today. If not for him, this debate would not be possible, and we should trust in the way he wants to run the club - that isn't to say we can't have ambition, more that we should get behind the club and see what that does for us instead of wishing loss onto our team or staying away.

There will eventually come a time when even the most reasoned of fans will demand more than survival, but by then we will be in a position to actually challenge, not just rack up debts and fall away aimlessly. How long will it take? Who knows. But if you care about the club, you'll be willing to give it time.
 
The money being thrown about has increased no doubt about it but I'm not sure the standard has increased so if we could compete then I don't see why we can't now in all honesty. Its been done by others so surely this has to be our aim? If thats punching above our weight then so be it. There wre also parachute payments back then so its never really been a level playing field in the contemporary era.

lol at the depressing admission but fair enough 🙂

I'd agree that the standard hasn't increased but unfortunately the money has, to an extent that we cannot possibly keep up. When a club without parachute payments can afford to pay £5m for Adam Reach it just shows how far adrift we are. That's the reason we can't complete now. I simply cannot see how we could pick up the likes of Mawene, Fuller or Nugent these days without someone waving a bigger wad at them.
 
When a club without parachute payments can afford to pay £5m for Adam Reach it just shows how far adrift we are. That's the reason we can't complete now. I simply cannot see how we could pick up the likes of Mawene, Fuller or Nugent these days without someone waving a bigger wad at them.

And then play him left back!!!
 
That's odd, the other day you said the next step was the Premier League and that was why you wanted Grayson out.

Oh and we'd been in this division for 4 seasons before we became a 'big hitter....under Davies'. So why do you expect us to be there in 18 months this time around?

Thats the ultimate goal Tino but progression is needed before we can achieve that. I'm not getting drawn into a Grayson debate as you are well aware of what I think on that issue. So your answer is 4 seasons. ok.
 
Back
Top