Skip to main content

Just got back

Just got back

Grayson's logic is truly baffling at times (okay, most of the time). We need a goal in the final few minutes of the game, so he brings on the useless excuse for a striker who hasn't scored in over a year. Genius. 😱


Excellent OP thanks Thracia.

As for the point about Buchanan/SKD substitution costing us the game... OK. But on the face of it, at 1-1, I think most people would be delighted that Grayson took off a defender to bolster the attack.

It didn't come off, but SKD does add something to the attack (even if it's not goals for himself!).... but I would rather lose "going for it" rather than ending up with a safe draw.
 
Did the 515 get free pies and a drink?
No we bloody didn't! Although I did forget to mention the highlight of the day - the pies were really good. 🙂

What are your thoughts on Grayson? Keep with him or get shut? Have to admit I've finally lost patience - only scraping to draws and a defeat to the bottom sides is completely unacceptable IMO.
I deliberately tried not to go there with this post, because there's tons of other threads talking about that! - but it's looking pretty bleak. I remember looking at the fixtures at the start of January and thinking we could really push on here, while Sheff Utd could have a really difficult month - and of course, the complete opposite has happened!

What might save him (beyond an amazing turnaround of form) is (a) some amazing signings on Monday, and/or (b) a win on Tuesday night - due to the riches that would bring us. So I'd like to wait and see what happens there first. Not holding out any high hopes after today though, obviously.

And I could easily see him become a "dead man walking", keeping the job until the summer even if he signs no one and loses on Tuesday, because the owner might decide there's no real point getting a new manager when the transfer window is shut, so we might as well let SG see the season out, in the vain hope that we can maybe scrape through the play-offs.

We are one dimensional in attack. Ball out wide presumably with intention of crossing in but no one to meet crosses. We never split the defence, nor do we have the option of a forward laying off to another forward because we don't have anyone near the lone forward.
Yep - and everything looked so rushed and uncertain, which contributed to the problem of having no one in position when we needed them there.

As for the point about Buchanan/SKD substitution costing us the game... OK. But on the face of it, at 1-1, I think most people would be delighted that Grayson took off a defender to bolster the attack.

It didn't come off, but SKD does add something to the attack (even if it's not goals for himself!).... but I would rather lose "going for it" rather than ending up with a safe draw.
I see what you mean, but it didn't feel (to me) like we were going for it (I don't think we had another attack worthy of note, whereas Crawley had several!) - it just felt like a really strange and unnecessary idea at that point.

Maybe that's just because it was SKD, I don't know!
 
I was there today as well Thracia , can not disagree with anything you said great report.

I would like to know what Grayson said after we scored though as i thought we were going to go on and win? . We were well on top at that point and seemed to go back as if we were playing for a draw. Very puzzling to me.
 
Last edited:
I was there today as well Thracia , can not disagree with anything you said great report.

I would like to know what Grason said after we scored though as i thought we were going to go on and win? . We were well on top at that point and seemed to go back as if we were playing for a draw. Very puzzling to me.

Sadly, rob, I predicted as much on the matchday thread. I was following the stats on the BBC site, up to scoring, in the 55th minute, wed had 9 attempts and the goal was our 4th on target. After we scored we had 1 single attempt thats all. Was it case of instructions from the bench?
 
Sadly, rob, I predicted as much on the matchday thread. I was following the stats on the BBC site, up to scoring, in the 55th minute, wed had 9 attempts and the goal was our 4th on target. After we scored we had 1 single attempt thats all. Was it case of instructions from the bench?

Kilkenny was on the pitch then, nothing else needs saying.
 
Thanks Thracia - that has saved me the trouble of writing just about exactly the same thing except that the whole experience was so dismal I am not certain I would have had the willpower.

I'll add a few things. Both Buchanan and Welsh were lamentable. Buchanan lacks strength in the tackle, invention, pace, height, shooting ability, almost any ability at all with his right foot and concentration - that is the second time in a just four matches where he has lot possession in a way that has led straight to a goal for the opposition. He scurries about and looks busy but is increasingly a liability. Laird should be restored to the left-back position and frankly I would rather have King as back-up. Once the loan window re-opens we should perhaps be looking for a strong, pacy left-back. Buchanan should be told he is free to look for another club. What really rubbed salt in the wound was that incident late-on more or less right in front of me where the Crawley left-back dispossed Reid while on the ground and then played a superb cross-field ball to their centre forward.

Welsh has been a fine servant of the club but he has been in visible decline since the start of last season. He is now past any use for us and again should be told he is free to look for another club.

As you say - and as I have been saying for some time - we lack leadership, drive, assertiveness and authority in the centre of midfield. That is the fundamental problem that needs addressing.
 
We are one dimensional in attack. Ball out wide presumably with intention of crossing in but no one to meet crosses. We never split the defence, nor do we have the option of a forward laying off to another forward because we don't have anyone near the lone forward.

Exactly.
 
Sadly, rob, I predicted as much on the matchday thread. I was following the stats on the BBC site, up to scoring, in the 55th minute, wed had 9 attempts and the goal was our 4th on target. After we scored we had 1 single attempt thats all. Was it case of instructions from the bench?

Something not right somewhere Raefil . The only positives for me were Gallager was the best player on the pitch , Johnson showed touches of class at times but seemed a bit afraid to shoot when he had the chance hopefully that will come . Johnstone in goal looked nervous to me ,but could do nothing about the goals. Looks like its the playoffs again if we are lucky .
 
