Skip to main content

Jones costing us points

Jones costing us points

I did say defenders are at fault as well and yes Baily Wright ,was at fault as well but he is one that has been dropped this season , Jones has been at least partly to blame for quite a few more goals than that one but seems undropable.

Bailey Wright wasn't dropped he has been carrying an injury since the summer and was sent for an operation.

I think you're right lenny, but you're probably wasting your time here - if we put Deepdale Duck in nets, some people would still be blaming the defence and insisting the keeper's job is basically just to take goal kicks. 😉

Not advocating that at all, just simply saying I think Jones has come in for undue criticism when the other players haven't been up to scratch, don't get me wrong he hasn't covered himself in glory like Rudd seemed to have last season but he definitely isn't at fault for every goal we have conceded this season.
 
Not advocating that at all, just simply saying I think Jones has come in for undue criticism when the other players haven't been up to scratch, don't get me wrong he hasn't covered himself in glory like Rudd seemed to have last season but he definitely isn't at fault for every goal we have conceded this season.
Nobody has said he's to blame for every goal.

Is he to blame for any goal?
 
Reading between the lines of Grayson's statements - there's shock horror too many games with the recovery days they have to have and there isn't enough time to show people DVDs and / or having them practicing defending free kicks / corners etc …I can buy what people have been saying about other teams obviously sussing Preston out , it happened last season too …needs dealing with …just a few thoughts , I'll put my crash helmet on !
 
Really??

Just off the top of my head I'd say he was at fault for Doncasters equaliser and Rochdales first goal.

Doncaster goal - Ball should have never come into the box because the whole defence switched off because they thought it was our throw in, too many were busy arguing instead of facing the ball. Jones could have done better but the goal was not just his fault.

Rochdale goal - Who allowed there player to have a free header at the back post? Jones should have not let it go through his legs but if the ball in is dealt with by the player (Garner) marking the man at the back post then the goalkeeper has nothing to do.
 
No of course not. I just don't agree that Jones is the calamity that you seem to believe he is. We're going to have to agree to disagree on this one!
I haven't called him a calamity - I find him unconvincing, and all I've tried to say on this thread is, if he's capable of MoM performances (as his fans claim he is), then let's see more of them, and let's see less of the mediocre performances that have arguably cost us points.

I think that's a reasonable position to take.

Whereas I think the suggestion that Jones hasn't been culpable for any goal conceded this season is just laughable.
 
I haven't called him a calamity - I find him unconvincing, and all I've tried to say on this thread is, if he's capable of MoM performances (as his fans claim he is), then let's see more of them, and let's see less of the mediocre performances that have arguably cost us points.

I think that's a reasonable position to take.

Whereas I think the suggestion that Jones hasn't been culpable for any goal conceded this season is just laughable.

He has definitely been culpable but on fewer occasions, I would suggest, than Clarke and King.
 
Ron blames the defenders for not doing their job and loves to quote prem teams and their players even other countries teams to support his points (eh we are in the 3rd division), well why bother with keepers then if every goal should be avoided by great defending, surely a keeper is there to "keep" the ball out of the net irrespective of other players, Jones is not that great at doing this simple task (oh and he is always going to be short).
 
This could be a contender for one of the most boring threads in PNE Online history, which is some achievement.

The same people have been arguing the same points for 4 days.
 
Ron blames the defenders for not doing their job and loves to quote prem teams and their players even other countries teams to support his points (eh we are in the 3rd division), well why bother with keepers then if every goal should be avoided by great defending, surely a keeper is there to "keep" the ball out of the net irrespective of other players, Jones is not that great at doing this simple task (oh and he is always going to be short).

I quote the other teams higher up in the leagues to show you Billy that no team and no player is perfect even when they are playing at the top end of football, it seems you won't rest with your agendas until we are perfect.

The goalkeeper is there to keep the ball out of the net but sometimes there is nothing he can do when his defenders haven't done their jobs. Yeates goal as an example on Saturday, he should have been closed down quicker by King or another PNE player or would you have expected Jones to save that shot?

Jones statistically has been on par with Rudd in keeping the ball out of the net, but Rudd didn't come in for this much criticism.
 
I quote the other teams higher up in the leagues to show you Billy that no team and no player is perfect even when they are playing at the top end of football, it seems you won't rest with your agendas until we are perfect.

The goalkeeper is there to keep the ball out of the net but sometimes there is nothing he can do when his defenders haven't done their jobs. Yeates goal as an example on Saturday, he should have been closed down quicker by King or another PNE player or would you have expected Jones to save that shot?

Jones statistically has been on par with Rudd in keeping the ball out of the net, but Rudd didn't come in for this much criticism.

there's none so blind as those who cannot see!!!!!!!!

does Jones help his defenders, take some pressure off them, organise them, talk to them or just keep on blaming them much like you do Ron?
 
This could be a contender for one of the most boring threads in PNE Online history, which is some achievement.

The same people have been arguing the same points for 4 days.

Some people certainly like the sound of their own arguments. My old Gran used to say that the persistence of such people is usually in inverse proportion to the size of their member. Judging by her worn out expression, she probably knew this only too well.
 
Doncaster goal - Ball should have never come into the box because the whole defence switched off because they thought it was our throw in, too many were busy arguing instead of facing the ball. Jones could have done better but the goal was not just his fault.

Rochdale goal - Who allowed there player to have a free header at the back post? Jones should have not let it go through his legs but if the ball in is dealt with by the player (Garner) marking the man at the back post then the goalkeeper has nothing to do.

So, surprise, surprise, defending is a team effort and there's been occasions this year where we've defended poorly as a team.

Jones is part of that and shares in credit and criticism (at least on these two occasions). Blindly slagging off individuals makes no sense but, at the same time, they aren't absolved of blame just because someone else fucked up. If there's a job to be done then players should be capable of doing it.
 
Back
Top