Skip to main content

jamie procter

jamie procter

If we keep Garner, Beavon and Kevin Davies then a player like Proctor - a you centre forward with a bit of physical presence - is the type of further striker we need to sign. Frankly if we were to re-sign Gallagher I would rather use him as a striker right upfront than in that position just behind two other strikers which robs the midfield of width.
Given that combination of players staying, what we need are forwards with either pace or clinical finishing. Jamie isn't that type of player and anyway he missed his chance when he was here.

When he was playing with Mellor and Hume he failed to learn enough so that when they were injured he wasn't knowledgeable to step up (a difficult task in any case).

He hasn't set the world alight at Crawley so why would we put him above young Jack Ryan who has just been given a professional contract (I assume on significantly less money due to his age).

People need to stop harking back to ex-players through rose-tinted glasses.
 
Are you on drugs? £12000 a week and "he might consider it"?

Aye oreet.

He is a lower league player at best.

I reckon you're related to the lad, fair play if so for sticking up for him. There is bound to be a touch of mis-guided bias.

Jesus! You were one of the last posters that I'd have expected to have been THICK enough to not realise I was jumping on the Bogie bandwagon & my post was completely tongue in cheek. I happen to think that I wouldnt pay Proctor in washers to come back to PNE... Taxi for Daniels !
 
Given that combination of players staying, what we need are forwards with either pace or clinical finishing. Jamie isn't that type of player and anyway he missed his chance when he was here.

When he was playing with Mellor and Hume he failed to learn enough so that when they were injured he wasn't knowledgeable to step up (a difficult task in any case).

He hasn't set the world alight at Crawley so why would we put him above young Jack Ryan who has just been given a professional contract (I assume on significantly less money due to his age).

People need to stop harking back to ex-players through rose-tinted glasses.

Especially ones who were rubbish the first time around.
 
He hasn't set the world alight at Crawley so why would we put him above young Jack Ryan who has just been given a professional contract (I assume on significantly less money due to his age).

People need to stop harking back to ex-players through rose-tinted glasses.

Quite - I didn't say we should re-sign him or even consider doing so, just that a player of his type is what we need to add to the roster. I agree with the general argument, though, that Proctor was misused by both our previous managers and that with better handling he might have been a useful player for us over the last couple of seasons. As for Ryan you may be right. More fundamentally it is pace and invention in midfield we need - unless we sort out that part of the team it will be more or less irrelevant what we do upfront.
 
Last edited:
just that a player of his general type is what we need to add to the roster.

What type is that?

A shit one that doesn't score goals.

If we're looking to get to the championship again, Jamie proctor or players of his type will not achieve this!
 
What type is that?

QUOTE]

As I said - young, a bit of physical presence, someone who could effectively act as an understudy for Davies as a partner for either Garner or Beavon. Little point harking back all the time but as I also said Proctor was badly used by both our previous managers and with different handling he might have been a different player.
 
Let's re-sign Proctor, St Ledger, Treacy, Wallace, Parkin and Lucas. We could then have threads on all of them.

There is no reason why players who come back to the club cannot be good signings - Alex Bruce is the obvious example. I have no idea who SG is interested in but of the possibilities St Ledger and, if he could impose some discipline on himslef, Treacy could very likely be more than useful.
 
There is no reason why players who come back to the club cannot be good signings - Alex Bruce is the obvious example. I have no idea who SG is interested in but of the possibilities St Ledger and, if he could impose some discipline on himslef, Treacy could very likely be more than useful.
Why?

Just Why?

We don't need, or want, to go backwards.

St Ledger for all his strengths is far too mistake prone, and like others have said about the likes of Lonergan, many fans would be on his back the second he misplaced a pass as he did consistently after the Middlesborough fiasco.

Treacy has talent however many years ago he left us now, but spending time trying to develop it now he is older just isn't worth it. If we are going to take risks like this, do it with younger or cheaper options.

As for Proctor, Jack Ryan will have the physical presence that we need as back up. Our midfield is not the fastest to get forward, but even so, we made far more chances than our opponents last season. In 33 of our games in fact we had more shots than the opponents.

It would be nice to have more pace and speed of thought, but I'd rather have a different option upfront. i.e a quick striker
 

Because we are in the third tier of English football and don't have a lot of money to spend. But, as I thought I made clear, I am not advocating signing these or any other ex-players. Frankly the players who have already played for us who I really want to see returning to the squad and pushing for a place next season are Ben Davies and Hayhurst.
 
Because we are in the third tier of English football and don't have a lot of money to spend. But, as I thought I made clear, I am not advocating signing these or any other ex-players. Frankly the players who have already played for us who I really want to see returning to the squad and pushing for a place next season are Ben Davies and Hayhurst.
If we don't have a lot of money to spend then the likes of Proctor, Treacy and St Ledger are exactly the sort of players we shouldn't be buying.

They have all been to higher level clubs (Swansea, Burnley and Leicester) and will probably have increased their salaries so that they are unlikely to be cheap.

I like Hayhurst, but doubt he will make it and as for Davies it's going to be hard for him with Laird and Buchanan in front of him.

I'm more excited about Browne and Brownhill and will be interested to see what happens to Jack Ryan and Nick Anderton.
 
PNEinGranby;1895900 I like Hayhurst said:
Who knows what will happen - at the start of least season Brownhill was just another young player and Browne not even our player. As for Hayhurst I think he can be a more than useful player for us - we just have to hope he gets another chance and makes the most of it. As for Davies, well I think he has enough to make keeping both Laird and Buchanan an unnecessary luxury.
 
If we don't have a lot of money to spend then the likes of Proctor, Treacy and St Ledger are exactly the sort of players we shouldn't be buying.

They have all been to higher level clubs (Swansea, Burnley and Leicester) and will probably have increased their salaries so that they are unlikely to be cheap.

I like Hayhurst, but doubt he will make it and as for Davies it's going to be hard for him with Laird and Buchanan in front of him.

I'm more excited about Browne and Brownhill and will be interested to see what happens to Jack Ryan and Nick Anderton.

Davies is clearly part of the plan, hence his contract extension. I wouldn't be surprised to see him forece his way into the reckoning. Don't forget, he can play centre back too so Grayson might see him playing a role as part of a back three rather than a four. Could Davies move ahead King. A back three of Clarke, Wright and Davies with Wiseman coming in and Davies/Laird at left-back if we play a four?

Very important season for Hayhurst. I reckon he'll be given a chance early on and if he steps up then great. If not, I suspect he'll be out on loan again and that'll be it for him at North End.

Browne and Brownhill will be fighting for a central midfield spot and hopefully one or other of them will jump above Welsh in the pecking order. Brownhill in particular is very exciting. If we don't resign Kilkenny, or an equivalent, we could see them forming the first choice midfield pairing before long.

Ryan and Anderton will most likely be sent somewhere on loan and monitored carefully. With luck, they'll be more successful than Croasdale was and be part of the first team picture in 2015-16.
 
Back
Top