Skip to main content

Jones costing us points

Jones costing us points

The conclusion then is that he is inconsistent....rather like our defence.....
That may be your conclusion.

On the balance of a few good performances vs. a lot of hesitant/crap ones, I think he's verging towards the consistently poor.

Maybe he just enjoys playing down south?
 
That may be your conclusion.

On the balance of a few good performances vs. a lot of hesitant/crap ones, I think he's verging towards the consistently poor.

Maybe he just enjoys playing down south?

Perhaps he does....constantly berating him on the forum will of course make a huge difference to his performances.
 
Perhaps he does....constantly berating him on the forum will of course make a huge difference to his performances.
Yeah, because I'm sure the first thing he does after another disappointing performance is log on here hoping to see us all applauding his efforts.

Let's not get silly.
 
We would have lost 1-0 at Rochdale anyway if it wasn't for his mistakes so the Doncaster equaliser is the only one that jumps out for me.
His Rochdale mistake cost us the points because conceding the first goal changed the whole momentum of the game.

We had been comfortable if dull at 0-0 before he gifted them that one with another misjudged long ball.
 
We would have lost 1-0 at Rochdale anyway if it wasn't for his mistakes so the Doncaster equaliser is the only one that jumps out for me.

Well god that is horrendous after 17 league games.

I'd suggest that having conceded 19 league goals this season and 8 coming in the last 4 games when we have have had Huntington and / or King in the team that he isn't the problem.

Had we played Peterborough away by this point last season....!?!
 
His Rochdale mistake cost us the points because conceding the first goal changed the whole momentum of the game.

We had been comfortable if dull at 0-0 before he gifted them that one with another misjudged long ball.

Yeah, fair point, i'm not his biggest fan at all but I can't really be assed with this slating of him every time we lose. We had some far shitter performers on Saturday.
 
Jones costing us points

His Rochdale mistake cost us the points because conceding the first goal changed the whole momentum of the game.

We had been comfortable if dull at 0-0 before he gifted them that one with another misjudged long ball.

Does the blame not fall on the defender who was out jumped at the back post? The guy marking the player who scored?

We were shit that day so Jones didn't cost us the points. We were out played.

And if Garner had scored the pen to make it 2-1 could you have predicted the out come of the game then?
 
Does the blame not fall on the defender who was out jumped at the back post? The guy marking the player who scored?

We were shit that day so Jones didn't cost us the points. We were out played.

And if Garner had scored the pen to make it 2-1 could you have predicted the out come of the game then?
No, it was Jones's fault. First he thought the ball would carry out of play and Garner could just shield it out, but it didn't, then he let the header in through his legs at his near post, because he was ball-watching rather than anticipating.

And I disagree with your "we were shit" capsule review - the first goal changed everything.

Nothing else that happened in that game after the first goal would've happened the same way if we hadn't conceded first, and we didn't look like conceding until Jones had a high long ball to "deal with".
 
Yeah, fair point, i'm not his biggest fan at all but I can't really be assed with this slating of him every time we lose. We had some far shitter performers on Saturday.
I tend to agree on the whole, and I don't expect him to be dropped at all, but he needs to up his game.

If he really is capable of MoM performances, then let's see more of them.
 
Does the blame not fall on the defender who was out jumped at the back post? The guy marking the player who scored?
So the guy with gloves on who can yunno catch things - he isn't culpable in your mind? We are conceding goals from corners (eg Bradford, Fleetwood, Walsall), we are allowing 60+ yard punts to drop into the box and be tapped in (eg Rochdale twice), we are conceding 25+ yard shots (eg Bradford, Colchester). We are dominating games in terms of shots on target but at the other end failing miserably (eg bradford had three shots on target and got two goals, rochdale had four shots on target and scored three goals). At some point the pedestrian in nets may have to hold his hands up don't ya think?

We should of known as soon as he let that goal in against Notts County what to expect from Jones. Getting beat near post from a tight angle is criminal. And ever since I have seen nothing in the games I have witnessed to think he is a quality goalkeeper. He can't collect crosses, he fails to command his box, the centre backs seem to have little faith in him, his communication at times causes confusion more than anything. He lacks height, strength and seemingly agility too. What the hell is to like about the guy? He seems good at kicking and picking balls outta the net I guess.

I want a goalkeeper who will make a good save now and then, who will also alleviate pressure by claiming crosses or punching balls outta play. But what we get is someone who stays rooted to the line. Right now, I dont see how anyone can suggest Jones is playing well. He simply isn't.
 
Jones costing us points

No, it was Jones's fault. First he thought the ball would carry out of play and Garner could just shield it out, but it didn't, then he let the header in through his legs at his near post, because he was ball-watching rather than anticipating.

