Skip to main content

Keane leaving maybe?

Keane leaving maybe?

Joined
Jul 30, 2009
Messages
17,283
Location
Cheshire
I Know that its wishful thinking on my part, but wouldn't it be great if Keith Curle was describing Keane in this below article taken from the Sky Sports website via the Transfer section when he's describing a 28 year old experience combative Midfielder?

Carlisle United manager Keith Curle has revealed he is in talks to bring two experienced players to the club in January.

“We are looking for a bit of experience to add to the mix,” he told the club’s official website. “There’s a 31-year old striker I’m looking at and a 28-year old combative midfield player.

“They have a little bit of know-how and they are both good, strong characters. That’s exactly what I need. They know their roles and responsibilities in the team, and in the changing room, and that’s another thing we need. They’re leaders and good people.

“I have an ongoing list of players who have come to mind and who we are considering. I think it was at seven at one point last week, but that changes as and when they go to other football clubs
 
If getting rid of Keane and Holmes enables us to bring in one quality midfielder who improves the starting eleven then it has to be done.

I wouldn't be disappointed to see King leave as well but can't see that one.
 
No

I'd rather Keane was in the squad and playing

I'd rather davies, king and a couple of others left before him

We would have more points on the board if keane hadn't been out on loan when we were missing a right back for 4 games.

We'd likely have more points on the board if we didnt have davies and had a striker who knew where the net was.
 
People complain we look slow when Welsh and Kilkenny play together. We would be even slower with Keane playing. He will be off this month, as will Holmes. Good lads, but not good enough for a promotion chasing side in this league.
 
No, I'd rather Keane was in the squad and playing.
I think you are remembering Keane far too fondly. Under westley he impressed at times because he was surrounded by league two and non league players playing a style of football which was all about tackles, throw ins and free kicks, rather than carving out openings or playing actual football. But he picked up yellow cards for fun and gave fouls away like crazy. Under Grayson he was quickly found out to be simply not good enough. You cant dive into challenges on the edge of the box all the time. I am sorry but Keane has to go. As a rightback he wouldnt have got us more points on the board at all IMHO. But we would of got some practice at playing with 10 men I guess. I hope hes offloaded asap.
 
I think you are remembering Keane far too fondly. Under westley he impressed at times because he was surrounded by league two and non league players playing a style of football which was all about tackles, throw ins and free kicks, rather than carving out openings or playing actual football. But he picked up yellow cards for fun and gave fouls away like crazy. Under Grayson he was quickly found out to be simply not good enough. You cant dive into challenges on the edge of the box all the time. I am sorry but Keane has to go. As a rightback he wouldnt have got us more points on the board at all IMHO. But we would of got some practice at playing with 10 men I guess. I hope hes offloaded asap.

Let's be honest. Until Keane got injured under Westley, we were actually playing some good football and getting good results. He was also surrounded by a starting eleven not far removed from what we have now. Stuckmann, Laird, Huntington, Wright and Welsh.
 
I Know that its wishful thinking on my part, but wouldn't it be great if Keith Curle was describing Keane in this below article taken from the Sky Sports website via the Transfer section when he's describing a 28 year old experience combative Midfielder?

Carlisle United manager Keith Curle has revealed he is in talks to bring two experienced players to the club in January.

“We are looking for a bit of experience to add to the mix,” he told the club’s official website. “There’s a 31-year old striker I’m looking at and a 28-year old combative midfield player.

“They have a little bit of know-how and they are both good, strong characters. That’s exactly what I need. They know their roles and responsibilities in the team, and in the changing room, and that’s another thing we need. They’re leaders and good people.

“I have an ongoing list of players who have come to mind and who we are considering. I think it was at seven at one point last week, but that changes as and when they go to other football clubs

Probably is Keane. Crawley were keen on bringing him back before Gregory left the managers job.
 
I am fond of Keane but to see him leave would be a good thing imo, he clearly has no place here now. The same can be said for Hayhurst, Holmes and now Jones. Looks like Hayhurst is off to County, if we can shift Jones and somehow move Keane on it would be a successful window. I am not sure about Holmes, is he at Pompey for the rest of the season?
 
Let's be honest. Until Keane got injured under Westley, we were actually playing some good football and getting good results. He was also surrounded by a starting eleven not far removed from what we have now. Stuckmann, Laird, Huntington, Wright and Welsh.
Good results with Keane in the team? I recall us being able to beat Yeovil, Scunthorpe and Stevenage in the months prior to Keanes injury. Are those the good results you refer to? Simonsen was in nets most of the time then. And we had the likes of Robertson, Wroe and Beardsley in the spine of the team. And most of these rejects are all now playing at a lower level. As for good football... westleys brand was the most excruciating tedium I have ever witnessed. Can't believe you wanna defend that shite.
 
