Skip to main content

Jamie Jones

Jamie Jones

Joined
Jul 24, 2008
Messages
153
I've seen nothing to get me excited about Jamie Jones at all this season. He always looks nervous and is nothing on Rudd who was fantastic for us last season. In all honesty I think Stuckmann should start over him. Got a clean sheet in the JPT and it was only a few seasons ago he was our player of the season.

Grayson talks about earning your shirt, well conceding 3 against Walsall isn't exactly doing that is it? Stuckmann deserves his chance IMO.

Curious to hear others' opinions on Jones and whether we're in agreement that Stuckmann should be given a chance to start and impress...
 
Teams who go up keep a settled back four and goalkeeper.

We've done anything but. Grayson needs to decide on his preferred goalkeeper and back four and stick with it unless a change is forced.
 
I have always been fairly fond of Stuckmann as a shot stopper and have never understood why he has been on the bench so much (he was unfortunate to have had Rudd loaned in and preform so well) but he has waiting patiently and deserves another look and a chance of first team league football. Unless there is something to do with attitude or poor training that we aren't aware of.
 
I've seen nothing to get me excited about Jamie Jones at all this season. He always looks nervous and is nothing on Rudd who was fantastic for us last season. In all honesty I think Stuckmann should start over him. Got a clean sheet in the JPT and it was only a few seasons ago he was our player of the season.

Grayson talks about earning your shirt, well conceding 3 against Walsall isn't exactly doing that is it? Stuckmann deserves his chance IMO.

Curious to hear others' opinions on Jones and whether we're in agreement that Stuckmann should be given a chance to start and impress...

I should hope not Dan.
 
In the play-off final for Orient, I thought he looked appalling - the match highlights show he didn't cover himself in glory with either Rotherham goal (1st one at 0:45):



He looked like another David Lucas to me - a decent shot-stopper, but a bit too small to ever be convincing in the air - so I admit I was quite disappointed when we eventually signed him.

He seems to have received mixed reviews since then, although I don't think he can be dropped unless he gets an injury, a suspension, or makes a truly monumental gaffe that costs us points.

Hopefully, none of that happens, of course.
 
I've seen nothing to get me excited about Jamie Jones at all this season. He always looks nervous and is nothing on Rudd who was fantastic for us last season. In all honesty I think Stuckmann should start over him. Got a clean sheet in the JPT and it was only a few seasons ago he was our player of the season.

Grayson talks about earning your shirt, well conceding 3 against Walsall isn't exactly doing that is it? Stuckmann deserves his chance IMO.

Curious to hear others' opinions on Jones and whether we're in agreement that Stuckmann should be given a chance to start and impress...

I completely agree that Jones is not as good as Rudd. But to blame him for the goals against Walsall is not fair, some of the goals he has conceded this year could have been easily avoided if his back 4 had shaped up, we have been poor defending this season.

The first goal was Sunday league stuff from our back line every one of them dropped back whilst Sawyers simply took a step back and had hours to pick his shot. The second goal was just a bullet header, Bradshaw had been bullied all afternoon and Bailey Wright somehow let him get in front of him, Rudd maybe would have saved it but he was a lot better shot stopper than Jones.

Clarke hasn't been the man mountain he was last season but would be the second name on the team sheet for me behind Garner, I think Bailey Wright is suffering either with an injury or a dip in form. I would give Huntington the shirt and tell him to do all he can to hold onto it, played well against Shrewsbury and was a mainstay at the beginning of last season where we conceded very few goals.

Stuckmann and Jones both make me nervous at times, however I have seen calmness from Jones when it comes to shots coming at him, but crosses and set pieces seem to be his undoing, maybe Stuckmann should be given a start as he has more of a presence and tends to go after the ball from set pieces.

Teams who go up keep a settled back four and goalkeeper.

We've done anything but. Grayson needs to decide on his preferred goalkeeper and back four and stick with it unless a change is forced.

