Skip to main content

Just Got Back - Quick Report

Just Got Back - Quick Report

jcfartpants

Chief Anal Acoustician
Joined
Feb 6, 2013
Messages
19,527
Location
Rutland
Only live 15 miles away, not driven at warp factor back to Preston.

Summary of game -

Pre-match drinks - bloody good, should have had more.

1st half (3-4-1-2) - battered with not really a look in. Rudd to blame partly for 1st goal in that he could have palmed it away rather than back into the path of the striker. 2nd goal Rudd mistake, stopped the shot but it slipped through his hands into the goal. That said, he stopped 2 or 3 shots very well so it could have been worse.

2nd half (Wroe and Welsh into midfield with Hume and Byrom off) - much better, lots of shots on but mainly from distance. Humphrey and Laird had lots of the ball on either wing, but neither had the beating of his man, nor looked confident to take on. BW had a stonking volley from edge of area which hit underside. Had that gone in then we could have gone on to get the draw. They didn't look like scoring (apart from disallowed goal).

PNE fans - amazing, very vocal and positive at the end.

UTW!!!!!!!
 
Only live 15 miles away, not driven at warp factor back to Preston.

Summary of game -

Pre-match drinks - bloody good, should have had more.

1st half (3-4-1-2) - battered with not really a look in. Rudd to blame partly for 1st goal in that he could have palmed it away rather than back into the path of the striker. 2nd goal Rudd mistake, stopped the shot but it slipped through his hands into the goal. That said, he stopped 2 or 3 shots very well so it could have been worse.

2nd half (Wroe and Welsh into midfield with Hume and Byrom off) - much better, lots of shots on but mainly from distance. Humphrey and Laird had lots of the ball on either wing, but neither had the beating of his man, nor looked confident to take on. BW had a stonking volley from edge of area which hit underside. Had that gone in then we could have gone on to get the draw. They didn't look like scoring (apart from disallowed goal).

PNE fans - amazing, very vocal and positive at the end.

UTW!!!!!!!

Cheers for report mate. Similar to what was portrayed by Surf and the commentator. Sounds like another great turn out by the fans.
 
Only live 15 miles away, not driven at warp factor back to Preston.

Summary of game -

Pre-match drinks - bloody good, should have had more.

1st half (3-4-1-2) - battered with not really a look in. Rudd to blame partly for 1st goal in that he could have palmed it away rather than back into the path of the striker. 2nd goal Rudd mistake, stopped the shot but it slipped through his hands into the goal. That said, he stopped 2 or 3 shots very well so it could have been worse.

2nd half (Wroe and Welsh into midfield with Hume and Byrom off) - much better, lots of shots on but mainly from distance. Humphrey and Laird had lots of the ball on either wing, but neither had the beating of his man, nor looked confident to take on. BW had a stonking volley from edge of area which hit underside. Had that gone in then we could have gone on to get the draw. They didn't look like scoring (apart from disallowed goal).

PNE fans - amazing, very vocal and positive at the end.

UTW!!!!!!!

Where do you live?
 
Only live 15 miles away, not driven at warp factor back to Preston.

Summary of game -

Pre-match drinks - bloody good, should have had more.

1st half (3-4-1-2) - battered with not really a look in. Rudd to blame partly for 1st goal in that he could have palmed it away rather than back into the path of the striker. 2nd goal Rudd mistake, stopped the shot but it slipped through his hands into the goal. That said, he stopped 2 or 3 shots very well so it could have been worse.

2nd half (Wroe and Welsh into midfield with Hume and Byrom off) - much better, lots of shots on but mainly from distance. Humphrey and Laird had lots of the ball on either wing, but neither had the beating of his man, nor looked confident to take on. BW had a stonking volley from edge of area which hit underside. Had that gone in then we could have gone on to get the draw. They didn't look like scoring (apart from disallowed goal).

PNE fans - amazing, very vocal and positive at the end.

UTW!!!!!!!

Only just back also, staying not too far away myself. I'd agree with the above mostly. SG's tactics were simply wrong in the first half, and the team was opened up far too easily by the expansive game that Peterborough were simply allowed to play: we were far too cramped in the centre and they were allowed to ping long diagonal, or cross-field passes at will. P'boro have some excellent attacking players, but North End's defence was easily beaten for speed too often.
Make no mistake about it, Rudd made two howlers, watch them later; the second one more comical than the first (where he was too slow himself to get up and parry the second shot). The scorer should not have been allowed the space to shoot anyway. The second clanger resulted from a simple strike straight at him....and straight through his fingers. He did make several classy saves afterwards though.

