I've not watched as much of Preston this year but I've started noticing criticism of our player of the year. I felt the role King had as link man between beavon and welsh and wroe greatly helped the midfield last season and that possibly the support he provided to the midfield was somewhat overlooked. Welsh had been criticised by some for his pre-season form and there's been a lot of mention of prestons midfield being overrun in the last few matches...is John welsh a starter on sat v Walsall or do you believe Grayson has doubts about his effectiveness for pne? (as shown by him being subbed and benched in recent matches)...the midfield positions appear very much up for grabs...
John Welsh
I've not watched as much of Preston this year but I've started noticing criticism of our player of the year. I felt the role King had as link man between beavon and welsh and wroe greatly helped the midfield last season and that possibly the support he provided to the midfield was somewhat overlooked. Welsh had been criticised by some for his pre-season form and there's been a lot of mention of prestons midfield being overrun in the last few matches...is John welsh a starter on sat v Walsall or do you believe Grayson has doubts about his effectiveness for pne? (as shown by him being subbed and benched in recent matches)...the midfield positions appear very much up for grabs...
I don't think having Keane alongside him has helped
- Joined
- Dec 4, 2005
- Messages
- 22,727
It will be poor by Grayson if he drops Keane or Byrom after tonight's performance.
It will be poor by Grayson if he drops Keane or Byrom after tonight's performance.
I don't think he will I can't see too many changes apart from bring Davies back in. The only thing is with us leaking goals he may change the centre halves but then leaves Keane the only option at right back..... Aaarrggh
- Joined
- Oct 19, 2004
- Messages
- 14,854
I've not watched as much of Preston this year but I've started noticing criticism of our player of the year. I felt the role King had as link man between beavon and welsh and wroe greatly helped the midfield last season and that possibly the support he provided to the midfield was somewhat overlooked. Welsh had been criticised by some for his pre-season form and there's been a lot of mention of prestons midfield being overrun in the last few matches...is John welsh a starter on sat v Walsall or do you believe Grayson has doubts about his effectiveness for pne? (as shown by him being subbed and benched in recent matches)...the midfield positions appear very much up for grabs...
Welsh is a good player at this level but hasn't been at his best so far this season. I think Grayson will start with Byrom and Keane on Saturday as they both played well tonight.
I agree about King. He's no striker but we are definitely missing him. As you say, he helped out the midfield and was also excellent defensively at set pieces. Westley said that he would end up as a centre half and when fit, I'd like to see him given a chance there.
It will be poor by Grayson if he drops Keane or Byrom after tonight's performance.
+1
Looked like a promising partnership and so should get the go ahead to start vs Walsall.
I know it was a different season and he had suffered with injury the beginning of last season. He then ended up player of the year.
Some players just start the season slowly but I genuinely don't think playing him alongside Keane helps him. Welsh alongside Wroe or Byrom would be key
Some players just start the season slowly but I genuinely don't think playing him alongside Keane helps him. Welsh alongside Wroe or Byrom would be key
I don't think having Keane alongside him has helped
Keane makes welsh look like a slightly weaker and less willing to put a tackle in, the two things which welsh does so well, and they both offer little to nothing in terms of final ball
Keane makes welsh look like a slightly weaker and less willing to put a tackle in, the two things which welsh does so well, and they both offer little to nothing in terms of final ball
Welsh is a good player and a good tackler. Keane runs across tackling everyone and quashing Welshs game
- Joined
- Apr 6, 2012
- Messages
- 31,336
Welsh is a good player and a good tackler. Keane runs across tackling everyone and quashing Welshs game
So are you suggesting we tell Keane to stop tackling people to give Welsh a chance?!! I'd expect this kind of post from 05Simpson, but not you.
So are you suggesting we tell Keane to stop tackling people to give Welsh a chance?!! I'd expect this kind of post from 05Simpson, but not you.
Not at all but we are not getting the best out of last seasons player of the year
Not at all but we are not getting the best out of last seasons player of the year
yep thats the point keane is just so keen(!) to make a tackle it stops welsh from doing what hes best at
yep thats the point keane is just so keen(!) to make a tackle it stops welsh from doing what hes best at
I like Keane but he is a headless chicken. He wants to cover everywhere and yes if your an attacking midfielder then happy days but as a fellow defensive midfielders, and a better one at that, it must be hard when your colleague has no positional play
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2006
- Messages
- 2,703
I like Keane but he is a headless chicken. He wants to cover everywhere and yes if your an attacking midfielder then happy days but as a fellow defensive midfielders, and a better one at that, it must be hard when your colleague has no positional play
What have we seen this season to say welsh is any better than keane???
just picking a player cause he was player of the year is ridiculous, and the fact that some grown men are using that as justification for him having a place in the starting 11 is laughable. Keanes final ball is far superior than welsh, keane wins the ball, takes the ball, passes the ball, all with what appears great ease. Welsh has been poor this season so far, And we cant use the excuse he needs games, all players need games but you cant have an out of form player that is effecting how the team perform on the pitch just to give him game time, Keane and Byrom looked solid and composed and they both complimented each others strengths perfectly. But if we all want someone who wont track back or get stuck in playing just to make Welsh look better then so be it ffs.
