Skip to main content

Jones costing us points

Jones costing us points

Excellently put, the lad has come in for some real stick that has been unnecessary.

He has and if he reads the stuff on here it's not going help..

Remember he was new to the team at the start of the season...Rudd wasn't this time last year he already new his team mates and had an understanding with them.
 
Okay so I don't want to become a statto but the overreaction re Jones is forcing me down this route; so lets compare ourselves in league performance terms to this time last year (which was the 6-0 drubbing of Barnet but as I've said that's been ignored along with the win over Blackpool etc....let's just look a the league)

This time last year;
Played 15
Conceded 16
Clean Sheets 6

This year (first 15)
Conceded 16
Clean Sheets 7

So same goals conceded but one more clean sheet this year!

So okay this year we've played more league games so if I include all current year results compared with the same number of games last year

This year so far;
Played 17
Conceded 19
Clean Sheets 7

Last year (first 17)
Conceded 17
Clean Sheets 7

Now I know you can prove anything what stats etc etc but I don't recall the people on here berating Rudd after either 15 or 17 games whichever way you look at it saying he's not good enough asking him to read a goalkeeper book etc etc. The worst case is after 17 league games the same number of clean sheets and two goals worse!

The agenda with Jones started early and three league defeats in a row has just fueled it. Give the lad a chance ffs given the defence he's had in front of him this year I'd say that's some achievement

Let's get behind the team COYW.
Like I always bang on, stats don't mean too much.Most people can make a good judgement with their own eyeballs.For me he is way too static on crosses and is not commanding enough.
 
Like I always bang on, stats don't mean too much.Most people can make a good judgement with their own eyeballs.For me he is way too static on crosses and is not commanding enough.

That may be true my complaint is that he's been made a scapegoat when in reality the performances have been comparable with this time last year.

Rudd was a flapper when it came to crosses that's not commanding your area in my book but there wasn't this hysteria this time last year. Peoples expectations have been raised and during the winning run it was very quiet on here now we've lost three who can we blame...

But again just my opinion, but the difference is I'm not going to jump to conclusions so early on because that then just becomes self fulfilling ie getting on the lads back doesn't help when it's not warranted.
 
That may be true my complaint is that he's been made a scapegoat when in reality the performances have been comparable with this time last year.

Rudd was a flapper when it came to crosses that's not commanding your area in my book but there wasn't this hysteria this time last year. Peoples expectations have been raised and during the winning run it was very quiet on here now we've lost three who can we blame...

But again just my opinion, but the difference is I'm not going to jump to conclusions so early on because that then just becomes self fulfilling ie getting on the lads back doesn't help when it's not warranted.

Well said AJ.
 
Thanks Ron

Do you know what got to me the most out of all these posts berating Jones was the one where someone was questioning his positioning at the corner and whether he had read the book on goalkeeping!! Ffs ! So okay if that was said by someone who has played at the highest (or at least a higher) level than Jones then fair enough but call me cynical but I suspect not!!!

I can just imagine the interview process with Jones;

PNE "So Jamie we know you've played at the highest level within league one and endured the playoffs and you know we check references etc etc, but can I just check? You've read the book yeah"

JJ "Read the book?? Good god yeah of course are you mad I live with that book I I mean I almost wrote it so yeah whatever like"

Hope he has a sense of humour ?? As I was just trying to make light of a seriously ridiculous statement and actually that goes for all the the other "Non goalkeeping" coaches on here that know so much better but actually never played at this level.
 
Having watched tonight I've seen international keepers beaten at near posts. Not come for corners or crosses within the 6 yard box and I bet there will be nothing in the press about poor goalkeeping.
 
Thanks Ron

Do you know what got to me the most out of all these posts berating Jones was the one where someone was questioning his positioning at the corner and whether he had read the book on goalkeeping!! Ffs ! So okay if that was said by someone who has played at the highest (or at least a higher) level than Jones then fair enough but call me cynical but I suspect not!!!

I can just imagine the interview process with Jones;

PNE "So Jamie we know you've played at the highest level within league one and endured the playoffs and you know we check references etc etc, but can I just check? You've read the book yeah"

JJ "Read the book?? Good god yeah of course are you mad I live with that book I I mean I almost wrote it so yeah whatever like"

Hope he has a sense of humour ?? As I was just trying to make light of a seriously ridiculous statement and actually that goes for all the the other "Non goalkeeping" coaches on here that know so much better but actually never played at this level.

There is just such a gulf on here between the critical cynics and the realists. Nobody is perfect in football, but if PNE were like some on here expect we would be playing the likes of Real Madrid. Rudd was a very good shop stopper and pulled of the champagne saves, Jones at the moment does not but when you look at the stats does that matter? No. Some on here don't understand football, probably part of the contingent I here shout "forward" at Deepdale all the time when they don't understand how important it can be to keep the ball.

