Skip to main content

Jones costing us points

Jones costing us points

He looks like he's been having a good run of form of late?

Always liked Lonners even with the deficiencies in his game.

There was a spell before his injury when it looked like he`d go far.

I don`t really know why it seemed to affect him so much, as a goalie. Guess a lot of it is in the head.
 
Thought Lonergan was and still is a good keeper. Played a massive part in us getting to the play offs under Irvine.
 
Lonergan is a great shot stopper but a fucking shit keeper.

Delighted when we finally got rid of him.
 
Lonergan is a great shot stopper but a fucking shit keeper.

Delighted when we finally got rid of him.

Not sure how he could be shit if he was a great shot stopper? I understand there's other parts to a keepers game but surely that's their primary job, to stop shots!?
 
Not sure how he could be shit if he was a great shot stopper? I understand there's other parts to a keepers game but surely that's their primary job, to stop shots!?

Great reaction stopper, good at one & ones. Shit at everything else.

He's terrified of leaving his 6 yard box which means he regularly finds himself with a striker bearing down on him because he hasn't dealt with the situation earlier. Similar to when Jamie Carragher used to get skinned every game and had to pull out a Hollywood tackle.

His footwork is also terrible which is why he struggles to deal with long-range efforts.

His "wonder saves" con people into thinking he's far better than he is.
 
He looks like he's been having a good run of form of late?

Always liked Lonners even with the deficiencies in his game.

You whinge about Jones then say you liked one of the worst keepers we've had in years.

Lonergan was garbage for us.

Glued to his line, poor decision making and was beaten regularly from distance.

Even his team mates called him flapper.
 
Lonergan has his faults (or he'd be the England keeper) - but some people do bleat on. Maybe the penny will drop one day, that year after year after year, this "garbageness" is apparently overlooked by the professionals. Despite missing a couple of years through injury, he's made 320 League and Cup appearances... mainly at mid-championship level.

In my opinion, there have been times when he's been in the top 10 English Keepers.

I think you'd have to be pretty biased to think he's not been in the top 20 for much of his career. If you hypothesise that a consistently-selected mid-Championship keeper would typically be 3rd choice at Prem clubs, and 2nd choice at top-half Championship clubs, that would make him about 50th best keeper in the country... and so probably top 20 English keeper. That's an attempt to be objective... and I think quite a conservative view.
 
I only remember Lonners for his terrible performances in our relegation season (my memory is shit so I can't remember when he was actually decent). Jesus wept he was bad that season. Every time the opposition had a long range shot you thought it was going to go in.
 
I only remember Lonners for his terrible performances in our relegation season (my memory is shit so I can't remember when he was actually decent). Jesus wept he was bad that season. Every time the opposition had a long range shot you thought it was going to go in.

Can't disagree with that!

He desperately needed dropping, to get out of the firing line. But we had no back up. His confidence was totally shot, and it went from bad to worse.
 
Stuckie I think has now kept 4 clean sheets in his 6games that he has played in this season?


We've had quite a few this season with respect , i think the real truth is Stucks commands his area better and is a big uncompromising lump of a guy .
 
Aye, and he wasn't exactly helped out by the defence in fairness. Calamitous.

The word was that Everton rated Lonners but his confidence was shot at - that lack of confidence worked it's way to centre halves like Craig Morgan as obviously opposition forwards , attacking midfielders and wingers were having a field day and the law of averages meant that Lonners would have to pick the ball out of the net and his teammates having to kick off again a lot more than once a game ! .

If I remember rightly Ridsdale was non too impressed with Sunbed Phil not having a proper specialist left back when questioned on Radio Lancashire .

I can also remember Ollie lending Sheffield United a winger and a forward to get them ready and they had a field day , everything concentrated down one flank. It seemed obvious that opposition managers had told their players to target Clark Carlisle , there were orders to turn him towards his own goal to force errors and go down the side of him .

The only time I saw it improve was against Southend in the FA Cup - Ian Ashbee did the mopping up in front of the centre halves who appeared to be under orders to clear their lines and keep it simple or again just give it to Ashbee who'd start a move going . However it didn't go down too well having an old injury prone player on high wages who spent most of his time in the stand .

Westley did improve things to a point - lots of 0-0 draws and boring regimented football though , and signed some players that we have still got which were of use . Maybe a lot of it boils down to Darren Ferguson as you can't impose a style of football without the pacey players that can carry it off . A catalogue of errors - PNE deserved to be relegated , it was always on the cards ??
 
A catalogue of errors - PNE deserved to be relegated , it was always on the cards ??

Losing 4 of your first 11 because they were recalled out of spite never helps either.

Agreed though, we made some shocking signings and Ferguson & Brown were out of their depth, trying to patch it up with about a dozen loan players.

That season out of the players we used, I think we probably would have stayed up with a team of;

Turner
Jones, Cort, Khumalo, Gardner
Treacy, Tonge, Coutts, Pugh
Parkin, Hume

If we had them all at the same time, losing Ricardo Gardner was a big blow.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Losing 4 of your first 11 because they were recalled out of spite never helps either.

Agreed though, we made some shocking signings and Ferguson & Brown were out of their depth, trying to patch it up with about a dozen loan players.

That season out of the players we used, I think we probably would have stayed up with a team of;

Turner
Jones, Cort, Khumalo, Gardner
Treacy, Tonge, Coutts, Pugh
Parkin, Hume

If we had them all at the same time, losing Ricardo Gardner was a big blow.

We lost 6 players that day. Three recalled by Man U, two by Stoke, and Parkin sold to Cardiff.
 
The word was that Everton rated Lonners but his confidence was shot at - that lack of confidence worked it's way to centre halves like Craig Morgan as obviously opposition forwards , attacking midfielders and wingers were having a field day and the law of averages meant that Lonners would have to pick the ball out of the net and his teammates having to kick off again a lot more than once a game ! .

If I remember rightly Ridsdale was non too impressed with Sunbed Phil not having a proper specialist left back when questioned on Radio Lancashire .

I can also remember Ollie lending Sheffield United a winger and a forward to get them ready and they had a field day , everything concentrated down one flank. It seemed obvious that opposition managers had told their players to target Clark Carlisle , there were orders to turn him towards his own goal to force errors and go down the side of him .

The only time I saw it improve was against Southend in the FA Cup - Ian Ashbee did the mopping up in front of the centre halves who appeared to be under orders to clear their lines and keep it simple or again just give it to Ashbee who'd start a move going . However it didn't go down too well having an old injury prone player on high wages who spent most of his time in the stand .

Westley did improve things to a point - lots of 0-0 draws and boring regimented football though , and signed some players that we have still got which were of use . Maybe a lot of it boils down to Darren Ferguson as you can't impose a style of football without the pacey players that can carry it off . A catalogue of errors - PNE deserved to be relegated , it was always on the cards ??

Sums it up well. Fergie Jr. was frankly clueless, whilst the recalling of the loanees after his sacking monumentally dicked us over. Signing a shed full of loanees is not prudent though, and it came back to bite us on the arse spectacularly.
 
Back
Top