Skip to main content

In summary

In summary

Libertine

Thick Nomark
Joined
May 23, 2005
Messages
10,511
Location
Costa Del Leylando
1) Why do we change winning teams? What message does it send to players if they start, win and play well and don't retain their place? I'm thinking Callum Woods and John Welsh in particular here.

2) Does Scott Wiseman know the meaning of the term "goal side?" As he is continually out of position when the opponents have possession. Get Bailey Wright back in the middle with Huntington, drop Wiseman and stick Clarke at right back.

3) Brownhill is struggling at the moment, why stick him in when we're live on tele and really need a win after a mini slump in results. Browne must be wondering what he's done wrong as he offered more in the 10 minutes that he was on.

4) Both wingers were poor, but Kyel Reid should have been taken off over Humphrey. At least Chris was willing to run, Reid was a liability. It was like playing with 10 men.

5) We desperately need to either play John Welsh or sign a central midfielder with a bit of bite. If we're getting Callum Robinson back we should go in for Daniel Johnson as well, he tore us a new one with Chesterfield. Either way Kilkenny and Brownhill couldn't tackle a chippy tea.

6) Sam Johnstone's distribution was decent.

7) I didn't boo at the end personally, but I'm glad that some did as it sends a message to Grayson and the Riddler that things need sorting out.

8) Gallagher refused to be interviewed by Sky as he left the pitch, which I like. He rightly got our MOM, but it's obvious he knew that the team performance was poor.

I think that's it for now.
 
Clarke should not play right back. I'd bring back Wright in place of Huntington and play Woods at right back. Buchanan yesterday had a nightmare game so Laird would start at left back. I agree about Brownhill. With him and Killkenny in midfield we lack strength and it was particularly noticeable in the second half that they were struggling to compete. We desperately need a physically strong midfielder. I thought that that was the best Beckford has played in a North End shirt. He won headers, held the ball up well and scored a goal and Gallagher is most suited to playing in that no 10 role. On the flanks have to totally disagree. Humphrey was beyond poor (and has been for a while now) shooting when he should have crossed and running into blind alleys. Reid grew as the game progressed, won the penalty and was dangerous down his flank. So in summary, we need to tweek the defence, sign a dominant midfielder and a right winger and we will be fine!
 
1) Why do we change winning teams? What message does it send to players if they start, win and play well and don't retain their place? I'm thinking Callum Woods and John Welsh in particular here.

2) Does Scott Wiseman know the meaning of the term "goal side?" As he is continually out of position when the opponents have possession. Get Bailey Wright back in the middle with Huntington, drop Wiseman and stick Clarke at right back.
So despite worrying about the message it sends out, you're now saying don't play Woods - the guy who played in that "winning team" that we shouldn't be changing?

So now Clarke is suddenly right-back, where he hasn't played all season.

Don't have a lot of confidence in this approach so far, to be honest.

4) Both wingers were poor, but Kyel Reid should have been taken off over Humphrey. At least Chris was willing to run, Reid was a liability. It was like playing with 10 men.
Oh dear. I think that's enough for me.
 
1) Why do we change winning teams? What message does it send to players if they start, win and play well and don't retain their place? I'm thinking Callum Woods and John Welsh in particular here.

2) Does Scott Wiseman know the meaning of the term "goal side?" As he is continually out of position when the opponents have possession. Get Bailey Wright back in the middle with Huntington, drop Wiseman and stick Clarke at right back.

3) Brownhill is struggling at the moment, why stick him in when we're live on tele and really need a win after a mini slump in results. Browne must be wondering what he's done wrong as he offered more in the 10 minutes that he was on.

4) Both wingers were poor, but Kyel Reid should have been taken off over Humphrey. At least Chris was willing to run, Reid was a liability. It was like playing with 10 men.

5) We desperately need to either play John Welsh or sign a central midfielder with a bit of bite. If we're getting Callum Robinson back we should go in for Daniel Johnson as well, he tore us a new one with Chesterfield. Either way Kilkenny and Brownhill couldn't tackle a chippy tea.

