Skip to main content

Joe Garner?

Joe Garner?

Joined
Jul 30, 2009
Messages
17,283
Location
Cheshire
Although he's our best player at the club, would anyone be tempted to have him on the bench from the start in any of the upcoming games, because to me he looks so out of form & isn't playing as a team member, but instead for himself & looks more likely to be sent off? ( just asking a the questions & for everyone's opinion?)
 
Although he's our best player at the club, would anyone be tempted to have him on the bench from the start in any of the upcoming games, because to me he looks so out of form & isn't playing as a team member, but instead for himself & looks more likely to be sent off? ( just asking a the questions & for everyone's opinion?)

No
 
Who would you put instead?
Injured Beckford?
No goals Davies?
Overweight SEB?

I agree, but at the same time I'm just getting fed up with his on field actions & Performances lately which has been very frustrating in recent games, because in my mind he is Is playing more with his heart then with head. So just wondering if by playing Davies up top on his on at Port Vale like we did at Sheffield United where he can hold the ball up & then bring the Players like Robinson, Johnson & Gallagher into the game more?
 
I agree, but at the same time I'm just getting fed up with his on field actions & Performances lately which has been very frustrating in recent games, because in my mind he is Is playing more with his heart then with head. So just wondering if by playing Davies up top on his on at Port Vale like we did at Sheffield United where he can hold the ball up & then bring the Players like Robinson, Johnson & Gallagher into the game more?

I know what you mean but I think as much as he does all that and doesn't play well there's still times when he can produce a moment of magic whenever he's on the pitch
 
Pretty sure we had people posting stuff like this in the days before he popped in four goals.

Garner adds a lot more to our play than purely goals. January proved that.
 
I think garner has got a bit too cocky, id put him on the bench for port vale if beckford is available.
 
Start with Davies and Garner - the only alternative might be to partner Garner with Robinson, who is after all a striker not a winger.
 
Haven't been able to understand why Robinson is not starting up front.
SG again having his tactics questioned. Not brining King on in a defensive role when we needed to see out the game last night??.
However back on topic yes Garner should start up front with Robinson.
 
Radio Lancs after the game said a Gillingham player hit him. No idea why Garner was also booked. The referee even gave us a free kick!

That referee was a joke. Worst Ive seen for many years. Garner got booked for being punched. He should never ref a game at League level again after that display. As for JG, he just needs one to go in, then he'll be back to his best. Sadly, SG's substitutions cost us the game last night, along with the ref. 🙁
 
I thought garner had a decent game, last night. His goals have dried up for now but theyll be back. If fit Beckford alongside Garner every day of the week for me.

I agree with Staffordwhite that the bizarre substitutions is what cost us the game last night. The moment we went one up front it was game up and Garner got more and more frustrated.
 
Radio Lancs after the game said a Gillingham player hit him. No idea why Garner was also booked. The referee even gave us a free kick!

Something garner said upset their no. 5 who walked up to garner and put 2 hands on him and pushed him over. Straight red I thought raising your hands. Dreadful ref he should be suspended after that display.
 
I thought garner had a decent game, last night. His goals have dried up for now but theyll be back. If fit Beckford alongside Garner every day of the week for me.

I agree with Staffordwhite that the bizarre substitutions is what cost us the game last night. The moment we went one up front it was game up and Garner got more and more frustrated.

His link up play was good, he won a lot of headers. But he was snatching at chances.

Playing Port Vale, who hate him, on Friday will go one of two ways. He'll either play a blinder, or he'll get sent off.
 
Something garner said upset their no. 5 who walked up to garner and put 2 hands on him and pushed him over. Straight red I thought raising your hands. Dreadful ref he should be suspended after that display.

I didn't see the incident but sounds like two yellows for me with Garner going down like Wade Barrett had floored him.....he did have his best game for a while though apart from score. Won nearly every header and some good lay off play.....has to play if fit.
 
We've had a few bad refs recently at Deepdale. Who was worst, last nights or the ref who forgot his cards the other week?

On topic, JG is quality and should start every game. A player playing with his heart over his head? Imagine saying that a few years ago you would have been laughed at!
 
Back
Top