Johnson?
Just said this on another thread 🙂
Get him signed up long term, so if he does leave, we will receive a sizable fee for him.
Get him signed up long term, so if he does leave, we will receive a sizable fee for him.
The club should not sell him for anything less than £6 mill. That's based on what he has done so far, come Jan he could be worth more. We will have to sell, to reinvest. Sam Johnstone should be the first signing. Its not ideal to sell DJ but its needed.
The club should not sell him for anything less than £6 mill. That's based on what he has done so far, come Jan he could be worth more. We will have to sell, to reinvest. Sam Johnstone should be the first signing. Its not ideal to sell DJ but its needed.
If we were to sell then reinvest, I would prefer it to be reinvested in 3/4 key players, including a replacement for DJ himself. Not sell him then buy a whole new team, because as we've seen when Suarez was sold by Liverpool, it rarely works.
Good players are always hard to replace, no matter how much money is reinvested, hence why Everton for example, held on to Stones this summer.
Besides, is it really "needed" ? As Grayson said when there was interest in Garner last summer, we have no need to sell our best players. Unless we're offered silly, silly money, I'd hold on to the lad for as long as possible.
If we were to sell then reinvest, I would prefer it to be reinvested in 3/4 key players, including a replacement for DJ himself. Not sell him then buy a whole new team, because as we've seen when Suarez was sold by Liverpool, it rarely works.
Good players are always hard to replace, no matter how much money is reinvested, hence why Everton for example, held on to Stones this summer.
Besides, is it really "needed" ? As Grayson said when there was interest in Garner last summer, we have no need to sell our best players. Unless we're offered silly, silly money, I'd hold on to the lad for as long as possible.
sadly in this league, say we got 6 million for him, we would not get 3/4 key players, probably too much cash being chucked about on individuals, just my opinion though. ...
IF we believe the owners post play off final interview, we should be trying for promotion next season. If we survive this season, and do give it a real go next season, we will need to keep hold of our best players, and that includes Johnson.
This.
I like Johnson but I'm not sure he is worth 6 million at this stage of his career. Needs to develop the defensive side of his game a little more and stay consistent all through his first season at this level.
We are only a quarter of the way through it yet.
We are only a quarter of the way through it yet.
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2014
- Messages
- 808
I like Johnson but I'm not sure he is worth 6 million at this stage of his career. Needs to develop the defensive side of his game a little more and stay consistent all through his first season at this level.
We are only a quarter of the way through it yet.
David Silva can't defend
dirk pnemouse
The Gentry (RIP)
- Joined
- Nov 1, 2006
- Messages
- 26,968
We don't need to sell so why would we ? unless its stupid money but i wonder sometimes if fans discuss these things because they want to know who and how much he would go for/to .
Liberation
Forum Patron
I'd be interested to know if there's a big sell on clause for Villa.
I'd be interested to know if there's a big sell on clause for Villa.
If there is just make sure we put a big one on aswell.
Liberation
Forum Patron
If there is just make sure we put a big one on aswell.
Agreed.... But I was thinking that if Villa do have a big sell on clause then it could render any sale ( unless it's silly money) a bit pointless... which would be good for us.
David Silva can't defend
Although you obviously rate DJ, you can't seriously believe David Silva is a good comparison to make? I agree David Silva can't defend but that wasn't really the point and I could also make a strong case that Silva has more in his locker than DJ.
The point I questioned, which you seemed to miss was that DJ was worth 6 million pounds at this moment in time. I personally think you need a more to your game and to have had at least two good seasons at Championship level to command such a fee.
I think he is worth 3 or maybe 3.5 million at a push and definitely has the potential eventually be worth 6 million. Only if he keeps consistently scoring goals and improving at this level for this season and next (if we stay up).
In reality there are better attacking midfield players than DJ who are seasoned campaigners at Championship (some with a good amount of Premiership experience) level not worth 6 million.
Bringing David Silva who is possibly one of the best attacking players in the Premier league into a debate over how much DJ is worth is just silly.