Skip to main content

If's

If's

We shouldn't fire Grayson if he doesn't deliver promotion this season. I'll be pissed off but the smart thing to do is show faith

I would tend to agree with this. A few months ago I would definitely only have given him till the end of the season, but that was because IMO he made some very poor/average signings in the summer. Since the signings of Johnstone, Johnson & Robinson there seems to be a change in philosophy and because of that I would give him one last chance next season. However, if he does fail to win promotion this season, I would be instructing him to ditch the safety first approach and to change to a more positive approach.
 
I would tend to agree with this. A few months ago I would definitely only have given him till the end of the season, but that was because IMO he made some very poor/average signings in the summer. Since the signings of Johnstone, Johnson & Robinson there seems to be a change in philosophy and because of that I would give him one last chance next season. However, if he does fail to win promotion this season, I would be instructing him to ditch the safety first approach and to change to a more positive approach.

I agree.
 
We need that approach now , to go out to win but even yesterday we started poorly once again. The main reason for that was the formation. If we fail this season what makes you think he will change next season. I honestly think we can do it this season with the players we have but tatics and team changes could be the deciding factor. The words leopards and spots within a sentence spring to mind. Hope you prove me wrong Simon..
 
However, if he does fail to win promotion this season, I would be instructing him to ditch the safety first approach and to change to a more positive approach.

You can't tell a manager how to manage - it completely undermines him.

At the end of the days it's a results business, I don't care how we get them.
 
Last edited:
Run by me again how we have fared after the sacking of Irvine, Ferguson, Brown and Westley.

Ferguson was worse than Irvine, it could be argued that Brown was worse than Ferguson, and for sure, Westley was worst than all of them.

If nothing else under Grayson we have found stability and what looks to be a gradual improvement.

Promotion or not, to sack him would be bordering on foolishness, and for sure taking a big risk on what the next guy could offer given the same financial restrictions.

Exactly. I'm staggered by how quickly PNE fans do want to push the panic button given how it has been completely ineffective for the best part of a decade.

Grayson had us close last season and this year we definitely do look better. He'll get us there but it's up to is to show some faith and backbone.
 
My reaction after the defeat at Walsall was that he should be potted. I couldn't get my head round his tactics for that game with Wembley beckoning.
On reflection, it was a knee jerk reaction and I will continue to back him as I have done 99% of the time since his arrival.
Can't see any better available candidates out there.
 
My reaction after the defeat at Walsall was that he should be potted. I couldn't get my head round his tactics for that game with Wembley beckoning.
On reflection, it was a knee jerk reaction and I will continue to back him as I have done 99% of the time since his arrival.
Can't see any better available candidates out there.

Agreed.... Although I knew he had a good win record and has turned the team around u thought he had taken us as far as he could and we were slowly starting to go backwards.

I am still concerned with his tactics but I am in the same boat and willing to back him as I have done him and all the other managers.
 
But Grayson just being "better than them" isn't enough.

He has to take us up this season.

What about Grayson being absolutely miles better than all of them put together. We have been so incredibly, incredibly bad for such a long time. There are so many chancers and fuckwits out there just looking for another club to manage, quickly get potted and move on with a cheque in hand. Grayson's team isn't fascinating to watch but he has actually built a very, very good side with some good players for very little cash. Saying he's just better than them (them being the tools we've appointed post Irvine) is like saying Joe Garner is better than Eddie Johnson.
 
But Grayson just being "better than them" isn't enough.

He has to take us up this season.

So showing 'gradual improvement and stability' isn't good enough to at least give Grayson one more season if we don't go up this time is it not?

Read my first post in this thread and answer my question about running by me again how we fared after sacking Irvine, Ferguson, Brown and then employing Westley............then think about how we have fared under Grayson, then see if you still feel the same way.

Sometimes it does look greener on the other side of the fence, but most times it isn't.
 
So showing 'gradual improvement and stability' isn't good enough to at least give Grayson one more season if we don't go up this time is it not?

Read my first post in this thread and answer my question about running by me again how we fared after sacking Irvine, Ferguson, Brown and then employing Westley............then think about how we have fared under Grayson, then see if you still feel the same way.

Sometimes it does look greener on the other side of the fence, but most times it isn't.

Obviously it would depend on who's available. There has to be replacements in mind if he does go.
 
Back
Top