First PNE player to break the 20 goal mark since Cresswell in 2004/5, keeps this up and he could well still get to 30 goals and the golden boot, only 2 goals off the current leaders, who woulda thought that the big goal striker that we all craved in the summer was someone we already had?
Joe Garner
- Joined
- Dec 4, 2005
- Messages
- 22,726
His 2nd goal was a great strike.
boltons1
The Gentry (RIP)
- Joined
- Mar 7, 2005
- Messages
- 6,110
It was right after Oldham in the JPT -he was a class above that night and although he played with concussion and didn't score I don't think(?) his misses and positioning in the box showed that his confidence had returned. He's now getting the goals he wasn't doing before and I knew he would after watching him that night. Well done Joe!
OP
cheshirewhite
Thread starter
It's even better that he's a Preston fan as well, you can tell what it means to him, especially after a rough start
- Joined
- Dec 4, 2005
- Messages
- 22,726
It was right after Oldham in the JPT -he was a class above that night and although he played with concussion and didn't score I don't think(?) his misses and positioning in the box showed that his confidence had returned. He's now getting the goals he wasn't doing before and I knew he would after watching him that night. Well done Joe!
I thought he was poor that night and wrote him off as not being any good for us.
Shows what I know, the lads been different class.
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2004
- Messages
- 1,222
It was right after Oldham in the JPT -he was a class above that night and although he played with concussion and didn't score I don't think(?) his misses and positioning in the box showed that his confidence had returned. He's now getting the goals he wasn't doing before and I knew he would after watching him that night. Well done Joe!
I only wish I had seen in Garner what you did in the JPT. I thought his failure to score that night was indicative of a striker who wasn't going to make it here.
At the start of the season I had him as 4th choice behind Davies Beavon and Hume.
Now like most he is first choice up front for me.
I thought he looked a player when he came here with Carlisle and on that basis expected more.
If he can Chanel his aggression a little better and be a bit cleverer with his gamesmanship he can go on to better things than league 1. Another 5 goals looks likely by May so I I expect him to be our first 20 league goals in a season for a few years.
Just hope he keeps it up.
I liken Joe Garner to strikers like Tony Ellis, Steve Basham and Johnny Macken of recent seasons, who all got loads of stick early doors because they were missing chances and not scoring - yet these type of players usually come good sooner or later.
-its the Strikers who never get into positions where they ever look like they should score that you worry about
We have had a few of those over the years!
-its the Strikers who never get into positions where they ever look like they should score that you worry about
We have had a few of those over the years!
I liken Joe Garner to strikers like Tony Ellis, Steve Basham and Johnny Macken of recent seasons, who all got loads of stick early doors because they were missing chances and not scoring - yet these type of players usually come good sooner or later.
-its the Strikers who never get into positions where they ever look like they should score that you worry about
We have had a few of those over the years!
I make you absolutely bob on.
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2004
- Messages
- 2,870
One thing I like about Garner (aside from the fact he scores goals) - he contests EVERYTHING. He's always got his arms up moaning about summat. And if he gives the ball away or misses a good chance, you can see that he curses himself.
This lad cares about our club.
This lad cares about our club.
- Joined
- Sep 30, 2012
- Messages
- 1,151
I liken Joe Garner to strikers like Tony Ellis, Steve Basham and Johnny Macken of recent seasons, who all got loads of stick early doors because they were missing chances and not scoring - yet these type of players usually come good sooner or later.
-its the Strikers who never get into positions where they ever look like they should score that you worry about
We have had a few of those over the years!
Good point. Only thing I disagree on is including Steve Basham in that list. He hit the ground running here, scoring 10 league goals in his loan spell. I'd have swapped his name for Nogan who seemed to take ages to score for us.
And to think that some thought him not worthy without really giving him time to find his feet. Would anyone like to admit to this error of judgement?
And to think that some thought him not worthy without really giving him time to find his feet. Would anyone like to admit to this error of judgement?
I thought he had it in him but would never come good for Preston.