Skip to main content

Improvements ?

Improvements ?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Nov 3, 2008
Messages
1,824
Location
Preston
Call me negative, call me whatever you want, but despite the fact we''re now on our 4th signing (5th if you include Kilkenny) have we really improved a squad which by all accounts failed last year ?

The signings of Hugill and Little seems to have given us strength in depth but looking back on last year and the play offs in particular it wasn't our squad depth that let us down, it was out starting eleven which wasn't good enough when push came to shove.

Jones for Rudd in my opinion is a backwards step, although I accept the club had little choice in that move.

I admit to knowing nothing about Hugill and Little and although they more than likely going to be better than Cummins and Beardsley are they really going to make the difference between us being a play off chasing side or going up automaticity.

IMO if we wanted to be real contenders this year we need to add a certain starter in each spine posistion. A centre back, a centre mid and another striker as well as a winger.

The signings we have made have really flattered to deciieve and at this moment in time I just can't see us challenging the top two.
 
The signings haven't been too bad. I'm not sure how much we have improved our first choice starting eleven though. The new right back and keeper aside, I don't think any of our signings will be regular starters in the league.
 
Five out (Keane, King, Byrom, Beavon, Holmes).
Three in (Striker, Brian O'Neil type of midfielder, Pacy left sided midfielder/winger).
 
Who are the top two?

Call me negative, call me whatever you want, but despite the fact we''re now on our 4th signing (5th if you include Kilkenny) have we really improved a squad which by all accounts failed last year ?

The signings of Hugill and Little seems to have given us strength in depth but looking back on last year and the play offs in particular it wasn't our squad depth that let us down, it was out starting eleven which wasn't good enough when push came to shove.

Jones for Rudd in my opinion is a backwards step, although I accept the club had little choice in that move.

I admit to knowing nothing about Hugill and Little and although they more than likely going to be better than Cummins and Beardsley are they really going to make the difference between us being a play off chasing side or going up automaticity.

IMO if we wanted to be real contenders this year we need to add a certain starter in each spine posistion. A centre back, a centre mid and another striker as well as a winger.

The signings we have made have really flattered to deciieve and at this moment in time I just can't see us challenging the top two.
 
Yeah I agree, they definitely haven't improved us, and like you, I know nothing about them....

Jesus.
 
Shocked that so many seem to have made up their minds about the new signings before the ink on their contract is even dry. 'Kin hell.
 
Who are the top two?

My point is at this moment in time is our squad better than or on par with the Brentford and Rotherham sides which went up ?

I don't believe they are, and surely that's the level we need to be aiming at.

With regards to Hugill , I'd be interested to see anyone who knows much about him. He's only had a year in professional football and wasn't a regular in that.

I'm not writing him off, far from it. All I said was will he improve the starting eleven ? IMO no. I hope I'm wrong
 
My point is at this moment in time is our squad better than or on par with the Brentford and Rotherham sides which went up ?

I don't believe they are, and surely that's the level we need to be aiming at.
You do know that, now that they've gone up, we don't have to play them again this season?
 
My point is at this moment in time is our squad better than or on par with the Brentford and Rotherham sides which went up ?

I don't believe they are, and surely that's the level we need to be aiming at.

With regards to Hugill , I'd be interested to see anyone who knows much about him. He's only had a year in professional football and wasn't a regular in that.

I'm not writing him off, far from it. All I said was will he improve the starting eleven ? IMO no. I hope I'm wrong

Im sure you are wrong....which is why Grayson is the manager and not you.
 
Call me negative, call me whatever you want, but despite the fact we''re now on our 4th signing (5th if you include Kilkenny) have we really improved a squad which by all accounts failed last year ?

The signings of Hugill and Little seems to have given us strength in depth but looking back on last year and the play offs in particular it wasn't our squad depth that let us down, it was out starting eleven which wasn't good enough when push came to shove.

Jones for Rudd in my opinion is a backwards step, although I accept the club had little choice in that move.

I admit to knowing nothing about Hugill and Little and although they more than likely going to be better than Cummins and Beardsley are they really going to make the difference between us being a play off chasing side or going up automaticity.

IMO if we wanted to be real contenders this year we need to add a certain starter in each spine posistion. A centre back, a centre mid and another striker as well as a winger.

The signings we have made have really flattered to deciieve and at this moment in time I just can't see us challenging the top two.
so you made your mind up before they even played they are not good enough
 
My point on the two new signings was probably not explained well enough but overall I was trying to say I don't feel we have improved the squad.

If we were to play the play off semi final again with the team we have now, I still don't think we would win.

It's a forum, we all have different opinions, if we all thought the same there would be no point in it.
 
Callum makes some good points to be fair, but typically on here, if you have reservations about our chances, or certain signings, then you are evil and anti-PNE.

Personally I never slag new signings until I have seen them in the flesh, and never on a match day.

BUT, Hugill and Little hardly make me think, bloody hell we're going to storm this league and conquer all.

Our lack of pace and quality was very apparent last season, particularly in the play off games, these lads don't look like they will improve this flaw in our game? I also would doubt injury prone keeper Jones will be as competent as Rudd? But let's wait and see.

If being concerned about us rotting in the third tier for ever more makes me a bad person then so be it.

All our new signings get my full support as do the players already here, forgive me if I don't cream myself over their impact though. Happy to be proved wrong though, as ever, but I won't hold my breath. I've been here before, just like our NINTH recent play-off failure.

Play-offs again at best for me, and we know what happens there.
 
'automaticity'

Excellent word. I never even knew it existed, but I shall be sure to use it whenever I get the chance.
 
Is there any chance of a pre-season fans forum with SG? It would be interesting to hear what he has to say abou this strategy for the coming season.
 
Is there any chance of a pre-season fans forum with SG? It would be interesting to hear what he has to say abou this strategy for the coming season.

Write to him and ask. Put your contact telephone number on your letter too.
If David Moyes can ring me up all those years ago when he was PNE manager, I'm sure SG will do same for you!
 
Callum makes some good points to be fair, but typically on here, if you have reservations about our chances, or certain signings, then you are evil and anti-PNE.

Personally I never slag new signings until I have seen them in the flesh, and never on a match day.

BUT, Hugill and Little hardly make me think, bloody hell we're going to storm this league and conquer all.

Our lack of pace and quality was very apparent last season, particularly in the play off games, these lads don't look like they will improve this flaw in our game? I also would doubt injury prone keeper Jones will be as competent as Rudd? But let's wait and see.

If being concerned about us rotting in the third tier for ever more makes me a bad person then so be it.

All our new signings get my full support as do the players already here, forgive me if I don't cream myself over their impact though. Happy to be proved wrong though, as ever, but I won't hold my breath. I've been here before, just like our NINTH recent play-off failure.

Play-offs again at best for me, and we know what happens there.

Spot on Neal, feel exact same way, hope the new boys do the biz though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top