Second half North End showed their mettle, with P'boro on the back foot most of the time (they still managed a good shot into the net, ruled out for offside of course). PNE had two efforts hitting the woodwork thanks to a more offensive outlook. Needless to say though, this approach only resulted from being 2-0 down, and may not otherwise have happened, if they had gone in at half time only 1-0 nil down. For me think Hume was not the answer today to the questions P'boro raised. BBC Cambridgeshire had Rudd as Peterborough's "MOM". Ouch...
 
It was a difficult one for Grayson today. He was probably thinking about a different system for this match but difficult to change a side that has won 5 straight.

It was completely wrong to line up like we did though. This was not a match for Byrom and we were completely overrun from the off.

The biggest danger for me though is that he is now tempted to revert to a more negative line up. Crewe up at home next and I feel the starting line up today will destroy them.

My only real nagging doubt is Hume. I really think he is past it.
 
Just Got Back - Quick Report

Just got in myself.

First half was largely as described by the other posters - very much men against boys. Peterborough were quick, full of energy and looked a team full of very good footballers. Scary to think they had 1 or two players out. Dare I say it but Ferguson tactically outclassed Grayson as we were completely overran in midfield with Byrom and Keane anonymous throughout resulting in us humping 60 yard balls up to the isolated Davies and Beavon time and again. Apart from a very good chance early on we did nothing whilst Rudd, despite his two clangers, made some good saves to restrict the damage.

Where my report differs is that I was not as impressed as other posters about our second half performance. Yes we were better but that really was not difficult. I would also argue that Peterborough didn't bother second half but rather content with the two goal lead. Although we hit the bar twice our general play was still poor and never really looked like turning round the deficit. That said, I thought the three subs had positive effects on the team which is something I don't think we have had the luxury of in the past few years. All 3 should be pushing for starts next time out.

Big wake up call I think. Peterborough looked a level or two up from us and will be top two come the end of the season in my opinion. Hope it's just a blip but there were some really worrying signs out there for me. The only real positives were Bailey Wright and Tom Clarke who I thought had decent games.

Special mention for a piss poor ref and one of the worst football grounds/atmospheres I've witnessed. Oh, and £28 for a ticket!!

Ratings -

Rudd - 5 (uncharacteristic errors)
Clarke - 7 (didn't really put a foot wrong at the back)
Huntington - 6 (his starting position/reading of the game worries me)
Wright - 8 (MOM)
Laird - 6 (solid enough at the back, didn't have his best game going forward)
Humphrey - 4 (did well to look awful in a very poor team performance)
Byrom - 4 (did well to look awful in a very poor team performance)
Keane - 5 (I'm a fan but looked out of his depth against the Peterborough midfield today)
Hume - 4 (must have touched the ball 5 times in the first half)
Beavon - 5 (no service)
Davies - 5 (no service)

Subs

Welsh - 7 (positive effect on the game - took better control of midfield)
Wroe - 7 (tried his best to create)
Garner - 7 (very lively)


I know this wont be a popular report but just my opinion on proceedings.
 
Last edited:
Interesting what you said about Clarke as he got absolutely slated on the radio by surf for his first half performance
 
Just got in myself.

First half was largely as described by the other posters - very much men against boys. Peterborough were quick, full of energy and looked a team full of very good footballers. Scary to think they had 1 or two players out. Dare I say it but Ferguson tactically outclassed Grayson as we were completely overran in midfield with Byrom and Keane anonymous throughout resulting in us humping 60 yard balls up to the isolated Davies and Beavon time and again. Apart from a very good chance early on we did nothing whilst Rudd, despite his two clangers, made some good saves to restrict the damage.

Where my report differs is that I was not as impressed as other posters about our second half performance. Yes we were better but that really was not difficult. I would also argue that Peterborough didn't bother second half but rather content with the two goal lead. Although we hit the bar twice our general play was still poor and never really looked like turning round the deficit. That said, I thought the three subs had positive effects on the team which is something I don't think we have had the luxury of in the past few years. All 3 should be pushing for starts next time out.

Big wake up call I think. Peterborough looked a level or two up from us and will be top two come the end of the season in my opinion. Hope it's just a blip but there were some really worrying signs out there for me. The only real positives were Bailey Wright and Tom Clarke who I thought had decent games.

Special mention for a piss poor ref and one of the worst football grounds/atmospheres I've witnessed. Oh, and £28 for a ticket!!

