Skip to main content

Joe Garner - Defensive Liability?

Joe Garner - Defensive Liability?

Joined
Jan 27, 2012
Messages
4,558
Location
Manchester
**Flack Alert**

No good comes from a striker 'helping' out in the box.

I can think of 3 occasions where Garner has cost PNE when helping out in our own box.

1) Handball against Chesterfield.
2) Lost Steven Jordan against Fleetwood
3) Allowed the Rochdale lad to score the first at weekend.

He is a good header of the ball and one might suggest that he has been unlucky. But at the end of the day he is a striker and not a defender. He should be waiting on the half-way line ready to pounce on the attack.
 
Please make this stop. Have you nothing else to do with your life, than to take time out and create this thread?
 
Please make this stop. Have you nothing else to do with your life, than to take time out and create this thread?

Weird post, he's made a thread about a PNE player on a PNE forum.

Garner probably is a liability at the back at times, a lot of strikers are but i'd probably rather have him defending a set piece over Humphrey who doesn't challenge for headers and is more dangerous on the counter.
 
Weird post, he's made a thread about a PNE player on a PNE forum.

Garner probably is a liability at the back at times, a lot of strikers are but i'd probably rather have him defending a set piece over Humphrey who doesn't challenge for headers and is more dangerous on the counter.

Thanks for the reply.

I was posting to ascertain what people's thoughts were about Garner being in our box and having been directly responsible for three goals we have conceded. I seem to recall a close shave other week when he very nearly headed into his own net!

I am not suggesting he is kicked out of the side or anything, but personally, i would have him on half way with Humph/Reid ready to break on the opposition. Putting 2 men on half way also means that the attacking side cannot over commit at corners and set pieces.
 
Thanks for the reply.

I was posting to ascertain what people's thoughts were about Garner being in our box and having been directly responsible for three goals we have conceded. I seem to recall a close shave other week when he very nearly headed into his own net!

I am not suggesting he is kicked out of the side or anything, but personally, i would have him on half way with Humph/Reid ready to break on the opposition. Putting 2 men on half way also means that the attacking side cannot over commit at corners and set pieces.
Jones was to blame for the first Rochdale goal, so you can cross that one off your hit list, Mr. Lawyer.
 
Jones was to blame for the first Rochdale goal, so you can cross that one off your hit list, Mr. Lawyer.

Probably wouldn't argue with you on that one as personally, i also believe that Jones should have been out to collect the ball.... However, as he didn't, then it is Garner's job to clear the ball or ensure that the opposition player doesn't get on the end of it, sadly he didn't do that and it is probably because he doesn't have the same defensive mind as a defender.
 
Please make this stop. Have you nothing else to do with your life, than to take time out and create this thread?

I don't know how he finds the time. Most solicitors I have encountered have been barely visible under a mountain of paperwork
 
Jones was to blame for the first Rochdale goal, so you can cross that one off your hit list, Mr. Lawyer.

They were jointly to blame. Regardless of the fact that Jones should have come out and also stopped the header, neither would have mattered if Garner hadn't been out-headed by O'Connell.
 
Probably wouldn't argue with you on that one as personally, i also believe that Jones should have been out to collect the ball.... However, as he didn't, then it is Garner's job to clear the ball or ensure that the opposition player doesn't get on the end of it, sadly he didn't do that and it is probably because he doesn't have the same defensive mind as a defender.
And when Garner failed to do that, it was Jones's job to save the bloody ball instead of letting it dribble in through his legs.

The goal was Jones's fault, so it doesn't belong on your list.
 
Weird post, he's made a thread about a PNE player on a PNE forum.

Garner probably is a liability at the back at times, a lot of strikers are but i'd probably rather have him defending a set piece over Humphrey who doesn't challenge for headers and is more dangerous on the counter.

Why can't we have both? It would give the opposition something to consider... Do they put 3 back in defence or maybe go for 2 with one on the edge of our box and hope to nick a goal because we are being adventurous?

Anything to help out our defence at corners and free kicks with a slightly less congested box?!
 
Not sure i understand?

I am making a point about Garner being somewhat of a liability in our own box and have highlighted 3 such occasions?

I've seen countless time's Garner win headers in our box, care to point out any mistakes other players have made?
Grayson picks the team, the way we play. Why didn't you make this thread when he made mistakes while we was winning?
 
Jones was to blame for the first Rochdale goal, so you can cross that one off your hit list, Mr. Lawyer.

Not completely, the ball was played into a really good area.

It was a 50/50 for whether he should come and gather it or not, he chose not too and Garner lost his man.

However, the ball should not go through his legs from that far out.
 
Not completely, the ball was played into a really good area.

It was a 50/50 for whether he should come and gather it or not, he chose not too and Garner lost his man.

However, the ball should not go through his legs from that far out.

Was the ball really played in to a good area? As far as I can see it was a long cross that Connell met in the 6 yard box. Anything that goes in to the 6 yard box should be claimed by the keeper every time & not by a striker heading toward his own goal. Keepers who remain stuck on their line in these situations frustrate the hell out of me. It isnt as if any referee isnt going blow for a foul the moment an opposition player as much as blows on them. Garner shouldnt be in the box defending set pieces. He should be on the half way line with Humphrey
 
Back
Top