6) Sam Johnstone's distribution was decent.

7) I didn't boo at the end personally, but I'm glad that some did as it sends a message to Grayson and the Riddler that things need sorting out.

8) Gallagher refused to be interviewed by Sky as he left the pitch, which I like. He rightly got our MOM, but it's obvious he knew that the team performance was poor.

I think that's it for now.

Agree with a good proportion of that. Thought Reid did ok. But just ok.

Question for me is why do our wingers always need three or four touches before crossing the ball? All it means is they either get closed down or the striker has made his run and gets caught offside.
 
So despite worrying about the message it sends out, you're now saying don't play Woods - the guy who played in that "winning team" that we shouldn't be changing?

So now Clarke is suddenly right-back, where he hasn't played all season.

Don't have a lot of confidence in this approach so far, to be honest.

Oh dear. I think that's enough for me.

I see your point. I'd be fine with Woods R/B and Wright and Clarke in the middle. I doubt not having played at R/B would be a problem for Clarke though. My main point is that Wiseman needs dropping.

I simply didn't see this improving performance from Reid.
 
Except for gally, Reid everyone else was poor for me.

Has our team forgot what got us high in the league, ie ball on the ground, pass and movement.

We have also been sussed. Decent defence and forwards with a soft centre so other teams are packing the midfield and breaking swiftly against our big defenders.

Until the requirement for a ball winner and a creative of decent quality is signed we will not bother the top two, they may well leave us further behind today.

Kilkenny looked like a little lad lost in a grown ups game last night and did a fairly good impression of a headless chicken.
 
Reid tired significantly - Humpfrey had more left to give.

Brownhill is a size thing - needs to bulk up a bit which will happen over time.

Woods over Wiseman & Laird over Buchs please

And replace Garner - the biggest joke of the night was SG telling SKD to sit back down when they EQUALIZED

Bringing you on Kev - but not to score!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
 
I can't believe people are picking out individuals like Reid for criticism. Last nights game was lost due the mindset the players have at home, and that has to down to the manager and his staff to sort out.

Everytime we go ahead you can see them take a step back. One thing that I noticed was Grayson had Davies ready to come on when they equalized and he immediately told him to sit back down. He panicked for me thinking 'how do we not lose this from here' Instead he should have got Ebanks-Blake ready as well and thrown both on up top with Beckford and hammered at the door for a winner. If we got hit on the break so be it. But the fact is our goal difference is far inferior to the other 3 top 4 sides as we point blank refuse to turn the screw when we get ahead at home and smash teams out of sight.

Leyton Orient where absolute garbage but we allowed them to dig in and nick a point due to trying to hold on at 2-1.

Tactically at home it needs looking at. It is better to win 2 and lose 1 than win 1 and draw 2. When was the last time we hit someone for 4, 5 or 6 at home?
 
It was a draw because we have good strikers, decent defence and a midfield that's neeeded a leader with a pass and some creativity for at least the past 4 years.

One small lad, two lightweight kids are just not going to or be able to cut it.

Kilkenny looked knackered weak and off the pace last night.
 
A lot of very poor performances last night,but to say Reid played worse than Humphrey you saw a different game than me !!
Humphreys biggest asset is pace, sadly he is petrified of using it when going forward with the ball.

Also what was all the shooting from distance about last night a bunch of schoolboys would have had more threat on goal !!
 
I can't believe people are picking out individuals like Reid for criticism. Last nights game was lost due the mindset the players have at home, and that has to down to the manager and his staff to sort out.

My criticism of Reid is not just based on last night. He has had one decent performance and that was against Norwich (On the bench for the next game against Walsall for some reason???!!!). There are too many footballers up and down the country stealing a living from playing well every so often. I can't believe that in support of Reid some are saying he had a decent 10 minutes. What the hell is that all about?
 
Back
Top