Skip to main content

John Welsh

John Welsh

Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
14,205
Location
San Diego (A Whales Vagina)
I think this lad in recent games has really started to hit form and has been a vital cog in our midfield, Welshy won't score 30 yard screamers or run past 3-4 players like many would hope but he puts himself about wins the ball back and gets the team moving forward.

A performance of note was against Forest on Wednesday, he was everywhere harrying them and putting in some vital tackles, tackles that the other team were not wanting to get involved in because it would get their shorts muddy. Keane may have got MoM on the night but for me it was Welshy and was really unlucky not to score if it wasn't a cracking save my De Vries.

John is a great foil for Kilkenny and they both work very nicely together in Midfield, I wouldn't mind at all if we started playing games with 3 in Midfield in the form of Keane, Welsh and Kilkenny. Some say it might be negative but it worked a treat against one of the best teams in the Championship on Tuesday. Away from home it would allow us to play football on the deck, instead of the football we play when we have 5 at the back, it may help us pick up results but it can be dire and teams can easily counter our wide men by doubling up on them.

At home I would like to see us play the following formation maybe just to give it a go -

Rudd

Wiseman - Clarke - Wright - Buchanan

Keane - Welsh - Kilkenny

Garner - K Davies - C Davies​

Thoughts?
 
Take big Kev out and put Gallagher in there instead. Then drop him slightly behind the front 2. Having the 3 you selected in central midfield will really allow the full backs to push up. Good team and formation.
 
I think this lad in recent games has really started to hit form and has been a vital cog in our midfield, Welshy won't score 30 yard screamers or run past 3-4 players like many would hope but he puts himself about wins the ball back and gets the team moving forward.

A performance of note was against Forest on Wednesday, he was everywhere harrying them and putting in some vital tackles, tackles that the other team were not wanting to get involved in because it would get their shorts muddy. Keane may have got MoM on the night but for me it was Welshy and was really unlucky not to score if it wasn't a cracking save my De Vries.

John is a great foil for Kilkenny and they both work very nicely together in Midfield, I wouldn't mind at all if we started playing games with 3 in Midfield in the form of Keane, Welsh and Kilkenny. Some say it might be negative but it worked a treat against one of the best teams in the Championship on Tuesday. Away from home it would allow us to play football on the deck, instead of the football we play when we have 5 at the back, it may help us pick up results but it can be dire and teams can easily counter our wide men by doubling up on them.

At home I would like to see us play the following formation maybe just to give it a go -

Rudd

Wiseman - Clarke - Wright - Buchanan

Keane - Welsh - Kilkenny

Garner - K Davies - C Davies​

Thoughts?

very good balanced side
 
All that team says to me is hoofball.

Zero creativity in the middle of the park, it would be horrible to watch.
 
It's a bit narrow, garner would have to work the channels when he needs to be in the box.

Agree with this and we wouldn't get the best out of Davies the Younger either. Both would have to track back to protect their fullback to (especially if the perceived weakness of 5-3-2 is the wingback is too exposed). I'd also swap Keane for Brownhill, who is a better footballer and offers much more of a goal threat. As a formation it would work though, just needs the right personnel.
 
It's a bit narrow, garner would have to work the channels when he needs to be in the box.

Not necessarily - the fullbacks would push up, Keane could race around out wide on the right while Gallagher could move between that central position behind the strikers and somewhere more to the left. Laird might, of course, make more sense than Buchanan in this formation. But that strong midfied trio, which could also include either or both of King and Brownhill, makes all the difference - a formation with two strikers and Gallagher and Holmes, though it can be effective later on in a game, is too lightweight as a starting formation because it leaves just two midfielders to do all the work of winning the ball and it can be overrun. If that happens your strikeforce is left high and dry - exactly what happened at Wolves. This is the formation that could, just maybe, get us back into contention for an automatic place.
 
Last edited:
A similar formation to which we ended up with on Wednesday night, which in my opinion worked really well. Keane played the deeper role, and just kept things ticking, Welsh and Kilkenny never stopped running, tracked back when needed, and a side to Welsh I've never seen before but he was darting forward.

I think this is the key to playing at home..
 
Re John Welsh, absolutely brilliant on Wednesday and definately coming into form nicely. He is a brilliant captain and will be absolutely critical if we are to get somewhere this year. Still one of the top 5 players in the squad for me.
 
Keane did very well on Wednesday... but Welsh was clearly the man of the match.

Whoever picked the MotM for the sponsors must have been enjoying the hospitality too much, or just picked his favourite player!
 
I thought we played Kev Davies and Lee Holmes up front on Wed to rest Joe Garner and Craig Davies. They'll probably be our front 2. Away from home we'll be a bit narrower and probably only play Gallagher wide. Whether we play play 3 center backs, bringing in Hunts or King, with wing backs is up the the management. Whoever plays will feel confident after our passing display against Forest. Welsh and Kilkenny are certainties if fit.
 
Re John Welsh, absolutely brilliant on Wednesday and definately coming into form nicely. He is a brilliant captain and will be absolutely critical if we are to get somewhere this year. Still one of the top 5 players in the squad for me.

Simon Grayson said that he thought that John Welsh was MOM on Wednesday. All 3 midfielders were excellent.
 
I took a mate to the game on Weds who has never been to a PNE game in his life. He's a keen footballer, and knows his stuff.

He pointed Welsh out the whole time, saying he was definitely one of our stand-out players.
 
Welshy started out the season in patchy form. Not helped by the fact he often had Byrom alongside. But that's not an excuse and the lad would, I'm sure, admit himself he wasn't in great form. But now I think he is playing even better than last year.

He is fulfilling the promise his early career showed before he got a bad injury at a key time. He will never achieve the heights he possibly could have but he could be a very important player for us in the Championship when we get there.
 
I took a mate to the game on Weds who has never been to a PNE game in his life. He's a keen footballer, and knows his stuff.

He pointed Welsh out the whole time, saying he was definitely one of our stand-out players.

That was Welsh's best game for us in my opinion - definitely man of the match for me, but could see why Keane was given it, as he too put in a very good performance.
 
Back
Top