I signed off for a bit last week and the beginning of this one because I came in for what I thought were unjust attacks against my working life because the cynics could not find another way to counter my argument so they resorted to personal attacks.
 
clean sheets and goals conceded count for let's face it... Not a lot.. Have we got to go over this all again..
If you are saying jones is a better keeper than Rudd you need your eyes testing.
Rudd is decent and jones isn't. Rudd mad some massive saves for us last season and made us atleast 7/8/9/10 points. jones hasn't done too much too impress so far.. It's a bit like a team losing a decent striker and replacing him with a mediocre one.. And that's exactly what we have In this case.
 
There is just such a gulf on here between the critical cynics and the realists. Nobody is perfect in football, but if PNE were like some on here expect we would be playing the likes of Real Madrid. Rudd was a very good shop stopper and pulled of the champagne saves, Jones at the moment does not but when you look at the stats does that matter? No. Some on here don't understand football, probably part of the contingent I here shout "forward" at Deepdale all the time when they don't understand how important it can be to keep the ball.

I signed off for a bit last week and the beginning of this one because I came in for what I thought were unjust attacks against my working life because the cynics could not find another way to counter my argument so they resorted to personal attacks.

Ron I think you have some valued arguments and don't think I've disagreed with you on anything you've posted so far so don't let the bastards grind you down.

But this is a discussion board and as long as it's a healthy debate and not too personal then let's carry on the debate. Truth wins ultimately whether that's mine, yours or someone else's we'll know in May!! I think (hope) we all want the same thing.

You and me WILL keep the faith I'm sure or chastise the bollocks of them if they need it but we're 3rd in the league so why panic early days........

Keep posting mate

COYW
 
There is just such a gulf on here between the critical cynics and the realists. Nobody is perfect in football, but if PNE were like some on here expect we would be playing the likes of Real Madrid. Rudd was a very good shop stopper and pulled of the champagne saves, Jones at the moment does not but when you look at the stats does that matter? No. Some on here don't understand football, probably part of the contingent I here shout "forward" at Deepdale all the time when they don't understand how important it can be to keep the ball.

I signed off for a bit last week and the beginning of this one because I came in for what I thought were unjust attacks against my working life because the cynics could not find another way to counter my argument so they resorted to personal attacks.

says it all
 
clean sheets and goals conceded count for let's face it... Not a lot.. Have we got to go over this all again..
If you are saying jones is a better keeper than Rudd you need your eyes testing.
Rudd is decent and jones isn't. Rudd mad some massive saves for us last season and made us atleast 7/8/9/10 points. jones hasn't done too much too impress so far.. It's a bit like a team losing a decent striker and replacing him with a mediocre one.. And that's exactly what we have In this case.

I think you're missing the point which is the facts!! The league is weaker and we're 3rd as a result because the our defence & strike force has held up whilst others haven't.

Have we improved more than others ? No.. but we haven't fallen back either! We are more than capable in this league. Some would have you believe we should walk it and win every game but then there are some of us in the reality zone.

Where are you?
 
Having watched tonight I've seen international keepers beaten at near posts. Not come for corners or crosses within the 6 yard box and I bet there will be nothing in the press about poor goalkeeping.

Of course not.

The problem is a simple one (however I'll elaborate thoroughly)

Rudd was a good goalkeeper for us in a team that moved up from lower midtable strugglers to promotion contenders.

Jones has been signed as a like for like replacement. He has made a sideways move in the process, which by comparison (Rudd returning to his Championship parent club.) Gifts the opinion of 'inferiority' to the masses.

Judgments were made (this I stress was embarrassingly clear) before Jones had even kicked a ball.

I have no reason to champion Jones, I've just kept a watchful eye over his performances.

And, I can quite honestly and confidently say I've been impressed. He has handled all the unnecessary pressure professionally.

He rarely makes mistakes and goes about his job in a consistent manner.

There will be parts of his game that are scrutinised by sections of our following. That is something Jones is going to find hard to shake. They've found a scapegoat, they've been eagerly waiting for him to slip up and add weight to their claims. Despite solid performances, clean sheets and a complete lack of blatent errors - these 'fans' are pointing to absolutely anything. Sad.

As a Defender myself, I would never expect my 'keeper to bail us out of trouble. He is the last line of defense and should only be expected to be called into action when necessary or if the odds favour him.

What I have read on these pages is nothing short of a witch hunt. I'd personally blame the tactical meltdown, of which all performances are fundamentally based. As well as the underperforming King & Clarke - they did make 'actual costly' mistakes.
 