Ratings -

Rudd - 5 (uncharacteristic errors)
Clarke - 7 (didn't really put a foot wrong at the back)
Huntington - 6 (his starting position/reading of the game worries me)
Wright - 8 (MOM)
Laird - 6 (solid enough at the back, didn't have his best game going forward)
Humphrey - 4 (did well to look awful in a very poor team performance)
Byrom - 4 (did well to look awful in a very poor team performance)
Keane - 5 (I'm a fan but looked out of his depth against the Peterborough midfield today)
Hume - 4 (must have touched the ball 5 times in the first half)
Beavon - 5 (no service)
Davies - 5 (no service)

Subs

Welsh - 7 (positive effect on the game - took better control of midfield)
Wroe - 7 (tried his best to create)
Garner - 7 (very lively)


I know this wont be a popular report but just my opinion on proceedings.

Cheers guys some very good feedback with both good and bad things to take out of today. Definitely sounded like Welsh, Wroe and Garner did enough to get a shout in coming weeks
 
Interesting what you said about Clarke as he got absolutely slated on the radio by surf for his first half performance

I thought he and Wright coped with the onslaught coming through the midfield quite well. But it's all about opinions I guess.....
 
Lost in the middle of the park first half. Welsh made a difference second half as did Wroe - simply giving it to one of our players. The formation with with Hume will work in games we dominate but not when there is a battle to win in the middle. Any of Keane, Hume or Byrom could have gone off. The defence was to often exposed. That said both goals avoidable and enough in the second half to make me remain confident. Probably now the start of Welsh's run in the starting line up.
 
Wrong starting line up (and yes I know its wise after the event) but DF obviously had done some research on our standard formation and simply outplayed us in the middle of the pitch, they gave their strikers plenty of chances by playing through us, and for anyone who still thinks Byrom is worth his place in the middle, give your head a wobble.

Laird had is poorest game since his return and was embarrassing when diving for free kicks after not being able to beat his man AGAIN and AGAIN, Hume was never in the game but hardly got any service at all much the same as Beavon and Davies first half. Wright did a great job after picking up a soft booking early on, he had to cover at times for Huntington who was caught for pace a couple of times, Clarke was no great shakes defensivley either first half and didn't look very composed when on the ball. Keane looked a little lost and on his own first half but you cannot fault his determination as was shown second hald when he chased back and made a fantastic tackle in the box on their very quick striker, looked much more composed alongside Welsh.

Second half we had 2 ten minute spells where we were all over them but just couldn't get a goal that I am sure would have led to at least another, Wroe did well as did Welsh who made a real impact and this brought Humphrey more into the game also, some good crosses and a very good shot form him, all in all a decent game but a poor starting formation and two howlers from Rudd.

Rudd, 3, his howlers early on were not made up for by a couple of great saves
Clarke 4, looked uncomfortable in this position against good players
Huntington 5, his pace is a concern
Wright 8, thank god for him

Humphrey 6, much better second half
Keane 6, much better with Welsh beside him, not a natural captain though!!
Byrom 3, one good tackle apart he was absent yet again
Laird 4, very poor going forward, stop bloody diving man

Beavon 5, much better second half with some service
Davies 7, this guy is a class act, just a pity some playing with him are so far below him.
Hume 4, tried but did very little

Subs;
Welsh 7, made a real impact and brought Humphrey much more into the game
Wroe 7, welcome back son
Garner 5, again buzzed about and could have scored.

Grayson 1st half 2, second half 7.

Fans 10, and happy 72nd birthday to Madge.
 
Thanks, Billy for the post - couldn't get today - bit too far and a bit too much on.
Won't do us any harm as we'll still be well there when we need to be I'm sure!
All the best from West Cumbria!!
 
Just got in myself.

First half was largely as described by the other posters - very much men against boys. Peterborough were quick, full of energy and looked a team full of very good footballers. Scafry to think they had 1 or two players out. Dare I say it but Ferguson tactically outclassed Grayson as we were completely overran in midfield with Byrom and Keane anonymous throughout resulting in us humping 60 yard balls up to the isolated Davies and Beavon time and again. Apart from a very good chance early on we did nothing whilst Rudd, despite his two clangers, made some good saves to restrict the damage.

Where my report differs is that I was not as impressed as other posters about our second half performance. Yes we were better but that really was not difficult. I would also argue that Peterborough didn't bother second half but rather content with the two goal lead. Although we hit the bar twice our general play was still poor and never really looked like turning round the deficit. That said, I thought the three subs had positive effects on the team which is something I don't think we have had the luxury of in the past few years. All 3 should be pushing for starts next time out.