My back 5 for the next 2 HOME games would be -

Jones

Wiseman - Huntington - Clarke - Laird

I have always been fairly fond of Stuckmann as a shot stopper and have never understood why he has been on the bench so much (he was unfortunate to have had Rudd loaned in and preform so well) but he has waiting patiently and deserves another look and a chance of first team league football. Unless there is something to do with attitude or poor training that we aren't aware of.

Grayson said last year that his training ethic and professionalism was brilliant, for me 1 or 2 poor games from Jones and maybe Stuckers should be given his chance.
 
Orient's goal conceded column isn't looking too clever since getting rid of him.
Their first choice Legzdins has injured his finger - before that, he hadn't conceded too many since their opening day defeat.

Second-choice Woods has been used in the cups, and shipped 2 against Colchester on Saturday.
 
I've seen nothing to get me excited about Jamie Jones at all this season. He always looks nervous and is nothing on Rudd who was fantastic for us last season. In all honesty I think Stuckmann should start over him. Got a clean sheet in the JPT and it was only a few seasons ago he was our player of the season.

Grayson talks about earning your shirt, well conceding 3 against Walsall isn't exactly doing that is it? Stuckmann deserves his chance IMO.

Curious to hear others' opinions on Jones and whether we're in agreement that Stuckmann should be given a chance to start and impress...

And if Stuckmann played tonight and conceded 3? Then what?
He's signed Jones, and will stick by him. If anything he needs to sort out the CB's in front of him, particularly Wright, to stop the free headers in the box.
 
Fully agree with OP. It gives out the wrong message to not only Stuckmann but other squad players that if you're playing badly you still retain your starting place. The guy has looked average at best for me and a bad keeper can also have an effect on the confidence of a back 4 very easily
 
I've seen nothing to get me excited about Jamie Jones at all this season. He always looks nervous and is nothing on Rudd who was fantastic for us last season. In all honesty I think Stuckmann should start over him. Got a clean sheet in the JPT and it was only a few seasons ago he was our player of the season.

Grayson talks about earning your shirt, well conceding 3 against Walsall isn't exactly doing that is it? Stuckmann deserves his chance IMO.

Curious to hear others' opinions on Jones and whether we're in agreement that Stuckmann should be given a chance to start and impress...

Can you tell me which goals Jones was to blame for on Saturday?
 
Their first choice Legzdins has injured his finger - before that, he hadn't conceded too many since their opening day defeat.

Second-choice Woods has been used in the cups, and shipped 2 against Colchester on Saturday.

Fair enough, I still don't think Jones is as bad as some make out, at this level anyway.

His (in)ability to deal with crosses is a worry though which makes the need for a commanding centre back more necessary. The Doncaster equaliser was a prime example, a proper leader at the back would have completely ignored a flapping keeper and headed that away.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Having seen the goals we've conceded this season whilst he hasn't had any clangers he certainly could've done better, Walsall's first in particular from the weekend where his positioning is highly questionnable.

If it was an outfield player I reckon someone else would have had an opportunity now so don't see why the GK is any different, would be happy to see Stuckmann in tonight.

Lets not forget with Rudd we were probably spoilt and making comparisons between him and any of our current keepers is foolish
 
To be fair, I do agree that it's hard to compare anyone to Rudd, who was in all honestly a fantastic goalkeeper for us. Such a shame we couldn't re-sign him on loan. Maybe in January? He's not starting for Norwich, so fingers crossed we can get him back some day.

However, even so Jamie Jones really doesn't have a presence as a keeper for us, where as I think Stuckmann is far more commanding, and whilst not perfect, I'd say worthy of his chance now. Especially after conceding ANOTHER 3 goals, this time against Chesterfield!

Also worth remembering how good Stuckmann is at pens too, if he saves that penalty on Tuesday we win 3-2. So it does make a difference..

Personally, I think it's Stuckmann's time to shine, and then Jones needs to work hard and show more bravery, belief and ability to get back in the team so that he deserves his place.
 
I think a fair test would be to stick a settled back four in front of Jones.

I fear that we lack height at the back, perhaps Grayson did too and that's why he opted for King. Thus, Huntington should perhaps get his chance.
 
Back
Top