Skip to main content

Jones costing us points

Jones costing us points

So the guy with gloves on who can yunno catch things - he isn't culpable in your mind? We are conceding goals from corners (eg Bradford, Fleetwood, Walsall), we are allowing 60+ yard punts to drop into the box and be tapped in (eg Rochdale twice), we are conceding 25+ yard shots (eg Bradford, Colchester). We are dominating games in terms of shots on target but at the other end failing miserably (eg bradford had three shots on target and got two goals, rochdale had four shots on target and scored three goals). At some point the pedestrian in nets may have to hold his hands up don't ya think?

We should of known as soon as he let that goal in against Notts County what to expect from Jones. Getting beat near post from a tight angle is criminal. And ever since I have seen nothing in the games I have witnessed to think he is a quality goalkeeper. He can't collect crosses, he fails to command his box, the centre backs seem to have little faith in him, his communication at times causes confusion more than anything. He lacks height, strength and seemingly agility too. What the hell is to like about the guy? He seems good at kicking and picking balls outta the net I guess.

I want a goalkeeper who will make a good save now and then, who will also alleviate pressure by claiming crosses or punching balls outta play. But what we get is someone who stays rooted to the line. Right now, I dont see how anyone can suggest Jones is playing well. He simply isn't.

The scary thing is a lot on here think he's doing just fine. I really hope Grayson starts to think otherwise or we are in bother.
 
Jones is a solid league 1 keeper with flaws in his game if he didn't have these flaws then he would be playing in the league above, simple. Some on here are bemoaning his so called mistakes on Saturday, what about the 1 on 1 save from Stead when he "CAME OFF HIS LINE" or a couple of times when he collected the ball from the air.

I try to deflect blame from a Goalkeeper because it is the defences job to make sure he doesn't have anything to do. The defence for the last few games has been very makeshift that could be an explanation to why we have been leaking goals. Thracia talks about the first goal at Rochdale, Jones should have done something with it but what about the 10 other players in the box that let it go past them without actioning it? Why do they get off scot free?

Rudd by all accounts was a class act last season but the mistakes he made were a lot more "clear cut" than Jones, 2 goals against Peterborough and the penalty against Brentford spring to mine. I haven't seen Jones make such blaring mistakes yet.

People ask for Jones to constantly come of his line to gather the crosses and collect but Keepers get blocked off, why do you think teams put a man in front of the keeper like Bradford did at corners? So that they cannot come and collect every ball, otherwise corners would be a useless part of football.

Like Billy says he is very average at best, League 1 is full of very average players at best thats why they are in league 1.

Exactly what i meant when people say they have not seen Jones make glaring mistakes yet. How can he when he's rooted to his line ? Look at the wider picture and defensive frailties,thats where a lot of them stem from.

He's making more mistakes by what he's doing now (nothing) I would take a keeper who commands his area/defence and organises but drops a boob now and again. That comes with the territory.
 
Why are you referring to yourself in the third person?

Your talking about two punts up field outfoxing our keeper because he doesn't come and claim them I was simply asking how does he claim a ball that wasn't in our box until Wiseman miss controlled it and Jones had to dive for it.

I was sat right in line with that and yes Wiseman messed up big time he should have controlled it. Jones though gave himself absolutely no chance to come and anticipate it incase something like that happened. He was on the back foot and to deep as proved when the attacker who was behind Wiseman beat him to the ball fairly off which was just a big long punt by their keeper.
 
I was sat right in line with that and yes Wiseman messed up big time he should have controlled it. Jones though gave himself absolutely no chance to come and anticipate it incase something like that happened. He was on the back foot and to deep as proved when the attacker who was behind Wiseman beat him to the ball fairly off which was just a big long punt by their keeper.

Jones got his hands to the ball though, a ball that is outside the area should be dealt by a defender there is only really one keeper in the world who deals with them otherwise and that is Manuel Neuer. If Wiseman was positioned correctly and wasn't complacent then we wouldn't be having this discussion, is it Jones fault that Wiseman hung him out to dry.

Exactly what i meant when people say they have not seen Jones make glaring mistakes yet. How can he when he's rooted to his line ? Look at the wider picture and defensive frailties,thats where a lot of them stem from.

He's making more mistakes by what he's doing now (nothing) I would take a keeper who commands his area/defence and organises but drops a boob now and again. That comes with the territory.