What have we seen this season to say welsh is any better than keane???
just picking a player cause he was player of the year is ridiculous, and the fact that some grown men are using that as justification for him having a place in the starting 11 is laughable. Keanes final ball is far superior than welsh, keane wins the ball, takes the ball, passes the ball, all with what appears great ease. Welsh has been poor this season so far, And we cant use the excuse he needs games, all players need games but you cant have an out of form player that is effecting how the team perform on the pitch just to give him game time, Keane and Byrom looked solid and composed and they both complimented each others strengths perfectly. But if we all want someone who wont track back or get stuck in playing just to make Welsh look better then so be it ffs.
I've seen pretty much a full season to justify my opinion as opposed to a few games.... Welsh wins the ball, takes the ball and passes the ball and I would say is a better distributor of the ball.
I'd have Welsh as the defensive midfielder as I'd have Keane at right back
What have we seen this season to say welsh is any better than keane???
just picking a player cause he was player of the year is ridiculous, and the fact that some grown men are using that as justification for him having a place in the starting 11 is laughable. Keanes final ball is far superior than welsh, keane wins the ball, takes the ball, passes the ball, all with what appears great ease. Welsh has been poor this season so far, And we cant use the excuse he needs games, all players need games but you cant have an out of form player that is effecting how the team perform on the pitch just to give him game time, Keane and Byrom looked solid and composed and they both complimented each others strengths perfectly. But if we all want someone who wont track back or get stuck in playing just to make Welsh look better then so be it ffs.
''But if we all want someone who wont track back or get stuck in playing just to make Welsh look better then so be it ffs.''
No we need an attacking midfielder because without we struggle to score and create chances
- Joined
- Apr 6, 2012
- Messages
- 31,336
I've seen pretty much a full season to justify my opinion as opposed to a few games.... Welsh wins the ball, takes the ball and passes the ball and I would say is a better distributor of the ball.
I'd have Welsh as the defensive midfielder as I'd have Keane at right back
Then why is Keane beating him to the tackles and quashing his game? Could it be that Keane is doing the job better, and that's why Welsh is being substituted or dropped? Keane is showing more commitment, more desire, higher work rate and a better anticipation of the game. It's about time we had genuine competition for places and I hope it spurs Welsh on to fight for his position (and the captaincy)
Still absolutely stunned that you'd want to drop a player or move him from his favoured position for tackling too much and too quickly!!!!
Then why is Keane beating him to the tackles and quashing his game? Could it be that Keane is doing the job better, and that's why Welsh is being substituted or dropped? Keane is showing more commitment, more desire, higher work rate and a better anticipation of the game. It's about time we had genuine competition for places and I hope it spurs Welsh on to fight for his position (and the captaincy)
Still absolutely stunned that you'd want to drop a player or move him from his favoured position for tackling too much and too quickly!!!!
Both would be better with an attack minded midfielder alongside them but only Keane has had that opportunity this season so can't judge Welsh based on that this season can we....?!?
I'd put Keane at right back as I feel it would help the team overall and Welsh alongside an attack minded midfielder.... which he had last season would enhance his game....
Yes SG has decided to take Welsh off more than Keane but the two playing alongside each other isn't working as we aren't getting the best out of one of our best players or getting the best for the team. Keane and Monakana on the right side would create more for the team and Welsh isnt a weak link
- Joined
- Apr 6, 2012
- Messages
- 31,336
Both would be better with an attack minded midfielder alongside them but only Keane has had that opportunity this season so can't judge Welsh based on that this season can we....?!?
I'd put Keane at right back as I feel it would help the team overall and Welsh alongside an attack minded midfielder.... which he had last season would enhance his game....
Yes SG has decided to take Welsh off more than Keane but the two playing alongside each other isn't working as we aren't getting the best out of one of our best players or getting the best for the team. Keane and Monakana on the right side would create more for the team and Welsh isnt a weak link
Is this the same Keith Keane who gets a booking every game when he plays at right back because it isn't his natural position? And the same John Welsh that played alongside an attacking midfielder in virtually every game last year so we already know what he can do?
Two players fighting for the same shirt, and you actually want to drop the one playing best?!!!
Is this the same Keith Keane who gets a booking every game when he plays at right back because it isn't his natural position? And the same John Welsh that played alongside an attacking midfielder in virtually every game last year so we already know what he can do?
Two players fighting for the same shirt, and you actually want to drop the one playing best?!!!
He lunges in whether in centre mid or right back. By the pure nature of his game he will pick up yellow cards and although he hasn't picked up any this season I am sure he will. I think you will see him get more yellows when he doesn't have Welsh alongside him as he will have to do more tackling.
Yeah I know what Welsh could do in a poor side and he was our best player and rightly our skipper.
I'm not dropping Keane I guess you don't read the posts