And I disagree with your "we were shit" capsule review - the first goal changed everything.

Nothing else that happened in that game after the first goal would've happened the same way if we hadn't conceded first, and we didn't look like conceding until Jones had a high long ball to "deal with".

No Garner got out jumped at the back post.

We were shit.

So if Garner had scored to make it 2-1....?!? What does your crystal ball say about that? Or is Jones to blame for the missed pen aswell?
 
Last edited:
Jones costing us points

So the guy with gloves on who can yunno catch things - he isn't culpable in your mind? We are conceding goals from corners (eg Bradford, Fleetwood, Walsall), we are allowing 60+ yard punts to drop into the box and be tapped in (eg Rochdale twice), we are conceding 25+ yard shots (eg Bradford, Colchester). We are dominating games in terms of shots on target but at the other end failing miserably (eg bradford had three shots on target and got two goals, rochdale had four shots on target and scored three goals). At some point the pedestrian in nets may have to hold his hands up don't ya think?

We should of known as soon as he let that goal in against Notts County what to expect from Jones. Getting beat near post from a tight angle is criminal. And ever since I have seen nothing in the games I have witnessed to think he is a quality goalkeeper. He can't collect crosses, he fails to command his box, the centre backs seem to have little faith in him, his communication at times causes confusion more than anything. He lacks height, strength and seemingly agility too. What the hell is to like about the guy? He seems good at kicking and picking balls outta the net I guess.

I want a goalkeeper who will make a good save now and then, who will also alleviate pressure by claiming crosses or punching balls outta play. But what we get is someone who stays rooted to the line. Right now, I dont see how anyone can suggest Jones is playing well. He simply isn't.

Are other teams not conceding from corners or 25 yard shots. So Jones was now at fault for the Fleetwood corner to despite the weak defending.

Teams do concede goals from 25 yards I reckon even Neuer has been beat from 25 yards or conceded at corners.

No if a team has 3 shots on target and scores 2 it isn't necessarily the keepers fault. That's stupid to blame the keeper solely.

Are we not right to blame the attacking players who get all their chances and obviously aren't scoring them.....!?! Or would that not fit the anti Jones agenda?

We had one of the best defences in the league until we started changing the back 4 around. 2 different left backs, several right backs and numerous centre mid and centre half partnerships. Maybe the lack of communication may stem from these forced and unforced changes. The keeper was still there when we had the good defensive record.

Hey I don't think he is quality in the slightest but having been the keeper in a team who finished the lowest 7th in the past 2 seasons I reckon he is a decent L1 keeper. Rudd was outstanding and I'd have him back in a shot. You bemoan getting beat at the near post.... I have seen world class keepers beat at their near post and Rudd gifted goals at times.

Jones punched and caught crosses on Saturday.
 
Hey I don't think he is quality in the slightest .... Jones punched and caught crosses on Saturday.
Blah blah blah. So he isn't quality? Nice one. Glad we agree. As for punching and collecting crosses I saw him punch one ball on saturday which skimmed off his gloves and landed 6 yards away in the box. Does that count as a punch? As for collecting crosses yes when then are sent straight to his hands he can catch them but if they are 3+ yards away forget about it.
 
Blah blah blah. So he isn't quality? Nice one. Glad we agree. As for punching and collecting crosses I saw him punch one ball on saturday which skimmed off his gloves and landed 6 yards away in the box. Does that count as a punch? As for collecting crosses yes when then are sent straight to his hands he can catch them but if they are 3+ yards away forget about it.

I don't think anyone has said he is quality. I don't believe there is a quality keeper in L1 that's why they all play L1 and not above.

He punched one that relieved immediate pressure and caught crosses regardless. He didn't however catch every cross which if you watch Prem football..... keepers very rarely do.

I've seen 25 yard shots and corners scored even against quality keepers.
 
No Garner got out jumped at the back post.

We were shit.

So if Garner had scored to make it 2-1....?!? What does your crystal ball say about that? Or is Jones to blame for the missed pen aswell?
Do you have trouble deciphering English sentences?

I already said: "Nothing else that happened in that game after the first goal would've happened the same way if we hadn't conceded first, and we didn't look like conceding until Jones had a high long ball to "deal with"."

You're clearly a Jones fanboy intent on repeating himself until he has had the last word, and has therefore "won", and who sees no wrong in a goalkeeper who cannot jump, command his area or save shots unless in easy reach.

However, I'm not interested in repeating myself for the rest of the day until you finally grasp what I'm saying, so I'll bail out here, having said everything I could usefully say to you already.
 
Back
Top