Like I have said at corners teams block the keepers thats what happened to Jones on Saturday, regardless off where he was his defenders should be winning headers in those areas.

Did he stay on his line when Stead went through 1 on 1?
 
Jones got his hands to the ball though, a ball that is outside the area should be dealt by a defender there is only really one keeper in the world who deals with them otherwise and that is Manuel Neuer. If Wiseman was positioned correctly and wasn't complacent then we wouldn't be having this discussion, is it Jones fault that Wiseman hung him out to dry.



Like I have said at corners teams block the keepers thats what happened to Jones on Saturday, regardless off where he was his defenders should be winning headers in those areas.

Did he stay on his line when Stead went through 1 on 1?

Like i said Wiseman should have more than dealt with it and it was very poor defending oh his part. Im saying though that Jones did not give himself the best opportunity incase of a mistake. His positioning and anticipation were not good. That was my take on it from side on touch line view. Not to blame as much as for the first goal at all though.

If its a case of simply putting a player on a keeper and causing havoc and panic in a six yard box i would ask you two things. Why don't we use these simple tactics off set pieces ? What has Jones got in his locker to combat this for the remainder of the season ?

From what i saw on saturday their keeper did the basics well commanding his six yard box and taking no prisoners. Thus instilling the team with confidence.

As for a one on one chance i wouldn't expect any less of a keeper to come out and narrow the angle. Not sure why he should be given plaudits for doing a routine thing like that. Im on about coming more than 2 yards from his line when a ball is floated into our 6 yard box.
 
Like i said Wiseman should have more than dealt with it and it was very poor defending oh his part. Im saying though that Jones did not give himself the best opportunity incase of a mistake. His positioning and anticipation were not good. That was my take on it from side on touch line view. Not to blame as much as for the first goal at all though.

If its a case of simply putting a player on a keeper and causing havoc and panic in a six yard box i would ask you two things. Why don't we use these simple tactics off set pieces ? What has Jones got in his locker to combat this for the remainder of the season ?

From what i saw on saturday their keeper did the basics well commanding his six yard box and taking no prisoners. Thus instilling the team with confidence.

As for a one on one chance i wouldn't expect any less of a keeper to come out and narrow the angle. Not sure why he should be given plaudits for doing a routine thing like that. Im on about coming more than 2 yards from his line when a ball is floated into our 6 yard box.

Tend to agree with a lot of that, the case I make is he is a League 1 keeper and for failings in some parts of his games he will make up for it in others.

You can't really blame a keeper for not anticipating a fellow team mates mistake, he's not telepathic, Jones probably thought that Wiseman was going to play it back to him therefore staying back near his goal giving him plenty of time to get his kick right, not sell him short.

I think we do use the tactic of putting players on keepers, every team employs that tactic really.

The point you seem to make is that he never comes for crosses he never catches the ball which I think is false, I've seen him do it many times but he isn't going to get to everyone and the first one he doesn't get to the jury's out, Rudd wasn't the best at coming for crosses and claiming the ball.

He shouldn't be given the plaudits for doing routine things, as he shouldn't be blamed for costing us points if he makes the decision to stay on his line and our defence fails in dealing with sometimes simple balls into the box or around his area.
 
In case anyones not noticed we have a Manager and coaching staff....... Maybe a little more of our shortcomings should be apportioned to them and a bit bloody less on the Keeper.
 
No Garner got out jumped at the back post.

We were shit.

So if Garner had scored to make it 2-1....?!? What does your crystal ball say about that? Or is Jones to blame for the missed pen aswell?

We were 3 - 0 down when Garner missed his penalty.

Were you even there cha?
 
All those backing Jones

All those backing Jones

Please tell me what a keeper should be doing,?, as far as i am concerned he should be,
a,] Organizing the defense in front of him, which includes communicating with his defense, and letting them know when he is coming to claim balls, something he v v rarely does. No wonder the defense are at 6's and 7's, he never moves off his bloody line.
b,] Stopping shots, sorry i,ve been on every home game and hardly seen him put in a decent save , i'd be very interested to know his saves per goals ratio, the opposing team seem to get in one or two shots and they invariably score. If we, the fans are doubting him, then i'm sure the defense certainly are.
Whilst i appreciate he isn't as good as Rudd, that still does not excuse him from his main job, keeping the ball out of the net. I would't mind if he was not good at crosses if he put some decent saves in, he does neither.
 
