Skip to main content

Jones costing us points

Jones costing us points

Obviously Jones wasn't solely the problem yesterday but he certainly had a poor game on this occasion, he really doesn't seem to inspire confidence to the rest of his defence. There's little point restricting the opposition to only a few chances if your going to concede from virtually every one -as seems to be happening to often recently.
 
Obviously Jones wasn't solely the problem yesterday but he certainly had a poor game on this occasion, he really doesn't seem to inspire confidence to the rest of his defence. There's little point restricting the opposition to only a few chances if your going to concede from virtually every one -as seems to be happening to often recently.[/QUOTE]

Spot on. We have nearly reached the "you shoot, you score" situation last experienced with Iain Turner.
 
Pickford was a lot better than Jones yesterday in every area.

He came and caught the ball when they were under pressure, he made some great saves and his distribution was better than Jones'.

Feck me that pass he did midway through the second half to their right winger was quality, I'd be pleased if one our midfielders could do that.

Jones is an average League 1 keeper. There are plenty worse than Jones however as yesterday shows and from what I've seen this season there are plenty better.

(having said that Pickford was in net for Carlisle last season when we put 6 past him)

Pickford had a great game. He probably thought I'm not letting them take the piss like last season after our boys shipped 6 goals past him.
 
Pickford is on loan from Sunderland at Bradford. He's the same keeper that was between the sticks for Carlisle when we hammered them 6-1.

I've never seen Jones play so I can't really comment. Once we have Wiseman back we can put Tom Clarke back in a centre half instead of King. A back four of Wiseman Clarke Huntington Buchanan/Laird is solid enough, let's see how Jones recovers with those in front of him.

Personally, I'd like to see Stuckmann get a chance. Maybe the JPT game that is coming up will give Grayson more of a diplomatic opportunity to do so.
 
Stuckmann was fantastic when he first arrived but in the JPT and league cup games I have seen he has not impressed me.

Jones began the season behind a back four including Wright Davies and Woods who are currently missing. Since then king and Huntington have come into the middle laird has been tried at left back and replaced by buchanen and wiseman has become right back but replaced by clarke who has been out injured himself.

We need a settled back four for us to judge our defensive unit.

Bradfords corners involved 3 players on the penalty spot all man marked. For the first goal jones was not to blame it was whichever defende lost his man.

For the second the lad needed closing down and wasn't
 
Having watched the highlights, neither of those goals were down to bad goalkeeping. On the match I thought Jones was at fault for both, i was wrong.
 
Bradfords corners involved 3 players on the penalty spot all man marked. For the first goal jones was not to blame it was whichever defende lost his man.
King lost his man, then for good measure got in Clarke's way and headed it into our net.

For the second the lad needed closing down and wasn't
King again.
 
Goalkeepers need to command the box or at the very least the 6 yard box from set pieces. I'd suggest you watch it again. Jones is watching it all happen in front of him.
 
Look at the highlights on youtube and the corner after they score is laughable. Ive never seen a keeper more nailed to his line. Jones gives the Bradford player a little nudge in the back then goes backwards. Is it any wonder there is panic spreading in our defence with a keeper that has no influence whatsoever in his six yard box.

I still think with how their keeper played in the second half he would have come and caught/punched that ball regardless of who is winning headers, i mean its 4 yards out for godsake. The second one was poor defending, backing off giving their lad all the time in the world to find the corner.
 
Look at the highlights on youtube and the corner after they score is laughable. Ive never seen a keeper more nailed to his line. Jones gives the Bradford player a little nudge in the back then goes backwards. Is it any wonder there is panic spreading in our defence with a keeper that has no influence whatsoever in his six yard box.

I still think with how their keeper played in the second half he would have come and caught/punched that ball regardless of who is winning headers, i mean its 4 yards out for godsake. The second one was poor defending, backing off giving their lad all the time in the world to find the corner.

The 2nd corner went beyond the back post. Not keepers territory.
 
Goalkeepers need to command the box or at the very least the 6 yard box from set pieces. I'd suggest you watch it again. Jones is watching it all happen in front of him.

Watched it several times, neither goal was down to poor keeping.
 
High balls into our box is both our keeper's and centre back's main weakness.

There's no leader in there or someone who will take control of the situation, it's been obvious for almost a year, even when Rudd was here.
 
Stuckmann is long past it, not even sure he is up to reserve, but we will find that out if we get an injury/suspension.

Jones is doing fine for me, no need to look for a scape goat. Haven't we conceded fewer than last season at this point with Rudd? He's also getting better as games go by and he was one of the top clean sheets last season in this league.

move along with this one for me
 
At every corner they had 3 players lined up one behind the other and we had 3 defenders lined up next to each other. As such, it is exceedingly difficult to make out who was supposed to be marking who at each and every corner - the same thing happened several times. Having watched the goal several times, it looks to me like Clarke is supposed to have picked up the scorer and King the number 5 - although the 5 also managed to get himself unmarked as well! On the basis that a player tends to pick up the same opposition at every set piece, that view is backed up by the next corner in the highlights when King has the 5. Crap defending by everyone.

Jones should have come for the cross but that doesn't excuse the defenders losing both their opponents. The problem for Jones was the speed of the cross meaning he had to decide instantly whether to come or not - pretty difficult.
 
Watched it several times, neither goal was down to poor keeping.

I disagree Raefil.. For the first goal it is a floated corner that lands in the 6 yard box. Should be food & drink for any goal keeper & unforgiveable that he is stuck rooted to his line. Very similar to the goal at Rochdale. No wonder there is panic in our defence & we are conceding goals left right & centre
 
The 2nd corner went beyond the back post. Not keepers territory.

Of course its keepers territory it was still in the six yard box. He just didn't judge the flight of it. Even if your saying its not his territory why is he stood on his line when its headed back in creating all kinds of panic ?A huge amount of confidence for a back line comes from the keeper. Something i think a lot of people underestimate.

Ive heard Gary Neville and others saying how assured they have been in the past knowing they have a keeper behind them that will relieve pressure by commanding their area, and not being bullied by the opposition. The six yard box at LEAST is the goalkeepers. Yes i know we are league one but you can still find keepers with a presence that can do the basics well like Rochdale's and Bradford's, even Stuckmann when he had a run in the side a few years ago.
 
At every corner they had 3 players lined up one behind the other and we had 3 defenders lined up next to each other. As such, it is exceedingly difficult to make out who was supposed to be marking who at each and every corner - the same thing happened several times. Having watched the goal several times, it looks to me like Clarke is supposed to have picked up the scorer and King the number 5 - although the 5 also managed to get himself unmarked as well! On the basis that a player tends to pick up the same opposition at every set piece, that view is backed up by the next corner in the highlights when King has the 5. Crap defending by everyone.

Jones should have come for the cross but that doesn't excuse the defenders losing both their opponents. The problem for Jones was the speed of the cross meaning he had to decide instantly whether to come or not - pretty difficult.

Pretty difficult for mere mortals like ourselves. But it is a professional keepers job
 
Back
Top