Of course not.

The problem is a simple one (however I'll elaborate thoroughly)

Rudd was a good goalkeeper for us in a team that moved up from lower midtable strugglers to promotion contenders.

Jones has been signed as a like for like replacement. He has made a sideways move in the process, which by comparison (Rudd returning to his Championship parent club.) Gifts the opinion of 'inferiority' to the masses.

Judgments were made (this I stress was embarrassingly clear) before Jones had even kicked a ball.

I have no reason to champion Jones, I've just kept a watchful eye over his performances.

And, I can quite honestly and confidently say I've been impressed. He has handled all the unnecessary pressure professionally.

He rarely makes mistakes and goes about his job in a consistent manner.

There will be parts of his game that are scrutinised by sections of our following. That is something Jones is going to find hard to shake. They've found a scapegoat, they've been eagerly waiting for him to slip up and add weight to their claims. Despite solid performances, clean sheets and a complete lack of blatent errors - these 'fans' are pointing to absolutely anything. Sad.

As a Defender myself, I would never expect my 'keeper to bail us out of trouble. He is the last line of defense and should only be expected to be called into action when necessary or if the odds favour him.

What I have read on these pages is nothing short of a witch hunt. I'd personally blame the tactical meltdown, of which all performances are fundamentally based. As well as the underperforming King & Clarke - they did make 'actual costly' mistakes.

Well said, nobody has highlighted the lack of form from Clarke and King both have been poor compared to last season, Clarke has not been his brilliant best and lets hope he isn't a one season wonder. King is suffering from confidence and really only plays well in a back 3 when he always has an outlet when his long balls down field are not available.

We haven't had a steady back 4 for a couple of games now, due to injuries, international call ups and loss of form that has to have some detrimental effect on the defensive cohesion.

What do you mean by that?

He basically has nothing to say back to my opinion therefore using CHILDISH tactics he picks out an autocorrect mistake by my computer, pathetic.

says it all

Like I have said above, pathetic.
 
It's not a witch hunt against Jones, from the first game against Notts County he cost us a goal beaten at the near post, since then he has looked vulnerable at crosses does not command his area, does not seem to communicate with his defenders. Yes defenders are to blame as well for some goals and have been left out of the side((dropped). Jones has not just rested for the odd game. The time has come for Stuckman to be given a chance if he doesn't perform then at least one keeper needs to go and another one brought in. We have let a lot of players go in the last couple of years either frees or out on loan who are not good enough ,why should the goalkeeper be any different it's such an important position we must get it right .
 
It's not a witch hunt against Jones, from the first game against Notts County he cost us a goal beaten at the near post, since then he has looked vulnerable at crosses does not command his area, does not seem to communicate with his defenders. Yes defenders are to blame as well for some goals and have been left out of the side((dropped). Jones has not just rested for the odd game. The time has come for Stuckman to be given a chance if he doesn't perform then at least one keeper needs to go and another one brought in. We have let a lot of players go in the last couple of years either frees or out on loan who are not good enough ,why should the goalkeeper be any different it's such an important position we must get it right .

So the goal at Notts County didn't come down to Bailey Wright letting his man turn in the box and shoot because everyone fell asleep at the quick throw in? Don't get me wrong I would expect Jones to save it but to put the blame solely at his door is wrong, something people on here seem to do.

Your talking about dropping keepers and then if the other one doesn't work bringing another one in what happens if that keeper makes a mistake, which Goalkeepers tend to do from time to time, Rudd did it 4-5 times last season.

The stats point to that Jones has been getting it right because he has the same number of clean sheets at this time last season as Rudd did, he has also pulled off some good saves in his time with PNE. Remember we are 3rd in the league and Jones has been part of our points accumulation because he has played every league game.

The 3 things you mentioned that he is poor at I disagree with, at times he can be like that but others times he does those things quite well but is never praised for it, the second he isn't perfect in his goalkeeping the cynics are out.
 
Our defenders are weak at defending corners and crosses, particularly King and Clarke. Wright is no better due to his lack of height.

Hopefully King will not be called upon to play in central defence again and hopefully Clarke will get back to last season's form.
 
I did say defenders are at fault as well and yes Baily Wright ,was at fault as well but he is one that has been dropped this season , Jones has been at least partly to blame for quite a few more goals than that one but seems undropable.
 
I did say defenders are at fault as well and yes Baily Wright ,was at fault as well but he is one that has been dropped this season , Jones has been at least partly to blame for quite a few more goals than that one but seems undropable.
I think you're right lenny, but you're probably wasting your time here - if we put Deepdale Duck in nets, some people would still be blaming the defence and insisting the keeper's job is basically just to take goal kicks. 😉
 
Back
Top