Skip to main content

John Welsh

John Welsh

I think Welshy has a point to prove. He's a top lad, like the other two - but his form at the start of this season hasn't been great. Not terrible, but not great. I think Keane is better defensively and Byrom/King are better going forwards. For now - leave him on the bench to impress the gaffer, and stick with Keane and Byrom.
 
Simple solution is don't play 2 similar style defensive midfielders. Welsh is a good player at this level and proven in his position. Keane is stepping up and has done OK but lacks the positional awareness required of a proper DM. One or the the other alongside an attacking or creative midfielder, maybe give Byrom a chance but I'd prefer a new signing ahead of Wroe or Mousinho, who I don't rate.
 
I've been a bit concerned from day one under Grayson that we have two really defensive midfielders (very good ones I might add) holding up play in midfield. I could understand it against Wolves but not against the minnows of league 1. I don't rate Wroe, if Byrom is hitting some form he needs to be given a good run in the team.
 
''But if we all want someone who wont track back or get stuck in playing just to make Welsh look better then so be it ffs.''

No we need an attacking midfielder because without we struggle to score and create chances

you mean a Byrom.......Then when he doesnt get stuck in like welsh or keane he is called lazy, yet when welsh and keane cant see a pass like byrom they have no vision, Keane beating welsh to the majority of tackles speaks volumes, if you cant see that then i think its time to get over your man crush on welsh and actually watch what other players bring to the game.
 
Simple solution is don't play 2 similar style defensive midfielders. Welsh is a good player at this level and proven in his position. Keane is stepping up and has done OK but lacks the positional awareness required of a proper DM. One or the the other alongside an attacking or creative midfielder, maybe give Byrom a chance but I'd prefer a new signing ahead of Wroe or Mousinho, who I don't rate.

I dont understand where people are seeing keanes so called positional unawareness???? he is a defensive midfield and he protects the back four.
 
you mean a Byrom.......Then when he doesnt get stuck in like welsh or keane he is called lazy, yet when welsh and keane cant see a pass like byrom they have no vision, Keane beating welsh to the majority of tackles speaks volumes, if you cant see that then i think its time to get over your man crush on welsh and actually watch what other players bring to the game.

So with Keane playing the full 90 minutes in our last three games and Welsh either being subbed or not getting a game, we have shipped 8 goals, fucking great job Mr. Keane!!!!!
Running about jumping into tackles and missing many of them does not make someone a decent midfielder, he (Keane) also cannot "stand" a winger up when playing full back, dives in gets either beaten or booked, league to far for this lad imho.
 
So with Keane playing the full 90 minutes in our last three games and Welsh either being subbed or not getting a game, we have shipped 8 goals, fucking great job Mr. Keane!!!!!
Running about jumping into tackles and missing many of them does not make someone a decent midfielder, he (Keane) also cannot "stand" a winger up when playing full back, dives in gets either beaten or booked, league to far for this lad imho.

Welsh is a better centre mid than Keane and that will become apparent over a whilst season
 
So with Keane playing the full 90 minutes in our last three games and Welsh either being subbed or not getting a game, we have shipped 8 goals, fucking great job Mr. Keane!!!!!
Running about jumping into tackles and missing many of them does not make someone a decent midfielder, he (Keane) also cannot "stand" a winger up when playing full back, dives in gets either beaten or booked, league to far for this lad imho.

You thought Keane had a bad game last night??

How on earth was he to blame for the goals conceded yesterday??
 
I dont understand where people are seeing keanes so called positional unawareness???? he is a defensive midfield and he protects the back four.

I thought he looked lost at times on Sunday if I am honest, and gave away free kicks just outside the box. I think Welsh will play the majority of games this season but maybe not on Saturday.
 
So with Keane playing the full 90 minutes in our last three games and Welsh either being subbed or not getting a game, we have shipped 8 goals, fucking great job Mr. Keane!!!!!
Running about jumping into tackles and missing many of them does not make someone a decent midfielder, he (Keane) also cannot "stand" a winger up when playing full back, dives in gets either beaten or booked, league to far for this lad imho.

keane does dive in to readily when at full back. clarke is number one right back and keane is not upto his standard in that position. and all 4 goals at coventry come down the left not through the middle billy, Keane offers a bit more bite and urgency than welsh for me. we defo need a byrom like player along side to try and pull the strings, i just hope byroms performance last night was not a one off.
 
keane does dive in to readily when at full back. clarke is number one right back and keane is not upto his standard in that position. and all 4 goals at coventry come down the left not through the middle billy, Keane offers a bit more bite and urgency than welsh for me. we defo need a byrom like player along side to try and pull the strings, i just hope byroms performance last night was not a one off.

Welsh has more composure and is as good in the tackle than keane
 
You thought Keane had a bad game last night??

How on earth was he to blame for the goals conceded yesterday??

Their second goal came about from our midfields inability to tackle Ings who took the piss out of 4 of our players, Welsh would have sorted this even at the expense of a free kick.
 
keane does dive in to readily when at full back. clarke is number one right back and keane is not upto his standard in that position. and all 4 goals at coventry come down the left not through the middle billy, Keane offers a bit more bite and urgency than welsh for me. we defo need a byrom like player along side to try and pull the strings, i just hope byroms performance last night was not a one off.


We missed tackles and gave the ball away further up the pitch last Sunday, when Mousinho replaced Welsh we were like a ship without a bloody rudder.
 
Back
Top