Skip to main content

Joe Garner

Joe Garner

Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
17,366
Location
The desert
..... What do people think of Joe and do you think he will play a key part in our promotion push next season...!?!?

I think he has some good assets for a striker including his pace. Today was hard as LO pressed us hard and the strikers didn't get much of a break.

He has a good work ethic and once he bags his first goal he will go and score a bagful.

Garner, Beavon and maybe the little Canadian who scored today as a 3 with 2 more physical strikers and we will have some good presence going forward....

Sorry Beardsley and Cummins.... Playing for Stevenage next season
 
Garner has ability, touch and pace. Could be good BUT...

He has an annoying habit of taking his first touch, waiting for any contact from the centre-half and then down he goes! It's actually ridiculous how often he does this. I understand this tactic if you are trying to relieve pressure and slow/spoil the game a little. It's not my favourite tactic but it can be affective in disrupting momentum when a team is on top of you, especially at away games. Why do it at home, when you're pushing for a win though? He even does it just as a move is looking good and we could get in on goal; down he goes and then they regather their shape and the moment has gone. Very frustrating.
 
Garner has ability, touch and pace. Could be good BUT...

He has an annoying habit of taking his first touch, waiting for any contact from the centre-half and then down he goes! It's actually ridiculous how often he does this. I understand this tactic if you are trying to relieve pressure and slow/spoil the game a little. It's not my favourite tactic but it can be affective in disrupting momentum when a team is on top of you, especially at away games. Why do it at home, when you're pushing for a win though? He even does it just as a move is looking good and we could get in on goal; down he goes and then they regather their shape and the moment has gone. Very frustrating.

He does need to stop diving so much
 
He does need to stop diving so much

+1

Whilst you could argue that Garner did receive close attention from the Orient defence when he got the ball he was looking to go down rather than beat his man and bring other players into play. Having said that Orient were very physical but it seemed to me that Garner didn't have the confidence to ride a challenge like Beavon would do.

Today was Garner's chance to show us what he can do. Whilst on the one hand he didn't get much service into the box he did show that he's got the potential to be a League One Healy type player with some of his movement inside the box, especially in the first half.
 
Garner has ability, touch and pace. Could be good BUT...

He has an annoying habit of taking his first touch, waiting for any contact from the centre-half and then down he goes! It's actually ridiculous how often he does this. I understand this tactic if you are trying to relieve pressure and slow/spoil the game a little. It's not my favourite tactic but it can be affective in disrupting momentum when a team is on top of you, especially at away games. Why do it at home, when you're pushing for a win though? He even does it just as a move is looking good and we could get in on goal; down he goes and then they regather their shape and the moment has gone. Very frustrating.

He does need to stop diving so much
 
His diving really pissed me off when he played against us so I am having a hard time watching him but I do think he can do a job for us.
 
Today was crying out for a bit of magic and with the exception of Holmes none of our players looked like delivering it.

I agree garner spends more time looking for a foul than he should and away this could be useful.

At home however he needed to be more positive with the ball and like beavon seemed a bit too involved in wide areas to influence what happens in the middle.

Of what I have seen of him he has yet to get near the level he showed when playin for Carlisle against us where he was a thorn in ourside for the whole game.
 
a slightly worse beavon, decent league one player but IMO we need a new target man to play alongside beavon for next year, garner is on the bench (sorry)
 
He's got a spring in his heels and a good turn, but seems to welcome contact instead of avoiding it. Doesn't work as hard as Beavon but is stronger. Don't write him off yet, on one performance.
 
Don't think he is good enough IMHO

Goes down to easy
Never gambles with a run
no tricks or skills
He is does not look a threat
Takes the easy option every time , I would prefare Jack King over him every time and I don;t rate King if I'm honest
 
Same as Mousinho for me.

He has proved at other clubs he has genuine ability.

So far he has not shone at Preston North End. In fact he has looked quite poor.

but he has not has a fair run of games to pass genuine judgement.

Until that time , I'm prepared to give him a chance
 
His diving really pissed me off when he played against us so I am having a hard time watching him but I do think he can do a job for us.

Agreed. For Carlisle against us, he was the most annoying player we have played against all season. He was constantly diving, won a penalty and scored from it.

As he is now our player, his diving now embarrasses me and unfortunately some of our other players do it too much too - King, Hayhurst and Holmes being the worst culprits.
 
Back
Top