Skip to main content

Keane and Welsh

Keane and Welsh

Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
17,366
Location
The desert
Didn't work at the start of the season and doesn't work now. I know we have no better midfielders but unless we address this position we will drop too many silly points and not win the big games.

I thought we could get away with it in the 5-3-2 formation but today the 4-4-2 was stagnant and wasted Gallagher out wide.

I like Keane and Welsh and think Welsh is the better footballer but we will struggle to score if they start in midfield together.

Anyway onwards and upwards
 
I agree I can't believe how we've drifted back into playing them along side each other. Both pretty poor today IMO. Both played like Pele in comparison to Humphrey though.
 
Poor midfield AGAIN today.
One quality pass in 90 mins Gallagher to Keane

Don't worry we've just signed a 19 year old lad from Cork City who will save us in January. In the mean time we can throw in 17 year old Brownhill to do the business.

Keep up the good work Mr Chairman.
 
Either of them with King would be better. But if we do have these in the centre then we need some pace and creativity wide of them. The players to provide that - in a 4.4.2 - are Holmes and Hayhurst.
 
Last edited:
One or the other for me, both need partnering with a more attackingly capable player, ie Wroe Welsh last season. Probably why we've no creativity in the middle when we've got two 'get stuck inners' there
 
Can't both play together at Deepdale. Could away though.

Agree totally with that.
At home has to be just one or the other, preferably Welsh for me.
You do need some defensive cover, a ball winner to protect the back 4 but at Deepdale that should just be the one, and then we take the game to the opposition.
 
Agree totally with that.
At home has to be just one or the other, preferably Welsh for me.
You do need some defensive cover, a ball winner to protect the back 4 but at Deepdale that should just be the one, and then we take the game to the opposition.

Welsh.

Too slow.
Too ponderous.
Too negative.
Zero creativity and imaginative passing ability.

But if that's your bag...
 
Welsh.

Too slow.
Too ponderous.
Too negative.
Zero creativity and imaginative passing ability.

But if that's your bag...

We are talking about a choice between the two:
- not sure Keane offers any of the qualities you list that much better than Welsh, even if he is Your preferred choice!
Personally don't see too much between them on those criteria.
 
We are talking about a choice between the two:
- not sure Keane offers any of the qualities you list that much better than Welsh, even if he is Your preferred choice!
Personally don't see too much between them on those criteria.


Keane is slightly better which isn't saying much...noticed how dire we are again at Deepdale with Welsh back in the team compared to when he was dropped?

Of course, I got slated by 95% of the posters on here last time I started a thread on this very subject, which now shows some truth, even to the blind on here, in what I posted, but tell me...it's no coincidence how poor we are at home with Welsh in the team...and I include last season in this.
 
Keane is slightly better which isn't saying much...noticed how dire we are again at Deepdale with Welsh back in the team compared to when he was dropped?

Of course, I got slated by 95% of the posters on here last time I started a thread on this very subject, which now shows some truth, even to the blind on here, in what I posted, but tell me...it's no coincidence how poor we are at home with Welsh in the team...and I include last season in this.

Which is why we need just one or the other of them purely as the ball winner to make a simple pass to 2 or 3 other better creative midfielders. And that is where we are lacking. players like Keane and Welsh are what they are, but they fall short if they are also asked to provide the creative spark
 
Which is why we need just one or the other of them purely as the ball winner to make a simple pass to 2 or 3 other better creative midfielders. And that is where we are lacking. players like Keane and Welsh are what they are, but they fall short if they are also asked to provide the creative spark

Sadly, I agree.

We require better though.

Over to Simon and Trev.
 
Would have been ok had we played 3-5-2 and put Gallagher in with them. In a 4-4-2 at home they just don't work together. Time for Keane to be rested in my opinion. A lot of people are calling for King to play in there with one of them. I'm not so sure that this is the answer, as I can't really remember too much of King as a midfielder, but why not give it a go?
 
Away from home the pairing of the two of them is perfectly fine but at home it just isn't working especially if we concede the first goal.
 
I have to laugh at the posters who think that King is the answer to our midfield problems, prior to signing for us he had 8 seasons in non league footy, he has hardly played in the midfield for us since arriving and the odd "hollywood pass" apart has offered nothing as a midfielder to suggest he can play this position.

Keane is a flat footed right back who for some reason has Grayson favour as our first pick midfielder, I would much rather see Brownhill played beside Welsh or even JD's hero Gally played beside Welsh in the middle of a traditional 442, the only downside to playing Gallagher is his lack of desire when it comes to tackling!!!
 
Back
Top