Skip to main content

Joe Garner

Joe Garner

Joined
Aug 22, 2004
Messages
3,052
Great attitude and workrate from Garner tonight! Gave it everything all evening! Fair enough his finishing wasn't there but thought he was MOM imo.
 
He played well, he missed some chances but I wouldn't say they were shocking misses, if Hume had missed them then there wouldn't have been half as many groans.
 
I'm sorry but for me giving everything is a prerequisite!!

His finishing to put it mildly was dog shit.

Yeah, but he was trying. From where I was sat he stood out in being a real grafter in the 2nd half. I've said on another thread that his finishing might need some work, but it was good to see him getting in there.

There seemed to be too many on our team that were just stood watching tonight.

Garner was not one of them.
 
I'm not his biggest fan I'm afraid. He wins free kicks which is a positive but as a striker he needs to score goals which he isn't doing.So yea he's below average in my estimation.
 
Didn't like him too much last season, but the improvement has been notable this time around - lots less diving around, better work ethic, which is always nice to see, but he still needs to add goals and decision making to his game to make him a first choice striker, which I'm not too sure he can, but I'd be gladly proven wrong.
 
He played well, he missed some chances but I wouldn't say they were shocking misses, if Hume had missed them then there wouldn't have been half as many groans.

The one where he spun on the edge of the 6 yard box before firing wide was!!

He should have done much better when he dragged a shot wide late on as well.

And yes, I would have moaned had Hume missed the same chances.

🙄
 
I wish Wroe & Mouisinho would display the same fight and desire to get back into the 1st team.
 
I wish Wroe & Mouisinho would display the same fight and desire to get back into the 1st team.

Moose was at fault for both goals and almost the howler of the season bad back pass which Stuckman controlled as bad as Tepi at his worst!

The guy had a chance to show at least some desire tonight but it ain't going to happen he needs to move on when the window opens
 
Moose was at fault for both goals and almost the howler of the season bad back pass which Stuckman controlled as bad as Tepi at his worst!

The guy had a chance to show at least some desire tonight but it ain't going to happen he needs to move on when the window opens

Isn't moose a midfielder. Slotting in at centre half with a full back on one side and the least reliable of our usual three to his right was always going to be an ask. It reminded me of his games at right back under the winning draw specialist.

I expect that he will be released next summer as he is well down the pecking order for a game in the middle.

He should have cleared the ball for a throw for the first and he should know stuckmann is poor on the deck. Not sure about the 2nd goal as the scorer appeared to come from deep to get on the end of it.

Too many changes tonight with a number of players uncomfortable with the formation and each other. Oldham had almost the same team as last time we played them and deserved to win.
 
only our 4th choice striker really, Davies Beavon and Hume all come before him, not a bad 4th choice option but wouldn't rely on him if we got injuries.
 
He's got a little nastiness in him as well hasn't he? Took out their full back probably on purpose.

Seemed to be trying too hard to find the far corner I think just smashing a couple towards goal would have seen him bag one.
 
Back
Top