Hugill
Was just a large garner today , very likable but just lacking in ability
Could Hugill do a greganesque type in role? Just wondering?
- Joined
- Jun 9, 2004
- Messages
- 10,618
Physically he showed he's willing to get his hands dirty and take the hits. The goal was brave.
He just doesn't have the talent for me. A useful (and cheap) stop gap perhaps but he's never going to be a regular starter.
That said, I though Andy Carroll had nothing about him when he was here either.
He just doesn't have the talent for me. A useful (and cheap) stop gap perhaps but he's never going to be a regular starter.
That said, I though Andy Carroll had nothing about him when he was here either.
- Joined
- Jun 2, 2015
- Messages
- 18,711
NoCould Hugill do a greganesque type in role? Just wondering?
- Joined
- Jun 28, 2004
- Messages
- 6,057
Hugill has a couple of attributes you can't coach - bravery and that ability to be in the right place at the right time.
It's a shame that big elements of his game aren't at Championship level. Hope that can change.
Credit to Grayson for taking a chance on him, and credit to the lad - immense goal today to change the game at the cost of nearly getting his head kicked off.
It's a shame that big elements of his game aren't at Championship level. Hope that can change.
Credit to Grayson for taking a chance on him, and credit to the lad - immense goal today to change the game at the cost of nearly getting his head kicked off.
Doyle ahead of him all day long for me.
He needs to stop giving away blatant fouls. Touch is generally poor although he did pull off one piece of skill on the half way line. Can't fault his effort and bravery.
I can understand though why Grayson will pick Hugill ahead of Doyle as he fits Grayson's style of football better.
He needs to stop giving away blatant fouls. Touch is generally poor although he did pull off one piece of skill on the half way line. Can't fault his effort and bravery.
I can understand though why Grayson will pick Hugill ahead of Doyle as he fits Grayson's style of football better.
Could Hugill do a greganesque type in role? Just wondering?
Really? Had you been drinking?
- Joined
- Aug 23, 2015
- Messages
- 4,634
Great work rate today but I just don't see it tbh, can't see him ever starting games on a regular basis at this level.
Likable guy but the lacks the quality for me.
Agree. A brave and important goal yesterday but long term I don't think he's good enough.
Could Hugill do a greganesque type in role? Just wondering?
In a word, no.
I can understand though why Grayson will pick Hugill ahead of Doyle as he fits Grayson's style of football better.
I think SG spent a lot of this season picking Doyle ahead of Hugill. But is Doyle now after a rather a long time suddenly 'clicking'?
- Joined
- Feb 13, 2005
- Messages
- 2,162
It was a Hugill type game yesterday where he was up against some strong defenders and needed to shield and lay off the ball to the runners. Thought he put in a good shift and his work rate couldn't be faulted. His early header was a good move and he beat his man comfortably. For the goal he was brave in putting his head in a danger zone.
Only disappointment when just before he was subbed he went down in the box and some bright spark in front of me was screaming 'get up you lazy c**t'. I thought it was a Bolton fan infiltrating until the same individual claimed that if you put him in a north end shirt he'd play a better game. Judging by his girth, I doubt he would have survived the warm up. Poor form from a north end fan. No problems with people giving their opinions on here but players giving their all don't deserve that type of abuse from their own supporter.
Only disappointment when just before he was subbed he went down in the box and some bright spark in front of me was screaming 'get up you lazy c**t'. I thought it was a Bolton fan infiltrating until the same individual claimed that if you put him in a north end shirt he'd play a better game. Judging by his girth, I doubt he would have survived the warm up. Poor form from a north end fan. No problems with people giving their opinions on here but players giving their all don't deserve that type of abuse from their own supporter.
- Joined
- Mar 25, 2006
- Messages
- 5,724
I think SG spent a lot of this season picking Doyle ahead of Hugill. But is Doyle now after a rather a long time suddenly 'clicking'?
Well it is coming to the time of year when footballers start thinking about their next contract or am I being too cynical?
First 25 minutes Hugill looked poor to me. But he came into the game as it went on, and started to link play a lot better. Was brave to stick his head in where it hurts for his goal, and won a few free kicks with some Garner inspired falls to the floor. He does need to cut out the blatent pushes he does, which nearly always get punished by the ref.
