Skip to main content

Jones costing us points

Jones costing us points

Do you have trouble deciphering English sentences?

I already said: "Nothing else that happened in that game after the first goal would've happened the same way if we hadn't conceded first, and we didn't look like conceding until Jones had a high long ball to "deal with"."

You're clearly a Jones fanboy intent on repeating himself until he has had the last word, and has therefore "won", and who sees no wrong in a goalkeeper who cannot jump, command his area or save shots unless in easy reach.

However, I'm not interested in repeating myself for the rest of the day until you finally grasp what I'm saying, so I'll bail out here, having said everything I could usefully say to you already.


I understand what your saying. I just happen to disagree.
 
Yeah, because I'm sure the first thing he does after another disappointing performance is log on here hoping to see us all applauding his efforts.

Let's not get silly.

Sarcasm and irony a bit too difficult for you? Give it a fucking rest. You think Jones is shite and that every point we have lost this season is solely due to him....I understand what you're arguing but I just happen to think that you're talking tosh and that's my prerogative.
 
We had one of the best defences in the league until we started changing the back 4 around. 2 different left backs, several right backs and numerous centre mid and centre half partnerships. Maybe the lack of communication may stem from these forced and unforced changes. The keeper was still there when we had the good defensive record.

We have done quite well against weaker teams in this terrible division, we have yet again failed against sides in and around us where more pressure will be put on our defense, Jones by staying on his line and not comanding his box leaves us horribly exposed at times.

I can see where you might have some substance to your argument when King is in the back 4 as he is just a terrible defender, but too often Jones neither helps nor organises those in front of him, he is very average at best.
 
Last edited:
Jones is a solid league 1 keeper with flaws in his game if he didn't have these flaws then he would be playing in the league above, simple. Some on here are bemoaning his so called mistakes on Saturday, what about the 1 on 1 save from Stead when he "CAME OFF HIS LINE" or a couple of times when he collected the ball from the air.

I try to deflect blame from a Goalkeeper because it is the defences job to make sure he doesn't have anything to do. The defence for the last few games has been very makeshift that could be an explanation to why we have been leaking goals. Thracia talks about the first goal at Rochdale, Jones should have done something with it but what about the 10 other players in the box that let it go past them without actioning it? Why do they get off scot free?

Rudd by all accounts was a class act last season but the mistakes he made were a lot more "clear cut" than Jones, 2 goals against Peterborough and the penalty against Brentford spring to mine. I haven't seen Jones make such blaring mistakes yet.

People ask for Jones to constantly come of his line to gather the crosses and collect but Keepers get blocked off, why do you think teams put a man in front of the keeper like Bradford did at corners? So that they cannot come and collect every ball, otherwise corners would be a useless part of football.

Like Billy says he is very average at best, League 1 is full of very average players at best thats why they are in league 1.
 
Jones is a solid league 1 keeper with flaws in his game if he didn't have these flaws then he would be playing in the league above, simple. Some on here are bemoaning his so called mistakes on Saturday, what about the 1 on 1 save from Stead when he "CAME OFF HIS LINE" or a couple of times when he collected the ball from the air.

I try to deflect blame from a Goalkeeper because it is the defences job to make sure he doesn't have anything to do. The defence for the last few games has been very makeshift that could be an explanation to why we have been leaking goals. Thracia talks about the first goal at Rochdale, Jones should have done something with it but what about the 10 other players in the box that let it go past them without actioning it? Why do they get off scot free?

Rudd by all accounts was a class act last season but the mistakes he made were a lot more "clear cut" than Jones, 2 goals against Peterborough and the penalty against Brentford spring to mine. I haven't seen Jones make such blaring mistakes yet.

People ask for Jones to constantly come of his line to gather the crosses and collect but Keepers get blocked off, why do you think teams put a man in front of the keeper like Bradford did at corners? So that they cannot come and collect every ball, otherwise corners would be a useless part of football.

Like Billy says he is very average at best, League 1 is full of very average players at best thats why they are in league 1.

Totally agree. He is an average L1 keeper who has been regulatory playing for a top team in recent seasons. We were spoilt with Rudd who I pick to one day play for England. I am quite disappointed he didn't stay as had expected him to be playing regularly in the Championship this season.