Let's be honest. Until Keane got injured under Westley, we were actually playing some good football and getting good results.
Keane was in the team for the first 2 months of the club's record run without a home league win that season.

The terrible home form spread to the away form too when Keane and Laird were injured, but I'm not sure when the good football and good results took place.

I think Keane's biggest achievement pre-injury was racking up 9 yellow cards in 19 games - a feat he bettered this term with 9 yellow cards in just 15 games for Crawley.

He was also surrounded by a starting eleven not far removed from what we have now. Stuckmann, Laird, Huntington, Wright and Welsh.
To be fair, it was more like Simonsen, Laird, Huntington, Robertson and Welsh - all defensive players I notice.

Our starting XI now is quite far removed from Team Westley at its "peak".
 
Good results with Keane in the team? I recall us being able to beat Yeovil, Scunthorpe and Stevenage in the months prior to Keanes injury. Are those the good results you refer to? Simonsen was in nets most of the time then. And we had the likes of Robertson, Wroe and Beardsley in the spine of the team. And most of these rejects are all now playing at a lower level. As for good football... westleys brand was the most excruciating tedium I have ever witnessed. Can't believe you wanna defend that shite.

I wouldn't dream to defend the majority of Westley's reign. However, the start to that season up until the game were both Laird and Keane got injured, saw us play some great football and pick up some good results.

The same squad managed to have a good points return under Grayson later on in that season. A points total that at one point would have seen us reach the playoffs had it been an average accumulation throughout a full season.

So, I wouldnt suggest Keane is now suddenly out of his depth.
 
saw us play some great football and pick up some good results.
What good results do you refer to? Is it just the mighty wins versus Yeovil, Scunthorpe and Stevenage? What about all those draws and defeats. As for 'great football' you have lost me there. Keane was a headcase who picked up a yellow every other game and gave away dangerous freekicks which cost us time and time again.
 
5-0 over Hartlepool and 4-1 over Swindon are the standout performances to add to that list. Beating both Palace and Huddersfield in the league cup. As well as getting through in the jpt during that period.

I'm not saying we were consistent, how could we be with a team that'd just been put together? But to make it out that our best eleven then was comprised of players far inferior to what we have now is pretty juvenile.
 
5-0 over Hartlepool and 4-1 over Swindon are the standout performances to add to that list. Beating both Palace and Huddersfield in the league cup. As well as getting through in the jpt during that period.
Yeah 5-0 against Hartlepool when Keane was not in the team nor on the bench. I guess in his own little way he made an impact. he was doubtless suspended. Our starting XI back then would get absolutly battered by the team we have now.
 
How many teams have we battered this season?

It's not a case of whether Keane started every game, as your point was that he looked good next to the rest of that team. I'm trying to highlight the fact that the best eleven from that period isn't that far removed from what we have now. So Keane wouldn't be as out of place as you were suggesting.
 
This threads about Keith Keane. You said we were playing good football up until he got injured. You want to claim 5-0 hammerings when he didnt play as evidence of this. I dont see how that is acceptable. We beat two teams in the league cup who looked totally disinterested in being in the competition. The 'good results' you alude to just dont exist in terms of the league results from august to keanes injury in mid november. Keane was a limited footballer. He still is. He has no place in the side we have now which like it or not is much stronger than Westleys team of 'winners' in 2012-13.
 
This threads about Keith Keane. You said we were playing good football up until he got injured. You want to claim 5-0 hammerings when he didnt play as evidence of this. I dont see how that is acceptable. We beat two teams in the league cup who looked totally disinterested in being in the competition. The 'good results' you alude to just dont exist in terms of the league results from august to keanes injury in mid november. Keane was a limited footballer. He still is. He has no place in the side we have now which like it or not is much stronger than Westleys team of 'winners' in 2012-13.

I completely disagree.
 
How many teams have we battered this season?

It's not a case of whether Keane started every game, as your point was that he looked good next to the rest of that team. I'm trying to highlight the fact that the best eleven from that period isn't that far removed from what we have now. So Keane wouldn't be as out of place as you were suggesting.

We played some very good stuff up until the County game when Laird was butchered... And prior to that Keane played a big part at right back and played very well...... Sorry I can't back you up with tiresome stats but we were far from shite whatever anyone says.. In fact it was the two fullbacks getting injured that sent Westley round the bend with ridiculous team selections and weekly changes... It was at that point he lost the plot ( cue those that claim he never had one ) 🙂
 
Back
Top