Big wake up call I think. Peterborough looked a level or two up from us and will be top two come the end of the season in my opinion. Hope it's just a blip but there were some really worrying signs out there for me. The only real positives were Bailey Wright and Tom Clarke who I thought had decent games.

Special mention for a piss poor ref and one of the worst football grounds/atmospheres I've witnessed. Oh, and £28 for a ticket!!

Ratings -

Rudd - 5 (uncharacteristic errors)
Clarke - 7 (didn't really put a foot wrong at the back)
Huntington - 6 (his starting position/reading of the game worries me)
Wright - 8 (MOM)
Laird - 6 (solid enough at the back, didn't have his best game going forward)
Humphrey - 4 (did well to look awful in a very poor team performance)
Byrom - 4 (did well to look awful in a very poor team performance)
Keane - 5 (I'm a fan but looked out of his depth against the Peterborough midfield today)
Hume - 4 (must have touched the ball 5 times in the first half)
Beavon - 5 (no service)
Davies - 5 (no service)

Subs

Welsh - 7 (positive effect on the game - took better control of midfield)
Wroe - 7 (tried his best to create)
Garner - 7 (very lively)


I know this wont be a popular report but just my opinion on proceedings.

Disagree with some of the things you say. I thought Humphrey did ok. Not brilliant but certainly not deserving of a 4. He was often left with little options especially first half. His pace worried them although his decision making let him down a little.
 
Disagree with some of the things you say. I thought Humphrey did ok. Not brilliant but certainly not deserving of a 4. He was often left with little options especially first half. His pace worried them although his decision making let him down a little.

Any pace he does have he does not exploit as he takes the ball far to close to the byline before trying to go down the outside of his man. I'd like to see him be a bit more direct and push it past his man early and turn it into a foot race for the ball. Not sure many LB's in this league would beat him for pace.

I thought he was very poor today. But as I said above, it's all about opinions.
 
Wrong starting line up (and yes I know its wise after the event) but DF obviously had done some research on our standard formation and simply outplayed us in the middle of the pitch, they gave their strikers plenty of chances by playing through us, and for anyone who still thinks Byrom is worth his place in the middle, give your head a wobble.

Laird had is poorest game since his return and was embarrassing when diving for free kicks after not being able to beat his man AGAIN and AGAIN, Hume was never in the game but hardly got any service at all much the same as Beavon and Davies first half. Wright did a great job after picking up a soft booking early on, he had to cover at times for Huntington who was caught for pace a couple of times, Clarke was no great shakes defensivley either first half and didn't look very composed when on the ball. Keane looked a little lost and on his own first half but you cannot fault his determination as was shown second hald when he chased back and made a fantastic tackle in the box on their very quick striker, looked much more composed alongside Welsh.

Second half we had 2 ten minute spells where we were all over them but just couldn't get a goal that I am sure would have led to at least another, Wroe did well as did Welsh who made a real impact and this brought Humphrey more into the game also, some good crosses and a very good shot form him, all in all a decent game but a poor starting formation and two howlers from Rudd.

Rudd, 3, his howlers early on were not made up for by a couple of great saves
Clarke 4, looked uncomfortable in this position against good players
Huntington 5, his pace is a concern
Wright 8, thank god for him

Humphrey 6, much better second half
Keane 6, much better with Welsh beside him, not a natural captain though!!
Byrom 3, one good tackle apart he was absent yet again
Laird 4, very poor going forward, stop bloody diving man

Beavon 5, much better second half with some service
Davies 7, this guy is a class act, just a pity some playing with him are so far below him.
Hume 4, tried but did very little

Subs;
Welsh 7, made a real impact and brought Humphrey much more into the game
Wroe 7, welcome back son
Garner 5, again buzzed about and could have scored.

Grayson 1st half 2, second half 7.

Fans 10, and happy 72nd birthday to Madge.

Sounds pretty much as it was fed back on the radio. Especially the point that Laird kept trying to take on his man by megging him then diving when couldn't get past. And Fergie Jnr had done his home work as they said that they knew that Davies would win the headers but they won all the second balls. And Welsh and Wroe did enough to get a start.

Maybe it was a game like today that two defensive midfielders would work.

Fans agree 10/10 nice one
 
Thanks, Billy for the post - couldn't get today - bit too far and a bit too much on.
Won't do us any harm as we'll still be well there when we need to be I'm sure!
All the best from West Cumbria!!

see thee soon oshor, maybe a wee lesson for our manager on team selection.
 
Back
Top