Well, I don't live far away. 🙂 Just my thoughts on today's efforts, before I read everyone else's.

First, this was a shocking result, woeful first half performance, second half we started brightly then faded away.

I think our main problem is a lack of leadership and no one to dictate the tempo of our play.

Our positive play is sporadic, there is no sustained pressure, and we never seem to be fully in control of things.

To go through some of the the individuals today: Johnstone didn't seem to have much chance with the goals, and Crawley didn't do much else - he saved a late free kick but his kicking seemed a bit wayward.

In the first half, the defence played some shocking balls between themselves and towards midfield, particularly the full backs and Huntington, who IMO is nowhere near as good as some would have us believe on here. Buchanan was obviously culpable for losing posession in the lead-up to the first and only shot/goal of the first half. He didn't have a good game.

Midfield during the first half was disorganised, the middle 3 seemed to rotate among themselves as to who was playing the defensive role, and this just caused confusion. Reid was the only real "outlet" but was rarely found, then tended to be wasteful. Gallagher did some things well, but other things very poorly, apparently at random. Too many of our forward balls were launched into spaces containing no PNE players within yards.

Up front, SEB worked really hard, but needed to head his only half-chance of the first half rather than chesting it down and overhead kicking it. I was impressed with his hold-up play overall though, he isn't just a "fill-in" and looks a far better player than SKD, for example - but he ideally needs a partner, or a midfield foil who is on his wavelength.

In the second half we were immediately better, and our best spell was the one leading up to our goal.

Johnson came into the game more, and showed some glimpses of real quality - his general play was good, and he, SEB and Reid, along with Gallagher occasionally, played some nice passing stuff between themselves during our best spell.

Kilkenny (on at HT) is better than Welsh at maintaining some midfield discipline, but unfortunately he is not as good at defending, and several times - particularly late on - Crawley carved us wide open with a simple long ball.

We need to get to a stage where neither Kilkenny or Welsh is starting for us, which means we need a new recruit who can do both their jobs - I believe this is not asking too much.

After we scored, we took our foot off the gas - this is where we need someone in midfield to show leadership and maintain our tempo. No one in the current squad can do this.

Brownhill came close to scoring a second for us, and it looked like he only needed to throw himself at the ball and it would be a certain goal, instead he chose to stay on his feet, or didn't quite anticipate the cross correctly. He didn't have a very effective game, a lot of the stray midfield passes in the first half were down to him.

When he came on, Humphrey demonstrated the one thing he seems to be good at - running fast - and the various things he isn't very good at - crossing, passing, shooting with his left foot (it actually looked close, but he just shouldn't be doing it!), etc.

The SKD for Buchanan substitution was mystifying, and ultimately cost us a point. SKD had no impact on the game at all, then we conceded.

Overall, it was pretty poor fare, and I don't think this team is going anywhere but the play-offs without a pair of genuine killer signings before the window closes.

Otherwise, and assuming the play-offs pan out the way we all expect, then I think the squad needs to lose a lot of deadwood in the summer - I'm struggling to think of anyone who's out of contract who's a certainty to be retained, but maybe there's one, the rest can probably go - and we need to go again with quality across the board, not just in glimpses here and there.

Great post Thracia
 
Very good OP. It would be equally interesting to know how SG might respond to it, but as Thracia is not part of the media pack, I guess we'll never find out. Does SG view here?
 
Are you for real or are you SG? Garner on his own up front still probably would not have won us the game using the current formation and tactics

Yes I'm for real. Were you there? Numerous times the ball was played into the box but Blake is a yard off the pace
 
I was there today as well Thracia , can not disagree with anything you said great report.

I would like to know what Grayson said after we scored though as i thought we were going to go on and win? . We were well on top at that point and seemed to go back as if we were playing for a draw. Very puzzling to me.

Agree we were excellent for 10 mins then suddenly reverted to type
 
I was there and think the OP has it spot on.
My two main observations from the game are :-1 why when at the start of the second half when we scored did we not just keep playing the same way? It was as if SG was playing for a point when they were there for the taking.
2. Did SEB head the ball at all? He can't jump more than a few inches off the ground and when he did his head missed the ball by miles.
 
The reality needs to be faced that most of our players are very ordinary, our rivals wouldn't want any of them, Garner and Gallagher excepted.

Grayson has run out of ideas and options.

The inability to recognise what is his best formation is scary, because we don't have one, just a bunch of very very standard players with no inspirational leadership.
 
The SKD for Buchanan substitution was mystifying, and ultimately cost us a point. SKD had no impact on the game at all, then we conceded.

Though I disagree about that point Thracia. On Tuesday we were all saying we needed an extra up front and yesterday he did that presumably with the idea of going for it. Now it didn't come off, but I don't think SG can be criticised for at least shifting the focus from defence to attack.
 
Though I disagree about that point Thracia. On Tuesday we were all saying we needed an extra up front and yesterday he did that presumably with the idea of going for it. Now it didn't come off, but I don't think SG can be criticised for at least shifting the focus from defence to attack.
Fair enough JC - Regardless said something similar above, so I guess I'm in the minority. 🙂

The problem wasn't "so much" the 1-up-front yesterday IMO - because we were playing well with it at the start of the second half.

As a few others have also said, as soon as we scored we seemed to suddenly stop playing well, and never regained momentum. That might be why I didn't expect SKD to change anything when he came on.
 
Back
Top