Skip to main content

Joe Garner

Joe Garner

raefil

Dolly Patron
Joined
Jan 11, 2005
Messages
111,060
This might not go down well with the faithful but................. Sorry he was a liability tonight. Totally got the refs back up and as a result no 50/50 decisions went our way in the 2nd half. We spent a lot of time criticising Rooney for his dive but in all truth Rooneys an amateur in comparison to our Joe.

Its happening too often and too obvious now, im afraid.
 
Was heading for a red card as well which is why I think they subbed him.

I like the nasty edge he has to his game but on occasions like tonight he sometimes goes to far with the diving.
 
Garner stopped two guilt edged chances by clearing the ball in the six yard box tonight.

He was fabulous in defence on those two occasions but I think he needs a spell on the bench. Coming on in the second half to piss off the centre half just as they get comfortable.
 
I honestly thought when the liner and ref were talking that he had punched someone or something and would get a red.

In the end they spoke to no one. Was a bit strange.

Shouldn't be needing to take him off to avoid getting red cards.
 
He was dogshit tonight, but to be fair when he's living off hopeful 60 yard punts, 2 wide men who failed to put a cross in all night and a midfield who didn't get within 30 yards of him for over an hour then it isn't surprising he was dogshit.
 
The service too him wasn't great in fairness, but some of his antics are a bit pathetic at times. He needs to focus on playing Football, because he is bloody damn good at it.
 
He was dogshit tonight, but to be fair when he's living off hopeful 60 yard punts, 2 wide men who failed to put a cross in all night and a midfield who didn't get within 30 yards of him for over an hour then it isn't surprising he was dogshit.

Good summary.
 
Maybe a case for Beckford starting in Garner's place on current form?

Its not his form that concerns me, more his antics, in truth. Its going way OTT. I honestly think its turning refs against us.
 
Oh absolutely. One average game in his last 35. I completely agree, get him dropped, he's a waste of space.

You really need to look at yourself people.
 
He was bullied out of the game by his markers, it wasn't his sort of game, Davies should have been brought on for the last 30 mins at least.
 
Joey is a cheat no ifs or butts.

I was speaking to a ref who gets the odd game in league 2 before the season.

He said they had been to a training session before the season and Joe Garner was one of the players mentioned when diving was highlighted. In the minds of refs so probably misses out on decisions he should get now
 
Come off it. He's played up front on his own against 2 center backs and was feeding off scraps. Did either winger get to the bye line and cross the ball, or did either midfielder feed him the ball to his feet? No. I thought it was crying out for one of the wingers to be taken off and Davies put up front with him. But do I know more than the manager that's got us to 2nd in the league in March? No. We've all got opinions.
 
How many times have I said it - Garner needs a robust partner. He is wasted in that lone striker role. I said it even when we seemed to be winning with him in that role. Perhaps now it will be obvious. Play him upfront alongside Davies or Ebanks-Blake or maybe even Beckford. Given that Gallagher will still play and that we need a central midfield partnership of two other players then out of tonight's starting line-up one or other of Robinson and Humphrey needs to give way. These are the decisions SG is paid to make and which frankly he sometimes shies away from.
 
The two CB's he was playing against was calling for KD to be introduced after 10 minutes of the second half, either go 3-5-2 to stop them flooding the midfield or go 4-4-2 and hope we didn't get over run in midfield.

The flooding of the midfield by Doncaster was done to not allow us to play football and isolate JG upfront on his own and it worked a treat.
 
He needed a partner up top with him tonight because he was a liability playing up front on his own tonight, So I would start him alongside Beckford on Saturday?
 
Back
Top