Skip to main content

Individual Errors

Individual Errors

we played very well and the best team lost. But we did look rather shot-shy /QUOTE]

sums it up.
'You shoot sir'
'no you shoot sir'
'no sir you shoot'
'oh fuck we've lost the ball'

And how many times did that happen last night?

A few on here showing they understand little about football. Don't be so naive.

The first goal was crucial. Forest got it and it became a different game. They defended for their lives packing their own box with players.

That meant that when we did shoot (and 20 plus shots on the stats would suggest we did - at least four times as much as Forest) it simply rebounded of a body in the box. Because that's where they all were.

If the game had remained nil nil there would have been more space to have a shot in. Because Forest would still have been attacking instead of camping in their own half protecting a precious lucky lead against an outstanding North End side.

If anyone was shot shy it was Forest (check the stats). And they won 2 nil. So maybe shot shy isn't such a bad tactic?
 
A few on here showing they understand little about football. Don't be so naive.

The first goal was crucial. Forest got it and it became a different game. They defended for their lives packing their own box with players.

That meant that when we did shoot (and 20 plus shots on the stats would suggest we did - at least four times as much as Forest) it simply rebounded of a body in the box. Because that's where they all were.

If we looked indecisive it's because we were seeking out the best option.

If the game had remained nil nil there would have been more space to have a shot in. Because Forest would still have been attacking instead of camping in their own half protecting a precious lucky lead against an outstanding North End side.

If anyone was shot shy it was Forest (check the stats). And they won 2 nil. So maybe shot shy isn't such a bad tactic?
 
we played very well and the best team lost. But we did look rather shot-shy /QUOTE]

sums it up.
'You shoot sir'
'no you shoot sir'
'no sir you shoot'
'oh fuck we've lost the ball'

And how many times did that happen last night?

A few on here showing they understand little about football. Don't be so naive.

we did shoot (and 20 plus shots on the stats would suggest we did - at least four times as much as Forest)

So you didn't see all the un-necessary passing before a shot was made?

We appear to have a few players who do not have the confidence to shoot and when in a position to do so pass it to someone else!

May I suggest (in my naivety) that if those players had took the shot at goal when in a position to do so (quite often) then our shots tally would have been greater than the 20 plus that we had, and maybe (with naivety) one of those extra shots may have gone in!
 
I think Ross's point is a fair one. The higher up the leagues you go, the more your mistakes get punished. Quite why it merits such a pompous reaction from some posters, I'm not sure. Are we Preston North Korea?

I suspect Albertan wants to put it on record that he's viewed a game. Fair enough, but at top level football the chain of causation doesn't break because there are other errors between one mistake and the goal. If Wiseman had not conceded the corner, they would not have scored. The point is a valid one irrespective of last nights magnificent performance.
 
I think Ross's point is a fair one. The higher up the leagues you go, the more your mistakes get punished. Quite why it merits such a pompous reaction from some posters, I'm not sure. Are we Preston North Korea?

I suspect Albertan wants to put it on record that he's viewed a game. Fair enough, but at top level football the chain of causation doesn't break because there are other errors between one mistake and the goal. If Wiseman had not conceded the corner, they would not have scored. The point is a valid one irrespective of last nights magnificent performance.


I can accept his point of view Christ i was a child once , it was his crying in his supper about our promotion credentials that really pissed me off . Also could your outburst against Albertan not be seen as pompous ? just saying like
 
we played very well and the best team lost. But we did look rather shot-shy /QUOTE]

sums it up.
'You shoot sir'
'no you shoot sir'
'no sir you shoot'
'oh fuck we've lost the ball'

And how many times did that happen last night?

A few on here showing they understand little about football. Don't be so naive.

The first goal was crucial. Forest got it and it became a different game. They defended for their lives packing their own box with players.

That meant that when we did shoot (and 20 plus shots on the stats would suggest we did - at least four times as much as Forest) it simply rebounded of a body in the box. Because that's where they all were.

If the game had remained nil nil there would have been more space to have a shot in. Because Forest would still have been attacking instead of camping in their own half protecting a precious lucky lead against an outstanding North End side.

If anyone was shot shy it was Forest (check the stats). And they won 2 nil. So maybe shot shy isn't such a bad tactic?

I think Ross's point is a fair one. The higher up the leagues you go, the more your mistakes get punished. Quite why it merits such a pompous reaction from some posters, I'm not sure. Are we Preston North Korea?

I suspect Albertan wants to put it on record that he's viewed a game. Fair enough, but at top level football the chain of causation doesn't break because there are other errors between one mistake and the goal. If Wiseman had not conceded the corner, they would not have scored. The point is a valid one irrespective of last nights magnificent performance.

I agree completely, but looking at other threads where it was suggested that individuals made mistakes the op has been jumped on as well.

For goodness sake, it is called critique, and is an important aspect of learning and improving, not derogatory!

I wonder how many of those who think that everyone had a magnificent game were actually at the match, as the game you see on tv is not the same as it is live!
 
I can accept his point of view Christ i was a child once , it was his crying in his supper about our promotion credentials that really pissed me off . Also could your outburst against Albertan not be seen as pompous ? just saying like

It depends how you interpret my comments on Albertan. To describe it as an outburst is a little over the top. FWIW, I wasn't having a dig at Albertan, he's passionate about North End and it's a rare chance for him to share fully in the debate about the game.

I wouldn't get too upset about these things if I were you Dirk.
 
It depends how you interpret my comments on Albertan. To describe it as an outburst is a little over the top. FWIW, I wasn't having a dig at Albertan, he's passionate about North End and it's a rare chance for him to share fully in the debate about the game.

I wouldn't get too upset about these things if I were you Dirk.


