Skip to main content

Jones costing us points

Jones costing us points

Part of a team which is 3rd in the league so far this year and 2 seasons in a team in the top 8 says different.

Has the same amount of clean sheets as Rudd did at this time last season, conceded 2 more, think Rudd had a more settled back 4 as well.

Jones only played 28 league games for Orient last season and 26 the season before letting in just more than 1 a game, so hardly and ever present Ron.
 
Part of a team which is 3rd in the league so far this year and 2 seasons in a team in the top 8 says different.

Has the same amount of clean sheets as Rudd did at this time last season, conceded 2 more, think Rudd had a more settled back 4 as well.

He cost us points at Rochdale and at Doncaster.

I deal in reality, not stats Ron - you should try it and maybe you wouldn't continually make yourself look like a buffoon on here.
 
He's garbage Ron - anyone with a footballing brain can see that.

Ok so if we need to agree (not sure we do) but then it's on these terms he's as crap as Rudd but with a worst defense in front of him!

I'd accept that if you'd have been slating the messiah this time last year but fuck me no you weren't because you had others to slate...

And then you get the Stuckmann needs to start bollocks.... jesus I can't even begin where to start with that one!!

As someone has already stated this thread is boring beyond now 4 days in so I'm going to try and simplify and end it...

Is Jones the best keeper in league one - No
Does he make mistakes - Yes - they all do
Has he cost us points - probably yes
Has he cost us points more so than Rudd - Evidently not
Has he cost us points more than any other top 6 six keepers - don't get me doing the stats because I will but I'd suggest not we're third ffs
Has there been a witch hunt on here since he signed - I'm trying not to swear
Has that witch hunt been warranted - Definitely not given the stats
Is he short - If you're over 6-4 then I'll accept yes if not you're an idiot (sorry that was personal and unwarranted)

The top and bottom of it is that along with the majority on here and the management at PNE Jones is the number one keeper and if you think differently then unfortunately (and this may hurt some!) Stuckmann needs to go!

I'm not advocating that because I think he's a more than a decent reserve probably more so than any other club has in this division but he's not the first choice!
 
He was injured Mid season 2013-4 and Orient had a loan keeper in whilst he was out.

so Orients final position was not solely a reflection of his performances for them!!!!!! what about the previous season with even fewer league games, injured again, sicknote perhaps???
 
Ok so if we need to agree (not sure we do) but then it's on these terms he's as crap as Rudd but with a worst defense in front of him!

I'd accept that if you'd have been slating the messiah this time last year but fuck me no you weren't because you had others to slate...

And then you get the Stuckmann needs to start bollocks.... jesus I can't even begin where to start with that one!!

As someone has already stated this thread is boring beyond now 4 days in so I'm going to try and simplify and end it...

Is Jones the best keeper in league one - No
Does he make mistakes - Yes - they all do
Has he cost us points - probably yes
Has he cost us points more so than Rudd - Evidently not
Has he cost us points more than any other top 6 six keepers - don't get me doing the stats because I will but I'd suggest not we're third ffs
Has there been a witch hunt on here since he signed - I'm trying not to swear
Has that witch hunt been warranted - Definitely not given the stats
Is he short - If you're over 6-4 then I'll accept yes if not you're an idiot (sorry that was personal and unwarranted)

The top and bottom of it is that along with the majority on here and the management at PNE Jones is the number one keeper and if you think differently then unfortunately (and this may hurt some!) Stuckmann needs to go!

I'm not advocating that because I think he's a more than a decent reserve probably more so than any other club has in this division but he's not the first choice!

Have you some stats to back this up?
 
Ok so if we need to agree (not sure we do) but then it's on these terms he's as crap as Rudd but with a worst defense in front of him!

I'd accept that if you'd have been slating the messiah this time last year but fuck me no you weren't because you had others to slate...

And then you get the Stuckmann needs to start bollocks.... jesus I can't even begin where to start with that one!!

As someone has already stated this thread is boring beyond now 4 days in so I'm going to try and simplify and end it...

Is Jones the best keeper in league one - No
Does he make mistakes - Yes - they all do
Has he cost us points - probably yes
Has he cost us points more so than Rudd - Evidently not
Has he cost us points more than any other top 6 six keepers - don't get me doing the stats because I will but I'd suggest not we're third ffs
Has there been a witch hunt on here since he signed - I'm trying not to swear
Has that witch hunt been warranted - Definitely not given the stats
Is he short - If you're over 6-4 then I'll accept yes if not you're an idiot (sorry that was personal and unwarranted)

The top and bottom of it is that along with the majority on here and the management at PNE Jones is the number one keeper and if you think differently then unfortunately (and this may hurt some!) Stuckmann needs to go!

I'm not advocating that because I think he's a more than a decent reserve probably more so than any other club has in this division but he's not the first choice!

I think you will find that of you are not one of Grayson's signings/fav's then that limits your chances at PNE so Stuckmann has little or no chance here now.
 
isn't that a keepers job?????

Ye so wheres the praise? If your going to slate him for not doing his job then praise him for when he does it, or just recognise that more times than not he gets it right.

He cost us points at Rochdale and at Doncaster.

I deal in reality, not stats Ron - you should try it and maybe you wouldn't continually make yourself look like a buffoon on here.

He didn't cost us points at either of those games or did you not go? They were not directly attributed to him as I have explained, all goals could have easily been prevented by our 4 defenders being a lot lot better. At Doncaster Jones didn't cover himself in glory but if our players hadn't wasted their time arguing with the referee and had actually faced play and prevented the ball going into the box or headed it away we wouldn't be having this conversation.

Rochdale 1st - Garner bad defending.

Rochdale 2nd - Simple tap in because nobody defended down the left hand side.

Rochdale 3rd - how good do you think Wisemans back pass was?

Jones only played 28 league games for Orient last season and 26 the season before letting in just more than 1 a game, so hardly and ever present Ron.

Did I say ever present?
 
Just providing some balance to your rather one eyed view.....in your world he's damned if he concedes but isn't praised when he makes first rate saves. Hardly fair but that wouldn't fit your agenda would it?

at Orient he made a fantastic double save and another one on one great save, he also flapped and missed at a cross into the box second half that nearly let them back in, he is just not good enough.
 
He didn't cost us points at either of those games or did you not go? They were not directly attributed to him as I have explained, all goals could have easily been prevented by our 4 defenders being a lot lot better. At Doncaster Jones didn't cover himself in glory but if our players hadn't wasted their time arguing with the referee and had actually faced play and prevented the ball going into the box or headed it away we wouldn't be having this conversation.

Rochdale 1st - Garner bad defending.

You're cluesless Ron, you really are.
 
Back
Top