Skip to main content

jack king

jack king

Joined
Apr 3, 2009
Messages
161
Can someone please explain why jack king continues to get selected when others , ie Keith keane, john welsh , paul huntington have never had a look in, nothing against jack king but he simply out of his depth at this level, for a big lad he is powder puff in the tackle, as seen against rotherham in the play offs.come on grayson sort your team out everyone bar you knows we are crying out for a leader in centre midfield.
 
Last edited:
I have him in the same bracket as Keane - committed, hard working, but lacking any real quality.

Part of his problem is that he hasn't properly got a position - he's not a striker, he's not a midfielder and he isn't really a defender.
 
He isn't a midfielder - well certainly not when he plays in a 2 man midfield.

I feel his biggest problem is that he doesn't seem to get a good run in any position due to the utility role he holds within the squad.
 
Can someone please explain why jack king continues to get selected when others , ie Keith keane, john welsh , paul huntington have never had a look in, nothing against jack king but he simply out of his depth at this level, for a big lad he is powder puff in the tackle, as seen against rotherham in the play offs.come on grayson sort your team out everyone bar you knows we are crying out for a leader in centre midfield.
nothing more than a squad utility player for me..............should never start other than serious injury crisis
 
I don't think King, Welsh or Keane are good enough for us. Moyes got us out of this division with Gregan and Rankine with McKenna. Week in, week out these lads ran fucking games, won back possession countless times and put in consistent performances. We need better players in midfield if Brownhill or Browne aren't gonna play
 
I don't think King, Welsh or Keane are good enough for us. Moyes got us out of this division with Gregan and Rankine with McKenna. Week in, week out these lads ran fucking games, won back possession countless times and put in consistent performances. We need better players in midfield if Brownhill or Browne aren't gonna play

Totally agree with this, with king being third choice out of the three.
 
I don't think King, Welsh or Keane are good enough for us. Moyes got us out of this division with Gregan and Rankine with McKenna. Week in, week out these lads ran fucking games, won back possession countless times and put in consistent performances. We need better players in midfield if Brownhill or Browne aren't gonna play

McKenna ( our latter day General and hero in central midfield ) wasn't good enough to get in the team in that position ... so was played out wide by Moyes... Always makes me smile does that one..That's not meant to be a criticism or anything but sometimes wrong things just drop into place and make a situation a right thing !....I think the word I'm looking for is " fortuitous " 🙂
 
I have him in the same bracket as Keane - committed, hard working, but lacking any real quality.

Part of his problem is that he hasn't properly got a position - he's not a striker, he's not a midfielder and he isn't really a defender.
He's not a striker, not a defender and not a midfielder. Is he a footballer? Ye Gods.
Can we have some intelligent discussions on this forum, please.
 
The problem with King is that he needs to be surrounded by runners to be able to cover for him. He's not great in a three man defence, but he gets away with alot more than when there's just two centre halves playing.

He's not particularly great as a midfielder (and that's where he was playing when we signed him) but again he seems to do better when there's an extra body alongside him.

Upfront, he's just a target-man to hoof the ball to. He doesn't convert enough chances to play there regularly though.

And there's the problem, if you want King in your team you have to re-arrange the whole team. There's no doubting his desire and work-rate, but can anyone really see Jack King playing in the Championship? I don't think he's got the quality to be at a top team in League One, and think we have better options in the squad for the positions we try to play him in.

King can get you through a couple of games, but eventually he gets caught out. Against Sheffield United he was a mistake waiting to happen but young Davies had a slightly worse game and took the brunt of the criticism that day. I know utility players are in fashion at the moment, but I'm surprised Grayson didn't look to move him on in the summer.
 
He's not a striker, not a defender and not a midfielder. Is he a footballer? Ye Gods.
Can we have some intelligent discussions on this forum, please.

Ok smartarse, add some intelligence and tell us what position you see him specialising as and why?

Regardless of what position he's played when I've seen him, he's always had the air of someone filling in to do a job, but not entirely comfortable or naturally at ease with the role. The nearest he's come is probably as a defender, but I'm yet to be convinced, hence my description of him as not a striker, not a midfielder and not really a defender.

I await your considered, enlightening contribution with baited breath.
 
McKenna ( our latter day General and hero in central midfield ) wasn't good enough to get in the team in that position ... so was played out wide by Moyes... Always makes me smile does that one..That's not meant to be a criticism or anything but sometimes wrong things just drop into place and make a situation a right thing !....I think the word I'm looking for is " fortuitous " 🙂

Serious question mate ... have you seen a PNE game since the start of the 21st century ?
 
I have him in the same bracket as Keane - committed, hard working, but lacking any real quality.

Part of his problem is that he hasn't properly got a position - he's not a striker, he's not a midfielder and he isn't really a defender.


Spot on that mate ... invariably players at our level need to be given a position/role in the team to refine unlike the top notch players who can adapt and evolve into different positions as required.
 
How King is almost an ever present when the likes of Huntington and Welsh, Laird and Buchanan have struggled or cant even get in the 18 absolutely amazes me.
 
His best position is as an attacking midfielder but he is hardly likely to get that role here.....clearly we lacked pace on Saturday in the engine room hence we were over run but there were worse performances than King.
 
King is limited but does come into his own when the team have their tails up. Another poster (pne-2004) has noted it from another angle...when there is movement around him.

Just another weak link when we`re subdued and uncreative, though. Which appears to be about now, from reports.
 
Looks okay in a 3 man central defence, looks okay in a 3 man central midfield. Play him in a 2 man centre defence, or 2 man centre midfield,and I think he looks shaky. He was poor yesterday, as were the majority of our team. The manager got our team selection wrong yesterday, and we paid for it.

Kilkenny played well against Sheffield United in a 3 man centre midfield, don't know why we changed it yesterday.
 
Back
Top