I'm not upset because of his frustration tantrum but do you yourself not think to start dismissing promotion on the back of that is a bit like a big old child sulking ? lets be honest Forest came to town last night and probably got there arses spanked harder than any other time this season . So instead of moaning like a child the majority i believe would say now this is something to build on . I honestly think if Garners effort had gone in they would have had no answer to us , just unlucky is all .
 
I can accept his point of view Christ i was a child once , it was his crying in his supper about our promotion credentials that really pissed me off . Also could your outburst against Albertan not be seen as pompous ? just saying like

What do you want me to say, we're definitely going to get promoted, reality, we've got about a 20-30% chance IMO
 
What do you want me to say, we're definitely going to get promoted, reality, we've got about a 20-30% chance IMO
How the fuck do you get to 20-30%? Is it simply because there are 4 teams hunting automatic promotion, so that's 25%? There's so many things that have to be taken into account when trying to work out our chances of promotion that it just isn't possible to do so. If we play like we did last night against any side in our own division we will win at least 3-0.
 
How the fuck do you get to 20-30%? Is it simply because there are 4 teams hunting automatic promotion, so that's 25%? There's so many things that have to be taken into account when trying to work out our chances of promotion that it just isn't possible to do so. If we play like we did last night against any side in our own division we will win at least 3-0.

It's around 30% -Bookies say so 😉
 
It's around 30% -Bookies say so 😉

I'd take 30% chance of promotion this year. Seems reasonable considering we haven't scored nearly enough goals so far this season to be seriously considered for automatic.

Hopefully we will walk the league next season if we don't scrape through the play-off's this season.
 
I think Ross's point is a fair one. The higher up the leagues you go, the more your mistakes get punished. Quite why it merits such a pompous reaction from some posters, I'm not sure. Are we Preston North Korea?

I suspect Albertan wants to put it on record that he's viewed a game. Fair enough, but at top level football the chain of causation doesn't break because there are other errors between one mistake and the goal. If Wiseman had not conceded the corner, they would not have scored. The point is a valid one irrespective of last nights magnificent performance.

"The chain of causation".............get off your high horse Traci. The point is that virtually every goal you see, and at whatever level, are caused by someone on the side of the team that conceded a goal making an error, or not doing their job properly. And if you want to take the "chain of causation" further, managerial team selection errors can cause goals to be conceded. How far back to you want to go?

My issue was with the apparent blame of Wiseman, when two other players after that error had opportunities to perhaps salvage the situation. Having said that, I don't blame Rudd (he made a valiant attempt to clear the ball) or Holmes any more than I blame Wiseman.

This is a team game, and individual errors are part of that game, and to start pointing the finger at individuals is not something I agree with.

You can take those plums out of your mouth now.
 
I think Ross's point is a fair one. The higher up the leagues you go, the more your mistakes get punished. Quite why it merits such a pompous reaction from some posters, I'm not sure. Are we Preston North Korea?

I suspect Albertan wants to put it on record that he's viewed a game. Fair enough, but at top level football the chain of causation doesn't break because there are other errors between one mistake and the goal. If Wiseman had not conceded the corner, they would not have scored. The point is a valid one irrespective of last nights magnificent performance.

... Fair enough but using the same " chain " then you forgot to list the other 49 million events that led to the goal. 🙂
 
Don't want to take the gloss off what is a fantastic team performance against a very good side, however IF and it's a big if we do go up individual errors such as wiseamans pass which led to the corner for their first and clarkes attempted clearance for the second HAVE to be cut out or else the top end championship sides will punish! All in all though a cracking performance, loved showing my mates at uni what were all about, onwards and upwards, we can do them playoffs!

We have had 16 clean sheets this season, and I bet if you watch through all of those games, there will be several individual errors in every game which went unpunished. Forest were clinical and punished 2 mistakes, which on another day, they would probably have missed em both.
 
Football is based on punishing the other teams errors.

Always has been, always will be.

Take the Port Vale home game for example. If we'd conceded the three goals we scored we'd probably still be talking about it now. All bloody awful defensively. It works all ways.

In the Forest case we can take heart from the fact that we dominated play overall but their two goals were both premiership level finishes. Thats why those two guys are playing in the championship and our lads aren't.
 
Arguably the mistake by Clarke that led to their second goal reinforced the message that one improvement we could make to the team would be to sign the sort of really dominant central defender who might have cleared the ball first time. But that mistake was so close to the end that it probably made no difference to the result.
Let's carry on. With the possible exception of C Davies for K Davies I really hope SG starts tomorrow with the same line-up that finished on Wednesday - it played the best football we have played all season. Four at the back with the fullbacks pushing up, a strong midfield trio, then Gallagher, then two strikers - that line-up has real balance and fluency and with the likes of King, Brownhill, either Davies and Hume on the bench it can be refreshed with new players without being disrupted, yet with Holmes there as well there is also the potential for a different approach if want to broaden things out in midfield.
 
What do you want me to say, we're definitely going to get promoted, reality, we've got about a 20-30% chance IMO


Its 50-50 you ether go up or you don't and after Wednesdays performance we should be brimming with confidence 2 defeats in 22 at the time , but you came out blubbing like a big baby , big IF if we go up . The way the lads played was great you just wizzed your toys out the pram accept it .
 
Its 50-50 you ether go up or you don't and after Wednesdays performance we should be brimming with confidence 2 defeats in 22 at the time , but you came out blubbing like a big baby , big IF if we go up . The way the lads played was great you just wizzed your toys out the pram accept it .

Are you joking, do you have a problem, it is a big IF as to whether we go up and i hardly wizzed my toys out the pram, i did state it was a fantastic performance, however the fact we conceded from individual mistakes is annoying and something that you cant afford to do against the better sides
 
Back
Top