Skip to main content

Joe Garner

Joe Garner

Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
14,205
Location
San Diego (A Whales Vagina)
Simple debate, how much do you think we will miss him?

Obviously he has been our best player over the past 12 months really coming into form and scoring plenty of goals. But will his injury be part of defining our season?

The next 2 months worth of fixtures will really show us whether or not we can be competitive towards the top end of the division without him.

The only positive to come out of it is that he definitely won't be sold in January and there is less possibility of him being sold in the summer if we don't get promotion.

I will also add that we have had 11 different goals scorers in the league.

I think a lot of pressure has now been put on Beckford as he is our only striker who is fit and can last close to 90 minutes.

Andy Little is coming back as well hopefully he can take some of the burden as well.

Thoughts?
 
Obviously loosing your top goalscorer and one that was still in form will be a huge loss. Question should be have we got or going to sign someone that is able to match his performances
 
At least his injury has coincided with us keeping clean sheets again, we need that to continue because I can't see us hitting 3 or more goals in many games this season.
 
Obviously a huge blow for us, but I genuinely believe we can keep our promotion push going.

I'm looking forward to seeing Fewster in action, and as the OP says, we do have players coming back from injury.

I do however, fear that we will become draw specialists again as we will shift focus on to keeping clean sheets. I hope this won't be the case but only time will tell!
 
I think it's a disaster and we will not get promoted now due to his injury. We may not have with him but I think unless we get someone in we have no chance now.

None of the other loanees/strikers will score anywhere near what he would have
 
At least his injury has coincided with us keeping clean sheets again, we need that to continue because I can't see us hitting 3 or more goals in many games this season.


Agree. But let's hope we're wrong once we see what Little and Beckford really have to offer - perhaps Fewster too, though he's young (and maybe other incoming in January?)

Personally, I think we were always going to be borderline for a shot at automatic... and with Garner out for 4 months, I think that just HAS to cost us a few points. In all probablility, that makes our chance of automatic quite low... but still not impossible.

Fingers crossed.
 
I think it's a disaster and we will not get promoted now due to his injury. We may not have with him but I think unless we get someone in we have no chance now.

None of the other loanees/strikers will score anywhere near what he would have

I agree to a point, but not many other league one strikers will get to a tally he would have anyway.

As we have seen goals are coming from all over the park this season so don't get too down yet!

I assume Grayson will be shifting the mentality to ensure everyone going forward knows they need to be scoring goals.
 
I think the problem is Little and Hugill are shit.

If they weren't then we would have been OK, but they are.

Beckford needs a goal and soon, he's a confidence player and right now his confidence is lower than a snakes testicle.

Disagree. I thought Hugill looked a decent player whenever he got a game.

He could win the ball, hold it up, and unlike most target men he could actually chase down a ball or two.
 
Top scorer and biggest threat.

Will we miss him?

You do the math.

Forget the Maths, you need to bone up on your english, WIBG, old buddy, old pal.

The question was never "Will we miss him?", you thundercunt-ish WUM.

I know, I know. "Reported".
 
Top scorer and biggest threat.

Will we miss him?

You do the math.

Someone did do the math and the math was that Garners goals contributed directly to 5 points so far this season.

So it roughly equates to 10-12 points over the season which will see us fall very short, that is assuming that nobody upfront scores any goals.

I think it's a disaster and we will not get promoted now due to his injury. We may not have with him but I think unless we get someone in we have no chance now.

None of the other loanees/strikers will score anywhere near what he would have

Fewster and Beckford haven't even opened there suitcases yet and your saying there not going to score.

Did you say the same about Robinson before he kicked a ball? Give the lads a chance.
 
Someone did do the math and the math was that Garners goals contributed directly to 5 points so far this season.

So it roughly equates to 10-12 points over the season which will see us fall very short, that is assuming that nobody upfront scores any goals.

You see Ron this is where your stats, which you seem to think is the be all and end all of any discussion, falls flat on its face my darling.

You can't manage into stats how other teams set up to deal with Garner, leaving space in other areas. You can't show what he did in the game apart from score the goals. You can't show lots of things Ron, you lovable rouge.

So the maths Ron, on this occasion, are bollocks.
 
I understood that Beckford was not signed as Garners replacement.

I understand that comments were also made on this forum about Garners injury before the close of the transfer window. I'm presuming that we were quoted ridiculous loan fees as a result, and as such we could only get young Fewster.

Perhaps their is a lesson to be learned here.
 
You can't manage into stats how other teams set up to deal with Garner, leaving space in other areas. You can't show what he did in the game apart from score the goals. You can't show lots of things Ron, you lovable rouge.

So the maths Ron, on this occasion, are bollocks.

......is the right answer.
 
Someone did do the math and the math was that Garners goals contributed directly to 5 points so far this season.

So it roughly equates to 10-12 points over the season which will see us fall very short, that is assuming that nobody upfront scores any goals.

Do those stats also account for the points he cost us, ie Chesterfield at home, or are they one-sided and therefore not worth anything?

For what it is worth, I think his injury will cost us automatic, not just because we'll miss his quality but the way we set up will have to change which will take time to adjust to (cue us now winning 12 points from they remaining 4 games of the year and progressing inter JPT now I've said that... 😉 )
 
We lost 3 league games on the spin with him in the team.

We have won 2 league games in a row (both clean sheets) without him in the team, including one against top of the league.

Good reaction to losing your top scorer.
 
I don't think it's a case of Garner's absence is season over. Don't get me wrong, it's a huge blow. Coupled with Robinson's recall, it was alot to take in.

What will define our season is the next 6 weeks. The first stage is December fixtures. It's obvious, that squad is lacking at the moment in the strike department, but it's paramount that the team stay competitive and grind out results, it doesn't have to be pretty. If the team can stay in contention up until 1st January, things are going well.

The January transfer window is the second stage, where is the season could be won or loss. Crucial signings include 2 strikers and central attacking mid. I do agree that the an additional defender is required to strengthen the team, but I just don't Grayson sees it that way with the current performance of our back line. While on the subject of Grayson, SG is under alot of pressure to succeed this season (and although I quite like the boring git), failure to achieve promotion will most likely spell the end of his tenure with PNE.

I don't believe Preston are a one man team, but if i'm wrong and it really is lights out for this season because of Joe, then I wouldn't of wanted to get promoted. A fine goal scorer might be able to get you out of League one, but he certainly wouldn't be able to save a team alone from relegation in the Championship.
 
I hope that all the other teams think of us as a 1-man Team, and sit back and relax a little now when they come up against us.

As has already been pointed out, our goals come from all over the park, so when teams get complacent with us because Garner isn't playing, I can see thembeing in for a shock.
 
Back
Top