The 'mistakes' Jones has made are subjective whereas the mistakes Rudd made were black and white.

We aren't solid at the back as we have made a lot of changes across the back four in recent weeks.


Jones, Wiseman, Clarke, Wright and Buchanan with some midfield cover would be as strong a unit in this division
 
Totally agree. He is an average L1 keeper who has been regulatory playing for a top team in recent seasons. We were spoilt with Rudd who I pick to one day play for England. I am quite disappointed he didn't stay as had expected him to be playing regularly in the Championship this season.

The 'mistakes' Jones has made are subjective whereas the mistakes Rudd made were black and white.

We aren't solid at the back as we have made a lot of changes across the back four in recent weeks.


Jones, Wiseman, Clarke, Wright and Buchanan with some midfield cover would be as strong a unit in this division

And proven as we had one of the best defences in the league and that didn't change when 1 player was exchanged because another was injured. But changed 2-3 and the defensive cohesion will not be the same.
 
Sarcasm and irony a bit too difficult for you? Give it a fucking rest. You think Jones is shite and that every point we have lost this season is solely due to him....I understand what you're arguing but I just happen to think that you're talking tosh and that's my prerogative.
It isn't your prerogative to bullshit about me though - I have said no such thing.

And yes, as my posts on here have demonstrated on countless previous occasions, sarcasm and irony are quite beyond me.
 
If you watch the highlights of the corner before the goal and the 1st goal, Jones' starting position is completely wrong - based on just about any Goalkeeping Manual you want to read. He positions himself about 3 yards away from the front post on both occasions instead of the mid point of the goal (or even further back) and therefore cannot attack the ball and claim the cross. Whatever your views on what the defenders should have done these are 2 very basic errors. If you could combine the assetts of both Jones and Stuckmann you would have the best keeper in the division. My concern is that scouts will now be feeding on this flaw in Jones game and we can expect even more crosses into the box. Restoring Stuckmann would more than counter this threat.
 
Does the blame not fall on the defender who was out jumped at the back post? The guy marking the player who scored? We were shit that day so Jones didn't cost us the points. We were out played.

And if Garner had scored the pen to make it 2-1 could you have predicted the out come of the game then?

No it doesnt. Any 40 yard long floated ball that lands in the 6 yard box should be the keepers every time. Whoever is defending should expect that & not be put in a position where he is defending facing his own goal & is not to blame. The blame firmly lies with the keeper
 
And proven as we had one of the best defences in the league and that didn't change when 1 player was exchanged because another was injured. But changed 2-3 and the defensive cohesion will not be the same.
We have won twice with that back four, Won twice when one of them were missing from the starting XI. And won five times when 2 or 3 of those were missing. What does that prove? Fuck all. And is irrelevant to the pleb wandering around in nets.
 
No it doesnt. Any 40 yard long floated ball that lands in the 6 yard box should be the keepers every time. Whoever is defending should expect that & not be put in a position where he is defending facing his own goal & is not to blame. The blame firmly lies with the keeper

Bullshit. No point having defenders marking anyone in the 6 yard box then I guess.
 
He is refering to rochdale when two big punts upfield outfoxed us because Mr Jones is unable to come out and claim a ball. Watch the highlights. He was horrific that day.

I went to the game. I also give some blame to Garner being out jumped and not doing his job and Wiseman not intercepting the ball.
 
He is refering to rochdale when two big punts upfield outfoxed us because Mr Jones is unable to come out and claim a ball. Watch the highlights. He was horrific that day.

I went to the game. I also give some blame to Garner being out jumped and not doing his job and Wiseman not intercepting the ball.
 
How can he claim the third when it wasn't it our six yard box until Wiseman miss-controlled it?
Stop being pedantic. You know exactly what the dude is referring to. Long balls into our box that teh keeper doesnt claim. Its pretty simple to comprehend even for you.
 
Stop being pedantic. You know exactly what the dude is referring to. Long balls into our box that teh keeper doesnt claim. Its pretty simple to comprehend even for you.

Why are you referring to yourself in the third person?

Your talking about two punts up field outfoxing our keeper because he doesn't come and claim them I was simply asking how does he claim a ball that wasn't in our box until Wiseman miss controlled it and Jones had to dive for it.
 
Back
Top