But I do think Doyle deserves some credit on the forum for his 6 minute cameo. He made intelligent runs, got a touch on Vermijl's shot for the winning goal, and put his offside chance away very well. Not been a great fan of him this season, but often he has played wide rather than centrally. With the movement of the likes of Robinson and Reach, Doyle could be more useful to us in the run in.
But I do think Doyle deserves some credit on the forum for his 6 minute cameo. He made intelligent runs, got a touch on Vermijl's shot for the winning goal, and put his offside chance away very well. Not been a great fan of him this season, but often he has played wide rather than centrally. With the movement of the likes of Robinson and Reach, Doyle could be more useful to us in the run in.
First 25 minutes Hugill looked poor to me. But he came into the game as it went on, and started to link play a lot better. Was brave to stick his head in where it hurts for his goal, and won a few free kicks with some Garner inspired falls to the floor. He does need to cut out the blatent pushes he does, which nearly always get punished by the ref.
But I do think Doyle deserves some credit on the forum for his 6 minute cameo. He made intelligent runs, got a touch on Vermijl's shot for the winning goal, and put his offside chance away very well. Not been a great fan of him this season, but often he has played wide rather than centrally. With the movement of the likes of Robinson and Reach, Doyle could be more useful to us in the run in.
Doyle's 'offside' goal should have counted. Seen a video of it from someone in the upper tier, he wasn't offside.
As a big critic of his, I hold my hands up and say he did play very well today.
But in the long run, is he good enough? Sorry but I don't think so.
That's how I see it. But I hope he produces more performances like he did yesterday.
But I do think Doyle deserves some credit on the forum for his 6 minute cameo. He made intelligent runs, got a touch on Vermijl's shot for the winning goal, and put his offside chance away very well. Not been a great fan of him this season, but often he has played wide rather than centrally.
Doyle is a striker and nothing else. The fact is that for most of his time with us he has been poor even when played in his proper position - quite simply he has missed chances he should have put away. But on the occasions I have seen him I would never say he has lacked commitment and strikers of course thrive on confidence. Based on how he has played so far then returning him to Cardiff at the end of the season on a 'thanks but no thanks' basis would seem the obvious thing - but if he were suddenly to start banging them in and get another half-dozen or so goals in in quick time then we might have to think again.
Last edited:
- Joined
- May 8, 2004
- Messages
- 19,187
Physically he showed he's willing to get his hands dirty and take the hits. The goal was brave.
He just doesn't have the talent for me. A useful (and cheap) stop gap perhaps but he's never going to be a regular starter.
That said, I though Andy Carroll had nothing about him when he was here either.
Interesting. I said Carroll was here way too young to make an impact but with his touch and size and strength he'll probably breeze it in the prem and he has. Hugill still looks way off to me. Still, well played to him for yesterday.
If we keep him as a squad player, fine but we need a serious talent up front. Someone like Pat Bamford up front would work wonders in this team.
I have doubts that he will make it, but it's worth a go giving him a run and seeing if he blossoms.
That goal will have given him confidence too.
And at this stage in the season how many big forwards have we played against in this league who have looked the part? The big lad at Derby looked good at ours, but he was megabucks.
Give him a chance I say and support him.
His goal on Saturday was Dawsonesque in its bravery.
That goal will have given him confidence too.
And at this stage in the season how many big forwards have we played against in this league who have looked the part? The big lad at Derby looked good at ours, but he was megabucks.
Give him a chance I say and support him.
His goal on Saturday was Dawsonesque in its bravery.
After his header in the first seconds he looked out of sorts for 25 minutes and didn't know if it was new York or new year.
second half he was a bit better and he was really brave for the goal.
He is young, raw, inexperienced and naïve but with SG and his team he will grow and grow in confidence, mature and will score goals. Obviously SG has been something in him very early in his career and I would support SG's judgement as he seems to get it right. I agree give him a start next Saturday.
I thought that Doyles second goal was on side and he looked very sharp. Like the old Doyle.
Roll on QPR then the plastics then those whinging interbred Dingles
second half he was a bit better and he was really brave for the goal.
He is young, raw, inexperienced and naïve but with SG and his team he will grow and grow in confidence, mature and will score goals. Obviously SG has been something in him very early in his career and I would support SG's judgement as he seems to get it right. I agree give him a start next Saturday.
I thought that Doyles second goal was on side and he looked very sharp. Like the old Doyle.
Roll on QPR then the plastics then those whinging interbred Dingles