Skip to main content

keane & Holmes ?

keane & Holmes ?

Joined
Jul 30, 2009
Messages
17,283
Location
Cheshire
What are peoples opinions on the chances of both Keane & Holmes leaving before next Monday night either joining another club whether its a loan or on a free Transfer or maybe being paid Up? I ask the question because although there they've are good people & served a purpose in my opinion they need a fresh challenge for themselves & for the club to move on?
 
Last edited:
What are peoples opinions on the chances of both Keane & Holmes leaving before next Monday night either joining another club whether its a loan or on a free Transfer or maybe being paid Up? I ask the question because although there they've are good people & served a purpose in my opinion they need a fresh challenge for themselves & for the club to move on?

Keane served a purpose but Holmes was shite, waste of space.

I imagine if it's proving really difficult to loan them out they'll pay them up.
 
Holmes was our 3rd highest assist maker last season.

The reality is that if we are serious about chasing automatic promotion then we can't carry players like Holmes.

He isn't good enough. The final straw was the Play-Off first leg last season.

Grayson clearly knows he's not good enough, hence why he's trying to offload him?
 
Lee Holmes is nowhere near as crap as some on here make out. Plus he always played on the right under Grayson, which was nonsense.

Over a full season i'd expect him to set up and score more than Kyel Reid anyway.

That said, him and Keane are both well out of favour so it's time to move on.
 
Lee Holmes is nowhere near as crap as some on here make out. Plus he always played on the right under Grayson, which was nonsense.

Over a full season i'd expect him to set up and score more than Kyel Reid anyway.

That said, him and Keane are both well out of favour so it's time to move on.

Is he good enough for an automatic promotion chasing side though?

For what it's worth, I don't think Reid is either but that's no the point.
 
The reality is that if we are serious about chasing automatic promotion then we can't carry players like Holmes.

He isn't good enough. The final straw was the Play-Off first leg last season.

Grayson clearly knows he's not good enough, hence why he's trying to offload him?

Agree & in my opinion it comes back to the same old question which is why did we give those 11 or 12 players new contracts, SG response was that it was out of loyalty I think that he regrets it now?
 
Is he good enough for an automatic promotion chasing side though?

For what it's worth, I don't think Reid is either but that's no the point.

I agree with Holmes I think he is past it, I just thought I would throw that stat out there.

Reid however, is just coming back from a series injury and starting to show what an asset he can be. Has played really well in the last couple of games and constantly beats his man and can put in a dangerous cross I just think he needs to be less greedy.
 
I think Reid has shown enough to say that when he is back to full fitness he will be a real asset.
He is a positive player who actually wants to run at and beat his full back. Something our wingers of recent times have seemed unwilling or unable to do.
 
I've heard Keane will be moved on this week.

To be honest I asked Keane On Sat if he be here this time next week & he said that the odds will be more likely that he wont be here, but you never know in football on will happen Doesn't hold any grudges if he did leave because that's football for you he said but would like to stay?
 
both have served a purpose and neither have let the club down but we have clearly moved on and its time they maybe did the same
 
People who say reid is not promotion quality need to look closer. He's getting better all the time and he's a danger on that left wing. Good addition in my eyes and i cant wait to see him fully fit. He's been exceptional in the last three games.
 
keane & Holmes ?

I agree with Holmes I think he is past it, I just thought I would throw that stat out there.

Reid however, is just coming back from a series injury and starting to show what an asset he can be. Has played really well in the last couple of games and constantly beats his man and can put in a dangerous cross I just think he needs to be less greedy.

I don't mind Reid but I think he's too inconsistent and doesn't put his head up. Decent player to have though.

Preferred Robinson on the left and to be honest I can see us signing another winger or two in the window, with Hayhurst and Holmes being binned, and Robinson seemingly not coming back.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top