Please tell me what a keeper should be doing,?, as far as i am concerned he should be,
a,] Organizing the defense in front of him, which includes communicating with his defense, and letting them know when he is coming to claim balls, something he v v rarely does. No wonder the defense are at 6's and 7's, he never moves off his bloody line.
b,] Stopping shots, sorry i,ve been on every home game and hardly seen him put in a decent save , i'd be very interested to know his saves per goals ratio, the opposing team seem to get in one or two shots and they invariably score. If we, the fans are doubting him, then i'm sure the defense certainly are.
Whilst i appreciate he isn't as good as Rudd, that still does not excuse him from his main job, keeping the ball out of the net. I would't mind if he was not good at crosses if he put some decent saves in, he does neither.

So is the 'defence' at 6's and 7's or are they doing a good job not letting the opposition have many chances on goal?
 
So is the 'defence' at 6's and 7's or are they doing a good job not letting the opposition have many chances on goal?

Ha ha, what you call one or two shots per game not doing their job ??, you would expect visiting team to have a 'few shots per game', it 's the keepers job to save them. Notts County beaten at near post, Sheff Utd, ball went in less than 2 yards from were he stood, [i know it was deflected, but his reactions are zero, near post at Rochdale, etc. The defense are at 6's and 7's because the keeper isn't doing anything to help them.
 
Ha ha, what you call one or two shots per game not doing their job ??, you would expect visiting team to have a 'few shots per game', it 's the keepers job to save them. Notts County beaten at near post, Sheff Utd, ball went in less than 2 yards from were he stood, [i know it was deflected, but his reactions are zero, near post at Rochdale, etc. The defense are at 6's and 7's because the keeper isn't doing anything to help them.

Or because we haven't had a settled back four and been playing players out of position. Hey these reasons seem to pass you by.
 
Of course its all Jones fault .... despite missed chances , lack of pace and creativity in the middle of the park , lack of a ball winner , lack of a dominant centre back , poor positional sense whilst defending , playing square pegs in round holes etc ...
Of course its all Jones fault , Of course it is !!!!!! 🙄
 
Okay so I don't want to become a statto but the overreaction re Jones is forcing me down this route; so lets compare ourselves in league performance terms to this time last year (which was the 6-0 drubbing of Barnet but as I've said that's been ignored along with the win over Blackpool etc....let's just look a the league)

This time last year;
Played 15
Conceded 16
Clean Sheets 6

This year (first 15)
Conceded 16
Clean Sheets 7

So same goals conceded but one more clean sheet this year!

So okay this year we've played more league games so if I include all current year results compared with the same number of games last year

This year so far;
Played 17
Conceded 19
Clean Sheets 7

Last year (first 17)
Conceded 17
Clean Sheets 7

Now I know you can prove anything what stats etc etc but I don't recall the people on here berating Rudd after either 15 or 17 games whichever way you look at it saying he's not good enough asking him to read a goalkeeper book etc etc. The worst case is after 17 league games the same number of clean sheets and two goals worse!

The agenda with Jones started early and three league defeats in a row has just fueled it. Give the lad a chance ffs given the defence he's had in front of him this year I'd say that's some achievement

Let's get behind the team COYW.
 
Okay so I don't want to become a statto but the overreaction re Jones is forcing me down this route; so lets compare ourselves in league performance terms to this time last year (which was the 6-0 drubbing of Barnet but as I've said that's been ignored along with the win over Blackpool etc....let's just look a the league)

This time last year;
Played 15
Conceded 16
Clean Sheets 6

This year (first 15)
Conceded 16
Clean Sheets 7

So same goals conceded but one more clean sheet this year!

So okay this year we've played more league games so if I include all current year results compared with the same number of games last year

This year so far;
Played 17
Conceded 19
Clean Sheets 7

Last year (first 17)
Conceded 17
Clean Sheets 7

Now I know you can prove anything what stats etc etc but I don't recall the people on here berating Rudd after either 15 or 17 games whichever way you look at it saying he's not good enough asking him to read a goalkeeper book etc etc. The worst case is after 17 league games the same number of clean sheets and two goals worse!

The agenda with Jones started early and three league defeats in a row has just fueled it. Give the lad a chance ffs given the defence he's had in front of him this year I'd say that's some achievement

Let's get behind the team COYW.

Excellently put, the lad has come in for some real stick that has been unnecessary.
 
Back
Top